Williams Selyem Pinot Noir Sonoma County

Williams Selyem

Other · Pinot Noir
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
90 /100
Reviews
18
professional

Vintages

1
2005 Other 90/100
Pinot Noir
NV

Community Reviews

25
25
Reviews
90.0
Avg Score
92
Highest
Taster #8262 · Jan 24, 2026
Medium red color, red berry nose, lighter weight not but plenty of berry fruit. Wine is still offering smooth and enjoyable drinking. Served with roast chicken. Surely past its prime but is a well-made wine to enjoy.
2005 vintage
Taster #8375 · May 19, 2025
91/100
With Grilled Orange Spiced rubbed pork chops….. Thought it might be dead but surprisingly sort a fresh with sweet and slightly sour and just the right acidity to stand up to Pork chop. Blood orange and slight earth. Very serviceable. Surprised…. After 90 minutes it started to fade so drink em
2005 vintage
Taster #8262 · Jul 31, 2022
Medium red color, mixed berry nose expanding with time, ripe mixed berry (mostly cherry) fruit, a it sweet, very smooth with a medium length sweet fruit finish. Actually a tasty wine with king salmon. We will drink our remaining bottles over the next 2-3 years.
2005 vintage
Taster #2647 · Jul 16, 2022
A quick taste from a 750ml. Good fill and intact cork. A nice wine with delicate flavors, but drink up. This is an example of how Williams Selyem's blends can age nicely beyond five to seven years. Of course there are contributing factors such as vintage, bottle size, and of course storage.
2005 vintage
Taster #3674 · Nov 8, 2021
92/100
Still tasting fresh.
2005 vintage
Taster #4443 · Oct 13, 2015
86/100
Nice red berry throughout, still fresh. Some nice baking spice, but overall slightly too sweet for my preference. Bought from WS at release.
2005 vintage
Taster #9884 · Nov 9, 2014
92/100
P/w 1 hour decant. Good cork. Clear, purple w/brown tint, some bottom sediment. Very nice, big Pinot nose. Well integrated, perfectly balanced wine in ideal drinking window. Not too ripe with good acid. Big and rich with nothing off. Just as good after 12 hours with same flavor intensity. Still got lots of time left but why wait. Nothing off, D/J
2005 vintage
Taster #4677 · Oct 10, 2013
89/100
Initial nose of strawberry which over time evolved to add some root beer aromas and allspice. Hazy lighter red color to the eye. Nice sweet berries on the palate. Nice wine. Served with grilled pizza.
2005 vintage
Taster #9884 · Aug 26, 2013
92/100
PnP w/15 min decant. Very slight fine haze, med ruby color, nice legs. Proper clean/big nose. Med body/finish, good integration/balance, nice acid/soft tannin. Not over the top extraction w/correct Pinot flavor profile. Good juice in prime drinking window. Nothing off, $49. Should hold for another few years yet but why wait.
2005 vintage
Taster #2198 · Aug 16, 2013
92/100
Nicely balanced, I like the fruit
2005 vintage
Taster #9884 · Jul 29, 2013
91/100
PnP w/10 min glass time. Clear, med purple/red color. Med nose. This RR was very nice. I like 05 Pinots, they are rich/bold. Nice balance, big, proper Pinot flavors. Decent finish. Good drinking window. Nothing off.
2005 vintage
Taster #6958 · Feb 5, 2013
Very enjoyable for its silky texture; overtly sweet, but balanced out by a light to moderate earthiness. What I sometimes don't like in WS Pinots is pronounced cola/sassafras, present a couple of years ago in this wine is no longer at all in evidence here. A good example of this style of Pinot, and a wine that definitely improved and integrated with medium-term bottle age.
2005 vintage
Taster #7818 · Nov 17, 2011
90/100
Drinking well. Definitely at it's prime. Cherry cola on the palate. Light and not much complexity. Very enjoyable to drink with my favorite Pinot noir cheese...port salute.
2005 vintage
Taster #2956 · Oct 1, 2011
13.8% alcohol. This has hit its peak, and it's absolutely beautiful. Very light red cherry color. On the nose, bursting with red cherry, spice, floral, and mushroom notes. In the mouth, a vibrant, balanced wine that showcases the best of red cherry from the Russian River, along with tea and floral notes that are bolstered by earthy spice. Still a nice acidic kick. Strong finish. Just delightful. A-
2005 vintage
Taster #1832 · Sep 16, 2011
87/100
Nothing distinctive; popped and poured; subtle, medium body effort
2005 vintage
Taster #2844 · Aug 19, 2011
90/100
Still drinking well - similar to last bottle.
2005 vintage
Taster #5650 · May 30, 2011
89/100
Cherry, cherry, cherry. Solid depth, with solid finish and fruit comes through nicely.
2005 vintage
Taster #5579 · Feb 2, 2011
89/100
PnP. This is a very good wine but singular dimensioned. Light RRV color and body with a hint of baking spices. I'll update this if a little air softens the palate.
2005 vintage
Taster #8217 · Jun 25, 2010
88/100
Color: clear light garnet center, with lightening to rose at the edges. Even a clear outer ring. Nose: after initial blast of cherry, showed good earth notes, leaves, with cola coming out after about 30 minutes. On the palate, big dark fruits, cherries, some tart plum, with good balance and depth. The long finish offers up cola to follow up the early fruit impression.
2005 vintage
Taster #6958 · May 30, 2010
Medium-weight, precisely flavored (with a prominent sassafras component), a lot to like here. I'm not sure that additional time will knit together the already enjoyable flavors, but only that integration is lacking from making this wine all it could be. There is a real danger in extended aging here, it seems to me. Worth another year or two in the cellar before popping last cork; downside seems larger than upside for waiting any longer than that.
2005 vintage
Taster #0837 · May 27, 2010
91/100
A great wine that seems to be drinking in its prime. Much more nuanced, balanced and light on its feet than the '05 Jayson also opened.
2005 vintage
Taster #4501 · Jan 25, 2010
90/100
This was story-book William's Selyem. Guests for dinner compared it very favorably with some of the top Burgundian wines from France. The wine had a bright medium intensity garnet ruby color in the glass. On the nose it was classic "Bill and the same for the flavors. Lots of cherry, some spice and earth...all at just the right intensity. The wine was medium weight and elegant.
2005 vintage
Taster #1518 · Dec 27, 2009
89/100
Popped and poured, sweet candied red fruit in the nose, with a hint of floral spice. Red plum, cherry and vanilla on the palate that turns a little sour on the finish. A little thin and underwhelming but still tasty. Based on this bottle, I would drink sooner than latter.
2005 vintage
Taster #2956 · Nov 15, 2009
13.8% alcohol. Light cherry color. Beautiful nose of red cherry, black cherry, a bit of spice, and a distinct floral note. In the mouth, elegant and with great balance. Full of fruit, with good layers of floral and mineral complexity. Gentle but necessary acidity. Long finish. Delightful and retaining plenty of life for a few more years. A-
2005 vintage
Taster #4839 · Nov 5, 2009
92/100
Big, full of fruit, nice structure
2005 vintage