Siduri Pinot Noir Shaw Mountain Vineyard

Siduri

Other · Pinot Noir
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91 /100
Reviews
25
professional

Vintages

1
2004 Other 91/100
Pinot Noir
NV

Community Reviews

32
32
Reviews
90.5
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #4278 · Jul 21, 2016
93/100
Red cherry, strawberry, and rhubarb fruit with subtle earth and spice notes. Nice acidity and long smooth finish. Tasted during a blind vertical against the '05, '07, & '09 versions of this wine. I had this as time top wine!
2004 vintage
Taster #2760 · May 22, 2014
80/100
red, orange, in color. red fruit, toothpaste, on the nose. light acid, on the finish.
2004 vintage
Taster #2994 · Jun 29, 2013
91/100
PnP. Brownish garnet. Impressive fruit expression, showing a complex profile of cherry, earth, pine, floral and Asian spice note aromatically and on the palate. Quite a bright melange. Palate features a fuller round sensation rather than crunchy fruit, but definite presence of soft tannins and light acidity makes this very attractive. Night 2 - this wine is now an alcoholic mess, very 'hot'. Just checked and it's listed at 15%. I think the charm of the aging, complex fruit made …
2004 vintage
Taster #9111 · Nov 3, 2012
94/100
Easy to pick out as a Pisoni in a lineup. Color is starting to show its age, but the wine is still very youthful. Expressive aromatics, big and linear fruit with a pleasant and long finish. I've had good luck aging most Siduri Pinots and this was enjoyed when tasting against some "hot" '09s.
2004 vintage
Taster #4201 · May 26, 2012
Wine is a little disjointed, most prominent flavors are deep and dark, with cedar and anise notes around the edges. Good, but not great at this time. I may wait a year or so to see how secondary characteristics develop--the structure seems in place to allow aging further.
2004 vintage
Taster #4278 · Apr 25, 2012
92/100
Bold, tart, red cherry and strawberry fruit. Nice balance and acidity, long finish.
2004 vintage
Taster #1557 · Jan 1, 2012
92/100
I've had this wine several times during the past few years, and it's been a consistent performer. I'd thought the previous bottle was starting to reach its age limit, but I was wrong. This bottle--paired with beef tenderloins and sauce Bernaise--showed remarkable staying power. Huge fruit forward flavors of cherry (dominant) and cranberry (minor), with velvet-like forest undertones--mushrooms, cedar. Finishes with a bit of vanilla and a mild sweet note, but then the acidity kicks in to dry it all …
2004 vintage
Taster #4426 · Feb 14, 2011
Nose is showing it's age, but in the mouth its still quite fresh. Overall just ok, nothing special. I should have drunk this a year ago. Much less enjoyable than the 04 Pisoni estate drank a few weeks back which was still going strong.
2004 vintage
Taster #2188 · Nov 25, 2010
91/100
Translucent ruby red color. The nose straightforward with red cherry and a touch of oak. In the mouth, there is red cherry and cranberry with a little oak. The wine has solid acidity and no tannins. Overall, this was a very enjoyable wine with solid fruit and balanced acidity.
2004 vintage
Taster #2994 · Oct 2, 2010
89/100
PnP. Bright garnet (translucent). Dusty strawberry, cherry, floral/spice, earth on nose. Dancing medium light fruit, crisp acidity, mineral. Low complexity, some finesse. Really nice paired with food. Great expression of pinot but lacks that extra dimension of depth and complexity that excites.
2004 vintage
Taster #1557 · Mar 17, 2010
92/100
One of my bottles of this wine was slightly off, with some volatile alcohols. But this one was on its A game. Great fruit, cherry and a bit of cranberry. Good depth of flavors, with vanilla and cedar notes. Tannins have mellowed nicely. Acidity is a bit light for a food wine, but that's my only complaint. I'd say it's at or very near its peak now.
2004 vintage
Taster #9421 · Feb 15, 2010
92/100
Delicate, bright cherry. Weird fizzy thing initially..that was not unpleasant. Long finish. Great racy acidity. Balanced oak and mid palate. A bit of OR forest floor coming through. A fabulous wine. Smoked a 2004 Papapietro Perry Leras
2004 vintage
Taster #9562 · Oct 24, 2009
Overly tart and lacking the big complex Pisoni expression I'm used to from these. Rather simple at this point. Possibly better earlier in life but I don't have experience with this vintage for this bottling.
2004 vintage
Taster #7011 · Jun 19, 2009
Popped and poured, enjoyed over 2 hours. Dark fruits, baking spices and earth on the nose. Smooth and rich, showing great minerality, balance and acidity. Long finish. In a great place right now. Drink now and over the next 3-5 years.
2004 vintage
Taster #6697 · Jun 1, 2009
