Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
95
/100
Reviews
16
professional
Vintages
1
2004
Other
93/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
2525
Reviews
93.4
Avg Score
97
Highest
Taster #9875
· Dec 12, 2025
93/100
More class and weight than the NSG on the side but somehow a touch sweeter for my taste. Most preferred the NSG. 93
2004 vintage
Taster #3552
· Jun 13, 2025
93/100
Nose: cherry, red fruits, hints of greenness, mung beans, red flower, black tea, raspberry, musk, smoke Notes: 13% ABV. Drank together with the 1998 vintage, this is so intense and flavorful. I again reiterate that the 2004s are drinking nicely now and despite many complaints about the grenness from the vintage I actually think that looking at it today it's quite trivial. Crazily aromatic and so complex with an intoxicating nose. This shows plenty of freshness still and is probably …
2004 vintage
Taster #2807
· May 17, 2025
95/100
Bei diesem Musigny blitze die absolute Genialität hin und wieder auf und beeindruckende mit Raffinesse im Spiel. Doch die für 2004 so typischen Attribute von Kargheit, gewisser Herbe, verbissener Tiefe, Sehnigkeit und einem Hang zur Fahrigkeit konnte er sicherlich nicht verbergen. Zum Glück! Aber einfach sich mit so einem Charakter anzufreunden, dürfte diese kantige, etwas snobistisch anmutende und zur Magersucht neigende Genialität nicht sein. Natürlich ein Fast Himmlischer Genuss mit wunderbar verbissener Tiefe! https://wine-zeit.blogspot.com/2025/05/wo-wunder-schon-geschehen-da-mochte-der.html
2004 vintage
Taster #5315
· Aug 7, 2024
97/100
A bouquet that immediately grabs your attention. Profound morello cherries, haunting violet nose complicated with some gamey tone, white pepper and completely harmonized tannin. No green meanies.
2004 vintage
Taster #3229
· Aug 30, 2023
97/100
Bu lors d’une série avec Un Echezeaux et Grand Echezeaux de la Romanée Conti. Quelle chance de pouvoir boire un si grand vin. Millésime peu reconnu pourtant aucune trace ici de ce côté végétal de plusieurs 2004. Des épices douces à profusion sur ce nez sublime et complexe. Bouche d’une telle classe et élégance tout en ayant encore une belle colonne et structure affinée, quelle finale délicieuse et longueur impressionnante. 96-97 Drank with Echezeaux 2013 and Grands Echezeaux 2010 of …
2004 vintage
Taster #0242
· Oct 16, 2020
94/100
This wine had a very deep red center with light red rims. The medium intensity took quite a while to develop. After a few hours it developed plums, violets, minerals, and some rhubarb. In the mouth, this had a nice silky texture, light rounded tannin, and very good length. This wine still seemed young and likely to improve with time. However, the QPR seems debatable.
2004 vintage
Taster #8394
· Jun 26, 2018
92/100
Touch of creaminess aromatically that signaled Mugnier, but smells and tastes like 2004. Strong greenness on nose and palate. Polished and refined tannins.
2004 vintage
Taster #7568
· Apr 15, 2018
97/100
During a La Paulee dinner, so no detailed tasting notes. Great, spicy wine, red fruit with clay, cloves, wonderful, no 2004 greenness whatsoever.
2004 vintage
Taster #6059
· Mar 9, 2018
92/100
Montrachet and Musigny : Blind. Dark violet florals, chocolate, blood, black cherry and some redcurrant. Really composed on the palate, medium bodied fruit and excellent length that is stretched out by bright acidity. Doesn't show any of the 2004 green streak at the moment, a really successful showing for this wine.
2004 vintage
Taster #6329
· Jan 20, 2018
Denne var som grønske i medisinskapet. Langt svakere enn en flaske jeg hadde for et drøyt år siden.
2004 vintage
Taster #5431
· Oct 20, 2017
Musigny theme'd dinner at Summer Pavilion. TBU - hard to pick a favourite between this and the 06 Vogue Musigny. Anyway, these 2 round up my top 3 wines of the night...
