Mount Veeder Winery, Reserve, Napa Valley
Mount Veeder Winery · California › Napa Valley › United States of America
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
90
/100
Reviews
118
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
114114
Reviews
89.6
Avg Score
95
Highest
Taster #9360
· Dec 26, 2025
1st bottle was weirdly corked with a nose that developed into ammonia, flat taste. Second bottle from cellar in perfect condition; nose of dark fruits and plum with notes of bitter chocolate, some sweet oak; palate tastes of rich ripe cherry w/ some currant, complex secondary notes of herbs, after-scents of sweet cherry tobacco; smooth texture with everything integrated but still bright. Delicious with rack of lamb. Won't improve past this.
1999 vintage
Taster #9649
· Sep 25, 2025
92/100
OENO VAULT Tasting, really nice drinking spot, little if no amber, nice bouquet, fruit still showing, finish maybe a bit short but nice. WOTN 92+
1995 vintage
Taster #3298
· Feb 21, 2025
94/100
Had this at a dinner with a friend over a tomahawk steak. I did not take notes at dinner because that annoys people but this wine still has a ton of youth in it. From memory: Nose: Eucalyptus, tobacco, leather, brambly dark fruit, dusty library Palate: Dark berry fruit and plenty of acidity on the finish. Tannins have smoothed out with age but aren't entirely gone. This wine has those great tertiary aged notes but still a ton of fruit …
1990 vintage
Taster #3923
· Jan 27, 2024
I let this air for about 90 minutes. Soft transparent red color. Faint aromas of red fruits. Smooth and polished on the palate. Muted red fruits and a distinct green note. Fine, drying tannins. Nice acidity and balance. Finishes long but faint with dark fruits. Past peak but it must have been lovely in its youth.
1990 vintage
Taster #6493
· Apr 14, 2022
91/100
This has a rich, oaky, opulence to it that's classy and although I'll invoke a lot of descriptors that I generally use negatively this isn't a bad wine. In fact, it's delightful in the way that old Cali wines often are: forward, full flavor, cocoa, espresso, Ribena, tobacco, suave tannin, ever so slightly sweet from a toasty oak treatment. Sometimes this style really hits the spot.
1991 vintage
Taster #5613
· Jan 14, 2022
91/100
Popped n poured with zero expectations. What a pleasant surprise to find this wine drinking quite nicely, still with plenty of sweet fruit--more dried than fresh fruit, however--with some spice, and a slight earthy pruniness. Tannins fully resolved. The wine looks its age but certainly was very well-preserved in my cellar for all of these years.
2000 vintage
Taster #6121
· Apr 23, 2021
92/100
Purchased at auction with reported good provenance. Still with light purplish color and mild bricking. On the nose matured cabernet nose with strong herbs and some musty cherries. Initially a little thin on the palate with a bordeaux-like herbaceous quality to the fruit. Good balancing acidity and light tannins which again, gave it a thinner feel to the body. Not much improved in the first two hours. Started by finally come around on hour 3 although not much wine left …
1990 vintage
Taster #4267
· Sep 26, 2020
91/100
Upon opening we thought... vinegar. Put it back In The bottle and opened something else. Two hours later went back and WOW! Funk was gone and the fruit shined. Tannins were showing beautiful and it was still pretty complex. No question this should be drank now, but don’t be scared upon opening!! This was a very cool bottle to drink and kept showing different things as we drank over the next hour. ****grab a screen or filter- this thing had …
1990 vintage
Taster #8128
· Aug 15, 2020
Its twin was too old when drunk in summer 2020. Open yesterday and hope for best, prepare for borderline undrinkable.
2000 vintage
Taster #4200
· May 4, 2020
Vinegar
1990 vintage
Taster #0462
· Feb 6, 2020
87/100
Purchased from a liquor store auction for <$10. At that price its was worth rolling the dice as it was mixed into a lot of other bottles I was interested in. The fact that the wine sat mid neck was promising. The cork was super soft and nearly split when opening. I could easily squeeze the cork and break it in half. It poured garnet and initially had a very musky mold nose. Had I judged the bottle on the …
2000 vintage
Taster #7088
· Apr 6, 2019
90/100
Couleur brique avec teinte brune au pourtour, on voit bien l'âge. Nez sur les prunes, cerise noire, viande, chocolat et fumé. En bouche, on retrouve sensiblement la même chose que les arômes, mais la finale est caramélisée et un peu alcoleuse (même si seulement 13.5%). Pas des plus complexes mais agréable seul ou avec plat tomaté acide pour balancer le sucre.