92/100
At the peak now, ripe fruit but not in your face. The alcohol is deceptively hidden beneath layers of fruit, some raspberries, dark/sour cherries and light oak
2004 vintage
Taster #2956 · Feb 10, 2009
15.0% alcohol. Extremely deep red color. Fragrant nose of blackberry, blueberry, spice, and minerals. A rich, fat, lush 2004, but without many of the sins of the vintage in the lesser wines. In the mouth, smooth and rich, with loads of blue and black fruits, spice, some flowers, and a good dose of minerals. Good acidity. Long finish that doesn't show any signs of heat. Nicely done and very drinkable. Not showing as much structure as a usual vintage. A-
2004 vintage
Taster #3289 · Dec 25, 2008
93/100
By far the best pisoni I have had. Went wonderful with the ribs with dinner. Spicy and rich. Just starting to enter its drinking window. Wonderful.
2004 vintage
Taster #9126 · Dec 20, 2008
92/100
So beautiful, drinks very well right now. Has morphed a bit toRussian River cola-like characteristics, but still balances well with fruit and a hint of spice. Nicely done, Adam and Gary!
2004 vintage
Taster #0171 · Nov 8, 2008
91/100
Decanted 1 hour.
2004 vintage
Taster #4956 · Oct 24, 2008
92/100
Consisent with all the prior praise. Drinking as beautifully as well. Last of my 6 pack, wish i had bought a case. This has tremendous structure.
2004 vintage
Taster #9742 · Oct 12, 2008
88/100
A very nice bottle of wine, but perhaps even more disappointing than my last bottle. Popped and poured at our club, it started out hot, though it did mellow in the glass. Seemed almost Russian River-like, with its cherry cola flavors and near-fizz mouthfeel. Certainly enjoyable, but neither the best of Siduri nor the best of Pisoni.
2004 vintage
Taster #6503 · Sep 15, 2008
92/100
Similar to previous tasting note.
2004 vintage
Taster #6503 · Aug 13, 2008
91/100
Tasty dark cherry and earthy aromas and flavors with pine needle notes on the pleasant finish.
2004 vintage
Taster #9742 · Jun 8, 2008
90/100
Wonderful wine from a wonderful producer and vineyard, but not the best I've had from either.
2004 vintage
Taster #1867 · Jun 8, 2008
87/100
Trip to Boston; 6/4/2008-6/9/2008 : completly out of place this night, like a syropy syrah, this was almoust not drinkable along with the other wines and the food. ripe, sugary-sweet, full powered... but lacking the balance of the finesse of pinot, nor possesing the rustic appeal of syrah. cant blame it too much but not my cup of anything.
2004 vintage
Taster #2487 · May 26, 2008
I know we enjoyed this a lot, just don't remember when it was that we drank it!
2004 vintage
Taster #7733 · Apr 7, 2008
90/100
Tasted along with Tantara 2004 Pisoni - slightly fruitier with less finesse on finish; A very nice bottle
2004 vintage
Taster #0568 · Feb 18, 2008
90/100
Dark red in the glass, suggesting a fair intensity. This wine needs time to breath; somewhat closed upon opening, after 1 hour it started to come around. Aromas of black raspberry, vanilla and a woodsy briar element. A good blast of fruit upon the entry, tending toward berry, and giving way to a nice complexity at mid palate. A velvety presence leads to a long finish. A little hot, but very lively. Not quite the flavor profile that I've enjoyed …
2004 vintage
Taster #7120 · Jan 24, 2008
90/100
Liked this a lot...everything in balance...soft and lucious
2004 vintage
Taster #4167 · Nov 24, 2007
90/100
Yum! Yum! Yum! Decanted about 3 hours. Purplish-red color. Light nose of dark cherry and just a hint of Oregon pinot funk. There is some alcohol on the nose, but it's soft. A little raspberry, some floral. Wonderful balance, acidity is bright and matches the shot of black cherry flavor nicely. I'm glad I have another bottle for later :-). Finish is nice and long. Annie really enjoyed this wine. color 4/5 balance 8/10 aroma 7/10 flavor 17/20 finish 4/5
2004 vintage
Taster #4619 · Feb 17, 2007
TB: Decanted for a half hour prior to trying. Still very tight up to one and a half hours of decanting. Light purple in color and clear. Nose showed bits of forest floor, mushroom, cola -- like the Bottle Caps candy you had as a kid, and pommegranite along with a bit of heat. Palate showed cherry, forest floor, and mushroom. This is a very extracted version of Pinot. The acidity seemed a bit lacking to deal with that level …
2004 vintage
Taster #9810 · Jan 21, 2007
89/100
Decanted about 3 hours. The nose was full of earthy aromas, followed by black cherry, plus a small amount of strawberry and a touch of spice. The palate was silky smooth and had lots of dark cherry fruit and spice, along with some forest floor. The tannins are firm, but a little bitter, and the finish goes on a good while.
2004 vintage