Vega Sicilia, Valbuena 5.°, Ribera del Duero
Vega Sicilia · Castilla y Leon › Ribera del Duero › Spain
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
93
/100
Reviews
47
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
5757
Reviews
92.7
Avg Score
100
Highest
Taster #1585
· Feb 9, 2026
92/100
The acidity and freshness are stronger than expected, dominated by red fruits, cloves, nutmeg, slightly jintan, dark oak, relatively fresh tannins, new leather, hint of lactose.
2003 vintage
Taster #7321
· Dec 25, 2025
93/100
Deep red moving into garnet Nose: heavy vanilla, white chocolate, leather, coffee, bramble and red fruits: red cherry, red and black currant and a wonderful florality with lots of violets and bay laurel. Palate: redcurrants, cherries and violets, with a healthy dose of coffee and tar. Tart acidity. Long sweet finish of cocoa and fresh pressed cafetière.
2014 vintage
Taster #1881
· Oct 1, 2025
90/100
Retains a nice ruby color. Oak (literally wood), mustiness and pine needles front the still-vibrant red fruit on the nose. Surprisingly fresh ripe red fruit up front moving to stewed strawberries with lovely acid and fine tannins. Fruit and acid draw out a nice finish. The wine is slightly hollow on pnp. I concur with the drink now sentiment.
2003 vintage
Taster #8482
· Aug 20, 2025
100/100
IMHO this is THe wine of the vintage for 1989 Ribera. Drank it many times, blind, including vs. '89 Unico- Valbuena is always a winner.
1989 vintage
Taster #2513
· Jul 10, 2025
95/100
Pretty dark red purple. Ink, tar, fragrant blue and red berries, floral, light. Ripe red and black berries, graphite, fine minerality, silky and refined, super fine powdery tannins, quite tightly structured, lovely mild crushed herb edge. Elegant, youthful, with a long life ahead of it.
2014 vintage
Taster #2508
· Jun 29, 2025
93/100
“Elegant gravitas with Spanish soul” At over a decade in, it’s just entering its prime stride, offering the kind of finesse that only time can deliver. Beautiful ruby with some faint rusting at the rim. On the nose, it opens with a restrained but complex bouquet: dried cherries, cigar box, iron-rich earth, and a dusting of sweet spice. 1-2 hrs of Decanting helps it come alive, revealing an elegant core of red currant, graphite, and well-integrated oak. There’s a coolness …
2014 vintage
Taster #6466
· Apr 30, 2025
91/100
Great nose - pure fruit, floral notes, dill. A little drying and hollow on the palate, slightly stewed fruit. Long finish. Drink up. 90-92
2003 vintage
Taster #6103
· Mar 30, 2025
95/100
Amazing wine especially when it comes to the QPR. Very refined as always from Vega Sicilia. Had all the oaky notes with ripe cherry being the most forward fruit note for me. Decant for 2-3 hours. Should keep well for another decade.
2014 vintage
Taster #8720
· Dec 31, 2024
95/100
This is delicious. Will probably get better but pretty fantastic now.
2014 vintage
Taster #7474
· Dec 30, 2024
90/100
Good not great, cold vintage
2014 vintage
Taster #2436
· Nov 1, 2024
96/100
Fantastisk fylde og duften springer ud af glasset med modne røde bær
2014 vintage
Taster #9217
· Sep 21, 2024
Saturday Night Live Blind BYO; 9/21/2024-9/22/2024 (Bodø City) : Grease, and sweat horse. Volatile.
2014 vintage
Taster #1438
· Jun 28, 2024
91/100
Mature and lovely wine. Sappy, with dark fruit compote, and very fine tannins. Energetic on its own, but was easily overpowered by food, as a grilled lamb chop was enough to drown out most discernible character. Was best with a mild goat cheese. This bottle had a much better showing than the one last night, but I'd venture that this wine is probably not destined for much more cellaring.
2003 vintage
Taster #1438
· Jun 27, 2024
Opened at a small tasting of Duero wines, and it did not show well against several much younger and flamboyant bottles. My bad.
2003 vintage
Taster #9326
· Apr 6, 2024
94/100
Cherry, jam, elegant, long month. Maybe a bit past its peak but still delicious.
1989 vintage
Taster #9765
· Feb 17, 2024
90/100
Saturday evening in diessenhofen, pairing with entrecôte. Decanted for one hour. Deep purple color. Lots of vanilla, red cherry, black pepper, green capsicum, mushroom and wet forest floor on the nose. Med acidity, full body, high alcohol, med flavor intensity, med tannins and med finish. Ample mouth, lots of cream and vanilla, lots of cherries, quite warm, dried Mediterranean herbs, dry tannins, mild pepper, nice capsicum. This still needs to evolve further and after 2 hours I start to taste …
2014 vintage
Taster #0951
· Jan 27, 2024
Only small pour and this hadn't gotten much air. Was a little rough around the edged with coarse tannins and red and black fruit profile. Didn't get to revisit later on.
