Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
94
/100
Reviews
4
professional
Vintages
1
2005
Other
94/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
77
Reviews
94.0
Avg Score
95
Highest
Taster #2107
· Feb 9, 2025
This was pretty, but not as expressive as I would have hoped. The aromatics were appealing, somewhat muted compared to the otherworldly 2002. Palate was similar, enjoyable but feeling like it was holding back. Could just be this bottle, or could be 2005 structure needing more time to unwind.
2005 vintage
Taster #2026
· Dec 4, 2024
94/100
Poured from magnum — this was a powerful, dark and rich bottle of Mugnier! Very tasty, but lacking some of Mugnier’s signature elegance and perfumed aromatics.
2005 vintage
Taster #3123
· Feb 26, 2023
95/100
Pure joy here. Sexy, strawberry fields forver, very open, good depth, spice, seamless harmony. Surprisingly open. Loving it, seems quite young still. #Peytz&Co
2005 vintage
Taster #8394
· Apr 15, 2021
92/100
Bit surprised, disappointed that it lacked the electricity and purity of 2005 Musigny or even Fuees.
2005 vintage
Taster #0905
· Apr 27, 2019
95/100
Two bottles opened, from separate sources, yet very consistent notes. Deep, dark and full of flavor but not at all heavy. Very precise and focused fruit, tannins not overwhelming. You can taste the care that went into this wine. Drinks nicely now, but will certainly irove and be a 97 pt wine some day.
2005 vintage
Taster #3335
· Nov 17, 2014
I was lucky enough to have two different bottles of this, two days in a row. The first, decanted for an hour showed incredibly intense red fruits with absolutely laser precision. The second, decanted for 150 minutes, showed much smokier, spicier with distinct clove and cinnamon notes. We had the '05 Mugnier Musigny next to it, which showed relatively as something an intense fruit bomb (after 5 hours of air). To drink now: take the Bonnes Mares. To drink in …
2005 vintage
Taster #1958
· Jan 1, 2007
From cask: Medium blood red. Nose is intense and very solid with black fruits and a touch of violets. Really quite classy. Mouth entry is sappy and very together. Nice acidity here. Mid-palate shows good fruit though not the intensity of the Roumier, and a very stylish flavour. Well balanced. A staggeringly different rendition to the Roumier and, for me, classier. 5
2005 vintage