Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
94
/100
Reviews
37
professional
Vintages
1
1983
Other
89/100
Cabernet Sauvignon
NV
Community Reviews
3131
Reviews
89.5
Avg Score
97
Highest
Taster #3552
· Jun 18, 2025
91/100
Nose: dark fruits, cinnamon, plum, leather, wet stones, black tea, plum Notes: 12% ABV. Almost perfect fill with an almost perfect cork. This is well conditioned Napa that is incredibly young and powerful. The old Diamond Creeks are incredible as they show excellent aging potential and alcohol contents remain quite low so despite its well built structure it's not too overwhelming or jammy. Bursting with the aroma of wet stones and minerality this is quite complex and strong. Still extremely …
1983 vintage
Taster #1603
· Jun 13, 2025
91/100
Magnum. 2 hr decant before back in the bottle and taken to the restaurant. Cork was dry but held together nicely. Open bottle for 1.5 hours before first glass. Classic aged Bordeaux nose with forest floor and earthy notes. Mostly secondary flavors with a small amount of fruit coming through mid palate. Fantastic old Napa that seems to have finally hit its stride. Score would be higher but a shorter finish than I would have liked. Started to fad around …
1983 vintage
Taster #8874
· Apr 11, 2025
96/100
What a terrific showing. Opened as a birth year bottle for a dear friend. This was absolutely perfect. Dark cherries, slate, elegant spices, meatiness, and lively acidity. Yet, the body was so ethereal and the finish was so persistent. Absolutely loved it. A truly regal wine.
1983 vintage
Taster #8874
· Oct 23, 2024
94/100
Opened at Eastbluff. The 1983 Napas I've had this year have all been excellent and this Diamond Creek is no exception. Dark cherries, slate, light spices, and medium acidity, with a solid finish to go with that beautiful classic aged nose. Very pleasant.
1983 vintage
Taster #6049
· Jan 24, 2021
Wine was incredible after decanting for 4 hours. Great earthy tones I’m looking for in older Diamond Creek Volcanic Hills.
1983 vintage
Taster #0912
· Mar 5, 2020
89/100
La Paulée Zachy's Auction - Thursday (Le Bernardin Privé) : Cedary, earthy and leafy nose. Light-to-medium concentrated on the palate. Seems a bit soft.
1983 vintage
Taster #4443
· Mar 5, 2020
Zachys La Paulee Auction; 3/5/2020-3/6/2020 (Le Bernardin Prive - New York NY) : Small glass, brief note. Still too tannic for the level of fruit.
1983 vintage
Taster #8383
· Jan 25, 2020
93/100
We had the volcanic hill on 1/19/20 and on 1/25/20. These take at least 4 hours to open both bottles were drinking very well at hour 4 and the red fruit and floral notes really started singing. Might go another 5 yrs? This is an amazing 37 year old cab I recommend opening it in the morning for a dinner time glass
1983 vintage
Taster #9779
· Jul 3, 2018
91/100
Recently obtained via auction from K&L and allowed to rest 1 month. Lower neck fill with a good quality cork (removed via Ah So)...moist only at the end. Medium brickish ruby tailing off noticeably toward the rim. Not bad for it's age. Nose of old cedar & oak with some tobacco, old cherries, plums, and red currants along with quite bit of tannin (which is perceived as the residue of Black Tea...the tannic acid). Amazingly good right of of the …
1983 vintage
Taster #8210
· Jan 27, 2018
90/100
Part of our No Wine Under 25 (Yr.) tasting. A medium garnet coloring with a hint of bricking on the rim. The nose gave off some fruit (black cherry, blackberry) and then faded to mature notes of cedar, leather and chocolate. A very smooth wine and drinking well.
1983 vintage
Taster #8210
· Jan 27, 2018
89/100
Part of our No Wine Under 25 (Yr.) tasting. A medium garnet coloring with a bit of bricking on the rim. Notes of dried fruit, currants and tobacco. The wine was smooth and very tasty.
1983 vintage
Taster #5202
· Oct 5, 2017
92/100
Definitely at the end of it's life, but this 30 year wine packs wonderful favor. Dried fruit, earthy notes, tobacco, currant, and smokey oak. A/A-
1983 vintage
Taster #2091
· Mar 10, 2017
92/100
You wouldn't believe it's an 83, holding up every well. Juicy strawberry liqueur, leather saddle, black currant, still tons of fruit. Tannins are mild but very much still there.
1983 vintage
Taster #1863
· Jan 11, 2014
From a magnum and decanted 4 hours. Served double blind. Hard to believe this was 30 years old. No bricking and tons of life left.
1983 vintage
Taster #4595
· Dec 14, 2013
91/100
Still showed fruit! Decanted 3 hours and tasted each hour. Very little bricking.
1983 vintage
Taster #5824
· Jul 8, 2013
91/100
Red berries; Bramble; Medium finish; Relatively narrow profile
1983 vintage
Taster #0069
· May 27, 2013
90/100
Thinning out a bit, but a lovely dusty complex nose of light cassis tinged with mint, bit of funk. Medium to light concentration but good palate overall, with funk adding to a core of mature cab "mulberry" type fruit. Perfect with grilled steak.