2014 vintage
Taster #3123
· Aug 24, 2023
93/100
This is your good old boy, very classic, very Spanish, very spicy (dark, Arabian spice), sweet fruit, full bodied effort, yet with impeccable. Very early maturity. #KulturmødeMors
2014 vintage
Taster #3127
· Jun 27, 2023
92/100
Big wine , ripe juicy sweet fruit, decent amount of oak of course, sweet oak but still the wine has enough substance to own the oak , dark fruited , plums. Proper richness and weight here as expected for the style and pedigree. On the young side but still silky enough to be welcoming . Touch one dimensional now though on account of that. 91-92 and with a lot of life ahead .
2014 vintage
Taster #7826
· Jun 20, 2023
Atualizando adega, não tem esse vinho deste ano na adega
2003 vintage
Taster #6844
· Jun 9, 2023
91/100
Didn’t like this as much as the previous bottle. Slight bricking but ink dark. A bit of spice and smoke on the nose. Full bodied with mild tannins (and lots of sediment). Still some dark fruit with hints of tertiary notes but the flavour was less intense than expected. Kept some in a half bottle for a few days - got a more expressive nose but also slight sour note.
2003 vintage
Taster #4106
· Apr 17, 2023
Incredible bottle of wine. Pomegranate on the nose, long finish.
1989 vintage
Taster #9181
· Apr 14, 2023
97/100
Mi tercera añada de este Ribera y siempre una pasada. Tinto Fino con un 5% de Merlot y crianza en madera francesa y americana, barricas de 225 litros nuevas y usadas y tinos de 8.500 litros. Alc. 14% vol. Si bien es cierto que tiene potencial para un largo recorrido, ya es un vino increíblemente rico y preciso, muy redondo, intenso y complejo, con una amplia gama de matices afrutados, especiados, balsámicos, tostados y mucho más. Bebido durante cena de …
2014 vintage
Taster #4983
· Apr 13, 2023
91/100
Drank at 67 A really beautiful smooth and linear showing
2003 vintage
Taster #2280
· Feb 15, 2023
97/100
Meaty, lange afdronk, elegant, full body, low tanine
2014 vintage
Taster #3123
· Oct 2, 2022
91/100
Oh, well. I managed to guess something from Vega, it's smokey, manly, firm, vertical - and very rich, 2003 speaks. #CP
2003 vintage
Taster #7816
· Jul 8, 2022
95/100
This is drinking beautifully now
2003 vintage
Taster #9669
· Mar 13, 2022
95/100
Opened to celebrate our son breaking up with his girlfriend who my wife and I absolutely despised. What a delish drink for the occasion. Victory could not taste any sweeter. Fabulous wine, drink now or hold for another decade.
2014 vintage
Taster #5769
· Feb 26, 2022
83/100
Medeirisiert, allenfalls schlecht gelagert vor Kauf
2014 vintage
Taster #2031
· Jan 30, 2022
87/100
Qui ne connait pas Vega Sicilia ? Propriété mythique d’Espagne de plus de 1000 hectares qui produit le Unico. Cette cuvée Tinto «Valbuena» 5° veut dire que le vin a passé 5 ans avant sa commercialisation entre le fût de chêne et la bouteille. J’ai passé l’année 2003 en Catalogne et je ne me rappelle pas avoir vu de la pluie. Un été caniculaire en Europe. Plusieurs doutaient du vieillissement des vins qui manquaient à leurs sortis de la fraicheur …
2003 vintage
Taster #2552
· Nov 21, 2021
93/100
Abierto dos horas antes y decantado una hora. Color rubí de capa muy alta con bordes ligeramente atejado. Aroma de intensidad alta, en un primer momento se detecta mina de lápiz, como aroma esencial seguido de grosellas, bayas y pequeñas frutas del bosque que progresivamente van cambiando a algarroba y castaña. La boca es intensa, consistente, tensionada interiormente , taninos finos y elegantes, da sensaciones frutales, torrefactos y especies. Es un vino muy estructurado, limpio, redondo, bien definido y elegante. …
2003 vintage
Taster #8868
· Nov 1, 2021
93/100
Last bottle at a restaurant and negotiated to a more reasonable price after a wine mix up earlier. Beautiful unusual nose on pnp, rich dark fruit, vanilla, still drinking quite young and will get better but certainly very enjoyable now.
