Piaggia, Vin Santo di Carmignano, Sasso
Piaggia · Tuscany › Vin Santo di Carmignano › Italy
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
90
/100
Reviews
19
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
2929
Reviews
90.4
Avg Score
93
Highest
Taster #1986
· Jun 22, 2024
92/100
Really nice. Balanced and smooth. Cherries, leather and a touch of thyme.
2013 vintage
Taster #0695
· Aug 29, 2020
90/100
No real notes tonight, but a very nice and well made wine, with a great qpr. Fine everyday drinker. Very much like my note from 5 years ago, but more developed and with more secondary notes present. Cherries, earth, leather and herbs. Well worth the money.
2006 vintage
Taster #4197
· Apr 6, 2020
dark inky plum red, little clarity, slight brickish hue Nose: plum, bing cherry, cigar, tobacco, coffee, lavender, earth, thyme, black pepper, smoke, oak Pal: plum, bing cherry, cigar, tar, tobacco, bitter dark chocolate, coffee, lavender, wet earth, thyme, clove, black pepper, dirt, minerals, smoke, soft tannins, oak Feel: full, tart, acidic Finish: long TC9
2006 vintage
Taster #1664
· Jul 16, 2018
92/100
Vin très agréable mais encore un peu trop puissant. A attendre encore un peu.
2005 vintage
Taster #5454
· Apr 9, 2018
I recall enjoying this a little more last time I had it 2 years ago. It had a little more freshness and energy. With that said, this was a very nice bottle that has mellowed out a lot over the last two years. Should drink well for a while.
2013 vintage
Taster #8044
· Sep 2, 2017
87/100
Nice smooth cherry and plum with hints of coffee.
2013 vintage
Taster #5454
· Aug 12, 2016
90/100
Really youthful and vibrant. Will enjoy this even more after a few years in the cellar, hopefully calming the acids down a bit, and integrating everything. Lots of bright red fruit. Thoroughly enjoyed this at this stage. Will be buying more to cellar for the next decade. 90++
2013 vintage
Taster #2855
· Feb 11, 2016
Tre Bicchieri (San Francisco) : Sangio and merlot. Light. Burnt.
2013 vintage
Taster #6171
· Nov 19, 2015
Rather super tasty. Doesn't really show the international varieties. Or rather, they are really nicely woven together.
2013 vintage
Taster #1664
· Jun 20, 2015
91/100
A attendre encore 3 à 5 ans.
2005 vintage
Taster #0695
· Jun 19, 2015
91/100
This was a really nice surprise, indeed. Bought a couple of bottles up on release, and tucked away a few to see what would happen. A brilliant move it seems, as this wine really showed great tonight. First few bottles drunk back when purchased was really easy going and straight forward, fruit driven and easy going. Very fine nose, with red berries, fine wood, cedar, loads of lovely green Italian herbs, spices, Tuscan earth, touch of licorice and cough medicine. …
2006 vintage
Taster #6916
· Nov 18, 2014
91/100
30 min decant. Definitely one of my wife's favorite wines for the buck....she is more of a 92 and I'm a 90. I'd say definitely has entered its prime!
2006 vintage
Taster #8547
· Jul 28, 2014
Probably at peak now. Fine although cork was almost completely soaked (and this bottle required only a short decant, probably as a result). Works well with Spaghetti Bolognese.
2006 vintage
Taster #8547
· Feb 16, 2014
Still needs a 2 hour decant. Some sediment is present. Not s good as previous bottle. Cork half soaked in red, btw. Consumed with beef and vegetable lasagne. Probably needs something even more substantial, beef stew or a steak.
2006 vintage
Taster #5877
· Nov 9, 2013
88/100
drinking very nicely - I was quite happy with this blend, despite giving it no time to open up due to having it at a byob. nice fruit and good finish.