1983 vintage
Taster #1031
· Mar 27, 2013
90/100
Magnum,cellared since release. Great nose, austere on palate, not much fruit remaining. Enjoyed by all. Passover at home.
1983 vintage
Taster #2546
· Dec 1, 2011
91/100
Jonathan Dinh 5th Annual Magnum Birthday Dinner (Donato Enoteca, Redwood City, California) : Opaque red violet color; herbal, ripe, tart black fruit, tart plum, olive nose; concentrated, tart black fruit, olive, herbs, menthol palate; medium-plus finish 91+ points
1983 vintage
Taster #2159
· Jun 26, 2009
93/100
This is a great example of the saying that, with a 20+ year-old wine, there are only great "bottles" and not necessarily great wines. Fortunately for my tasting group and me, this was a great bottle. It was purchased upon release and stored in pristine fashion. Tonight (6/26/09) it was presented in double-blind fashion to our tasting group, a night when many great wines were served double-blind alongside. My tasting of the wine was unblinded. I double-decanted the wine in …
1983 vintage
Taster #6255
· Apr 12, 2009
69/100
I was extremely hesitant to even taste this wine given the tasting notes from 12/31/2007. It’s now more than two years later, and this wine is 26 years old. However, having three bottles in the cellar, they would either get tasted or dumped. No harm in tasting. On the cautionary side, the wine was opened and decanted for two hours. Upon opening, the nose presented substantial - overbearing earthy minerals and ash. Upon tasting two hours later, there was a …
1983 vintage
Taster #6463
· Dec 31, 2007
77/100
I would confidently say that this is past its prime and more so past being palatable. At first the nose was intriguing. Offering plenty of ash, damp earth, minerals, and bitter chocolate. The palate however was offensive and out of balance. Sour red fruits up front with a minerality that was metallic and steely, piercing acidity with no fruit to back it up. Interestingly enough, it finishes with these awkward tannins out of nowhere. Having had some 20+ year old …
1983 vintage
Taster #2159
· Jul 21, 2001
86/100
Medim red-brown with orange rim. Clean nose which requires at least 25 minutes of aeration in decanter to show anything. Moderate to heavy sediment. The bouquet ultimately shows mint, cedar, black cherry and blackberries. The palate is full-bodied, with heavy, hard, astringent tannins. The tannins give the wine a dry finish which is definitely a detriment. Although this wine still has fruit, assuming that this simply doesn't represent bottle variation, it appears to have gone out of balance at this …
1983 vintage
Taster #2159
· Feb 2, 1996
97/100
Tasted at Brasserie with Don Mason. Medium ruby with orange/brick rim. Moderate sediment. Immediate nose closed. After 30 minutes, the nose opens to show mint, cedar, currants and black cherries. Youthful palate with same flavors. Still quite tannic. Plenty of fruit left. Long, slightly tannic finish. Will continue to improve.
1983 vintage
Taster #2159
· Jun 30, 1993
97/100
Tasted at Domaine Chandon near window with good daylight (bottle brought from personal cellar). Color even deeper than 12/11/91 (opaque mulberry). Nose, palate and finish otherwise similar to 12/11/91. Despite being 10 years old, this wine is still very youthful.
1983 vintage
Taster #0332
· Jan 30, 1993
85/100
Hi-Time Cellars Tasting 11 Diamond Creek Cabernet Sauvignons, nose of cherry and forest floor, same on the palate, softer fruit and tannins then the Gravelly Meadow, big body, rich, fruity wine on the palate, good acid, needs 7 years to peak.
1983 vintage
Taster #0332
· Jan 30, 1993
89/100
Hi-Time Cellars Tasting 11 Diamond Creek Cabernet Sauvignons, cabernet sauvignon nose, big body, more forward and better balanced than the other 2 1983 wines, softer tannins.
1983 vintage
Taster #2159
· Dec 11, 1991
96/100
Deep ruby with red rim. Mild to moderate sediment (not decanted). Immediate nose shows prominent fruit and oak. Within 15 minutes, the nose shows complex aromas of cigar, mint and chocolate (never losing the fruit). Palate follows, with abundant but fairly supple tannins. Long finish. Wonderful, and will definitely improve.
1983 vintage
Taster #8125
· Feb 2, 1991
88/100
With Michael Lehmann and Brett Raven at Singer and Foy. Very dark ruby color. Lots of enticing fruit in the nose. Chocolatey, forward, herbal. On the palate, it is somewhat austere and tannic, but with surprising fruit and drinkability. Short. Slightly hard finish. Good wine for the vintage. 5-11-15-7: 88/100.
1983 vintage
Taster #8125
· May 13, 1989
88/100
With Michael Lehmann at Singer and Foy survey of Diamond Creek wines. Dark color; more Ruby than the others. Closed, chocolatey nose. Good weight, power and richness. Very good, but needs time. 5-11-15-7: 88/100.
1983 vintage
Taster #8125
· May 13, 1989
79/100
With Michael Lehmann at Singer and Foy survey of Diamond Creek wines. Filmy, with bubbles. Lighter in color than the other wines. Nose is very closed. Fairly smooth on the palate. A bit disjointed. 3–9–13–4: 79/100.
1983 vintage