2014 vintage
Taster #9483
· Oct 22, 2021
94/100
A masterful amazing wine by Vega Sicilia! This was a giant amongst its peers (Alion 2014 and Pintia 2015, and the Numanthia 2010 too) last night at our dinner session in Martas Kitchen, Hartamas. Stunning nose and gorgeous ruby tones right out of the bottle, grateful for chance to try my first Valbuena 5 @[1|9482449|Mika Tyson Teau] It developed even more smoothness never losing its character over the hours I sipped it, super on its own and amazing with the …
2014 vintage
Taster #4815
· Oct 19, 2021
96/100
Dunkelbeerige Superstar Nase. So komplex. Klar Vega. Schon sehr gut trinkbar wird aber noch zulegen
2014 vintage
Taster #0304
· Aug 13, 2021
94/100
Medium-red color. Dark fruit and oak notes in the bouquet. A rich supple powerful wine. Only mild tannins. Good grip and long finish. Complex, with a ripe dark fruit flavor.
2003 vintage
Taster #6761
· Jul 22, 2021
92/100
Eðalklúbbur, sumarsmakk 2021 (Hlíðarás 10) : Múrsteinslitað. Mjög fínn og þroskaður ilmur. Blóð og kjöt. Kokteilsósa, bílaverkstæði, ryk, járn. Frekar mikil sýra þegar smakkað á víninu. Þéttur bragðvöndull sem erfitt er að greina í sundur. En mjög flott miðað við aldur. Stendur vel fyrir sínu. Væntanlega komið vel yfir toppinn en ekkert farið að dala neitt mikið. Miðað við þetta smakk þá er líklega ekki sniðugt að geyma Valbuenurnar sínar mikið meira en 15-18 ár ef maður vill ná því …
1989 vintage
Taster #8571
· May 10, 2021
93/100
Very drinkable but leaving alone might be best, 5 years?
2014 vintage
Taster #7932
· Mar 6, 2021
95/100
Took 2h of decanting to open up and stayed perfect for next 2h. Very nice sophisticated bouquet, not strong, but rather fine taste without strong tannins, but with long ending. Five more to go from my cellar, but will probably wait at least another 2 years as it probably has potential well beyond 95 points.
2014 vintage
Taster #1308
· Jan 8, 2021
94/100
Deep and seductive, with mix of ripe cherry and dark fruit, smooth tobacco, and savory umami, unfolding like a fine, slow-burning cigar. Polished, layered and utterly satisfying — a wine to linger over, with a long, luxurious finish.
2014 vintage
Taster #5607
· Dec 29, 2020
Decanted. Pretty powerful aromatic, loaded with intense sweet dark fruits, light incense and filled with high class vanilla oak. Equally powerful and dense on the palate. Almost a bit too sweet to me. Fortunately the acidity was showing up after 2hours in the decanter and give the wine a nice backbone and freshness. Still pretty dominated by the new oak at the end of the palate. Need many more years to hit the right balance.
2014 vintage
Taster #3046
· Oct 13, 2020
90/100
A bit young in 2020
2014 vintage
Taster #7469
· Oct 10, 2020
94/100
Loved it. Plush clean warm fruit, nice balance, good length. Shone after 30 min so no need for a long decant. Still lovely 2 hrs later. Will buy more, plush and elegant
2014 vintage
Taster #9565
· Feb 22, 2020
92/100
Really nice juice, just slightly on the other side of the bubble. Drink now, thru 2022
2003 vintage
Taster #1623
· Jan 18, 2020
93/100
Just a perfect balance of powerful fruit and acidity. This was a fabulous bottle and I can’t wait to enjoy the other two from the 3 pack.
2003 vintage
Taster #1438
· Mar 12, 2019
95/100
Huge bouquet, clove, smoke, wood, pine. Perfect from the first sip. Muscular, sculpted body, sappy, meaty, umami. Sweet cherry fruit with perfectly integrated wood, solid acidity. Outstanding depth and composure, long finish. Wonderful bottle. I am aware that old Valbuena can be pretty variable, but this one was just awesome. I do not recommend bringing this wine to a tasting with a dozen young cabs; Just drink it it at home with somebody you love and some simple food.
1989 vintage
Taster #9945
· Jan 14, 2019
91/100
dry cork needed help removing cranberries and spanish earth predominant length was a little short compared with the 2011 presumably from the difficult year still, a delight this evening
2003 vintage
Taster #5419
· Dec 27, 2018
93/100
Not tired at all , got better during the evening. Stood up against Clos Erasmus 2006. Both very good and still alive...
2003 vintage
Taster #3590
· Sep 30, 2017
92/100
delivered more than expected given age. still young fruit notes, solid tannins and lively acidity.
2003 vintage
Taster #3123
· Sep 4, 2017
89/100
A bit pruny, tired, ends dry, this is 2003, although you do find some freshness also. I don't see it going anywhere. #Vega#KongHans
2003 vintage
Taster #3143
· Jan 30, 2017
93/100
Plums, dark cherries, game, tobacco. A structured, complex wine drinking beautifully now. Has a lovely mouthfeel and good length, with a drying finish. Still has many years in front of it.
2003 vintage