2006 vintage
Taster #8547
· Jan 20, 2013
89/100
70% Sangiovese. The remaining 30% is a mix of Cabernet, Merlot, and Cab Franc. Decanted. It does need at least an hour or so to mellow and come together, very satisfying result after a 90-120 min... but do give it a try before this; the Cabernet Franc dominates in the first 15 minutes. It is still there after 90 minutes but now it is a part of a more complex array of flavours. It can be drunk now (with a …
2006 vintage
Taster #6254
· Nov 18, 2012
I didn't decant since I was afraid that it would accentuate the oak. In a way I was right, and in a way wrong ... First glass, served with filet de boeuf, jerusalem artichoke, root celery and potatoes from the oven togetter with a buttery sauce based on Marsala, is quite oaky. 70% sangiovese tastes more like a 100% bordeaux, with cassis, a tad coffee, some tar and a feeling of cigarbox. It works well with the food though, even …
2006 vintage
Taster #6735
· Feb 26, 2012
90/100
Very nice and firm wine. Still enough life for another 5 years at least. Still quite tannic, and confirm with other commenters about the pencil lead and cherry. Sangiovese is the backbone, but gets noticeable help from the C abernet. Serious wine, that I picked up at a local wineshop during a stay in Tuscany in 2010 for around 14 EUROS. I gladly give it 90 points.
2006 vintage
Taster #5183
· Mar 13, 2011
90/100
Decanted for an hour, and still going strong. Wish I had bought a case of this!
2005 vintage
Taster #3526
· Dec 18, 2010
91/100
Very well made and with good sangiovese character that doesn't get lost behind the cabernet, etc. in the blend. This was a very satisying and all together tasty bottle of wine, of the basis of which I'll start looking for the 2007.
2006 vintage
Taster #8097
· Sep 25, 2010
93/100
Lovely
2006 vintage
Taster #1263
· May 22, 2010
88/100
Served it as a blínd one. Worked well, got votes for languedoc... To me a it is a very decent supertuscan. Fruit and leather. But still if you wander into the price/quality section. Well. I would expect 90 for that price. Still, worth waiting for.
2006 vintage
Taster #7221
· Apr 18, 2010
93/100
This wine shows a ruby red color in the glass with aromas of black cherry, lavender and herbs, lead pencil and just the right amount of toasty oaky. On the palate I found juicy blackberry with a citrus twinge, followed by cedar on a well structured frame with balanced acidity. Citrus and sour cherry show on the medium long finish.
2006 vintage
Taster #0966
· Apr 10, 2010
92/100
Purchased this in Radda in 9.08. Day 1: Slightly green/vegetal nose. Cocoa, coffee, black fruits. 70% sangiovese, 20% cabernet, 10% merlot. Suspect this would benefit from a few more years in the bottle. Day 2: Really came around after re-corking and a night in the fridge. Chocolate-covered cherry, hot chocolate. Lush nose. Slightly dusted tannins. Great stuff. Plan to give the last couple glasses another night in the fridge to see how it evolves. Day 3: Still going strong. Espresso, …
2005 vintage
Taster #4197
· Nov 7, 2009
plum red, brickish hue, medium clarity Nose: blackberries, chalk, mint, earth, tobacco, cola, oak, smoke, fennel, onions Pal: blackberries, chalk, mint, earth, tobacco, cola, oak, smoke Feel: medium, acidic, savory Finish: long TC8
2006 vintage
Taster #7221
· Oct 23, 2009
93/100
What a surprise since I picked this up after reading a brief article on Carmignano and thought to taste one. Amazing nose that reads like a basket of red fruit. First it's raspberry, then wild berries and then cherry cough drops followed up by cedar and saddle leather. The palate reveals sour cherries, creme fraiche and clove. Medium body with wonderfully brisk acidity and a nice long red berry finish.
2006 vintage
Taster #1630
· Mar 7, 2009
Då ramlade man dit igen då, 90 poängare under 250 bagare låter ju alltid bra. Schysst för de stålarna men ingen kanon, nått saknas...partner in crime kanske, frugan gravid igen, så nått bollplank finns inte att räkna med på ett tag.
2006 vintage
Taster #2798
· Mar 6, 2009
70% sangiovese give this supertoscan a pleasant stucture. Smell of cherries and oak, good acidity, Concentrated and long taste.
2006 vintage
Taster #6691
· Apr 26, 2008
87/100
At first, very acidic and feels much too young. This doesn't feel ready to drink yet, after several hours it's starting to taste like a really nice Chianti. Store at least three-four years in the cellar.
2005 vintage