2004 vintage
Taster #5607
· Oct 20, 2017
Theme: Musigny Grand Crus 13% Beautiful ruby. Sweet nose, cinnamon, blueberry, black currant, floral. Just incredible, So fresh and seductive! The savouriness, the sweeetnes, the finesse and elegance yet so much substance. Truly iron fist in the velvet glove. Fresh and great length. Truly captivating! Drinking at its peak and wil stay there for very long time. My WOTN
2004 vintage
Taster #4929
· Mar 30, 2017
94/100
2004 Burgundy Grand Cru Dinner (Holland Park) : Not up there with Mugnier's very best examples from Musigny, but this was nevertheless an absolutely lovely wine, and drinking wonderfully at the moment as well. The nose did feel slightly green and herby, more so than many of the other 2004s on show, but this was wrapped up in a full, generous bouquet of blueberries ringed with a beautiful perfume of lovely florals and whiffs of smokiness. It was such a …
2004 vintage
Taster #6329
· Oct 18, 2016
93/100
Subtil på duft, dog meget elegant. Lyse røde bær leker seg i bakgrunnen, florale toner, spice og litt edelt trevirke. Lekkert, men ligger et lite stykke bak sine søsken i bedre årganger. Åpner seg mer med luft og den blomstrer i større grad. Legger på seg. Meget elegant munnfølelse. Lettbeint og helt uten skarpe kanter. Så luftig og vektløs som bare Burgund kan bli. Medium konsentrert, fresh frukt og et fint syrespill. Lekker balanse på denne. Smooth i utgangen med …
2004 vintage
Taster #4899
· Oct 7, 2016
92/100
Poker night - Reds double blind - 91 Musar, 09 Coche Perrieres, 67 Marthas and etc. : Served blind by Paul. Strong note of stem, my guess is Dujac CDR from 2008. I tell Paul that he better not brought the 04. Strong stem but not obvious LBT. Subtle blackberry fruit, strong stem, black pepper and earth. Medium concentration, stem like dry note and medium finish. Not a bad wine but not worth the price.
2004 vintage
Taster #7665
· Sep 3, 2016
95/100
Fresh, subtle, herby full of life and with depth. A great moment...
2004 vintage
Taster #2107
· Jul 29, 2016
No '04 mean green here, lovely floral aroma. Quite enjoyable, though it didn't have the miraculous precision and delineation that the best examples of Musigny possess. I rate this a very good wine, but only a middling Musigny.
2004 vintage
Taster #4941
· Apr 17, 2016
94/100
香气独特且集中,有些生青,入口平衡度高。
2004 vintage
Taster #2538
· Sep 25, 2015
92/100
Freddy Mugnier dinner at Jade Palace. Very dark in appearance, in fact more opaque like as compared to the 2006. This too, was very similar in bouquet to the 2006, with a lovely rich and intense perfume from red roses and violets, with wild strawberries, grapefruit, blueberries and orange zest. This had a touch of green-ness, but nothing as sinsister at the Roumier Cras. This had more structure and power as compared to the 2006, with lots of red and …
2004 vintage
Taster #5431
· Sep 25, 2015
Clearly a step-up from the '94... as good as the '06, with a beautiful nose of roses, berries, intermixed with dang-gui (a Chinese herb) which some may identify as a touch of greenness... Nice silky/cool palate, with red-dark berries and some mushrooms. A very, very enjoyable wine, considering that this was from the '04 vintage!
2004 vintage
Taster #4330
· Jan 27, 2015
92/100
From magnum, this is not a big one but good enough to blow my mind. After 2 hours, the scent of beautiful Musigny shows up, the silky texture, medium-bodied with a soft landing, lovely long finish. 92-93/100 I love the style of Mugnier more than Roumier. (at this moment)
2004 vintage
Taster #8896
· Apr 25, 2014
Medium red. Aggressively peppery, menthol aromatics right out of the bottle. Eventually, some red fruit rises. Medium weight. The pleasant fruit and hint of sap are swamped by harshness and the herbaceousness which was strongly reprised on the finish. Nowhere near Grand Cru quality, much less that of Musigny. The half full bottle was a heartbreaking sight as we left the table, but that was all we could manage.
2004 vintage
Taster #1320
· Jun 30, 2013
93/100
Dry earth, tubereuse, strawberry. Light silky tannin. No greens despite vintage. Long finish. #wine
2004 vintage
Taster #6440
· Mar 15, 2013
91/100
Tasted at the Gala dinner La Paulee NYC. Couldn't get past the green elements in the nose. Nice on the palate.
2004 vintage
Taster #9184
· Dec 13, 2012
88/100
Had pulled 2 other Burgs but Jay had brought a Musigny so I thought I would see what we had that might be drinkable in that department. Settled on this to see where it was at. This would divide people along the lines that this vintage divides people. There's the green, semi-stemmy smelling, vegetative, herbal, green peppercorn streak on the nose and in the palate. Undeniably there but not in a truly disgusting level or manner. Under it there is …
2004 vintage