2000 vintage
Taster #2861
· Jan 19, 2019
95/100
Bordeaux Perfection! This Reserve blend from an excellent vintage by an excellent producer is one sets the benchmark standard. Give it an hour to really excel, but the floral aroma is immediately wafting around the room and the luscious foamy blackberry is completely smooth and beautiful. I remain a HUGE fan.
2001 vintage
Taster #5121
· Sep 10, 2018
90/100
Smooth, ripe and sweeter then I expected.
2001 vintage
Taster #2861
· Aug 16, 2018
93/100
Magical California Bordeaux! Absolutely perfect blend of floral bouquet and black cherry/blackberry aroma that was wonderfully smooth. Definitely not past its best at age 17.
2001 vintage
Taster #1357
· Apr 18, 2018
90/100
Pnp. The nose opens up with plum, tea leafs, tobacco, earth and mushroom. Palate is initially old and tired. After 20 mins, the acidity slowly emerges with sweet dark fruit and tea. The tannins are resolved. Perhaps drinking off the peak but the tertiary amd secondary note are enjoyable. 90+
1991 vintage
Taster #7259
· Apr 16, 2018
90/100
Very nice at 18 years old. Everything is still present here a very well kept bottle.
2000 vintage
Taster #8348
· Sep 5, 2016
88/100
Soft and flat. Mellow, dark fruit. Time to drink up!
1999 vintage
Taster #2861
· Aug 10, 2016
92/100
Delightful! Just the right fruit balanced perfectly. Great floral aroma. Lucious blackberry dark cherry Bordeaux like magic. Mt Veeder mixed the magic elixir years ago.
2001 vintage
Taster #1129
· Apr 2, 2016
88/100
Pleasant, though quite simple and oddly a touch too sweet and almost nonexistent secondary notes. Not the profile I would expect for a 25 year old wine.
1991 vintage
Taster #6558
· Feb 20, 2016
89/100
Used for the 25th Anniversary party as the toast.
1991 vintage
Taster #3848
· Oct 26, 2015
Vinegar
2000 vintage
Taster #0975
· Jul 18, 2015
94/100
Best for last. This was my last bottle, and probably the best of them all. Wonderful layering of 5 nobles but with a clear California over-ripeness. Some dried herbs, sweet Oak and hints of cassis. 20 second finish and near silky on palate.
1991 vintage
Taster #0975
· May 15, 2015
90/100
Not my best bottle over the past year. It took about 30 minutes for the funk/age to blow off, but even then this bottle was a bit tired compared to others I've had recently. Still, however, a perfectly lovely Meritage with red, black and blue fruits in that order, soft Oak, dill and other herbs.
1991 vintage
Taster #0975
· Mar 13, 2015
92/100
Not the best of the 6-pack but still quite tasty. Nicely layered black, blue and red fruits with some leather notes and sweet Oak.
1991 vintage
Taster #0975
· Mar 7, 2015
93/100
There is some funk when first opening, but after 30 to 40 minutes, the wine comes around fully. Sweet and perky black, blue and red fruits, a little bit of spice and sweet Oak. Very smooth wine with a 20 second finish. A real bargain.
1991 vintage
Taster #1145
· Feb 18, 2015
My winner at a special lunch amongst 4 older Napa cabs. Bordeaux style age and balance. Beautiful.
2001 vintage
Taster #0975
· Feb 5, 2015
93/100
Another excellent bottle. Pop and pour and within 15 minutes in the glass it was fully blooming. Beautiful layers of black, blue and some red fruits. A little leather and dried herbs too. Very smooth with a 20+ second finish.
1991 vintage
Taster #0975
· Jan 17, 2015
91/100
This bottle was from a differnt auction lot than prior bottles and although the storage seems great (into neck, solid cork and capsule and color) this bottle was clearly more advanced than others I've had. The fruit had started to fade a bit, although still present and very enjoyable. Both overripe and slightly sour red fruits with black fruits in the background, sweet Oak, some hints of leather and tobacco.
1991 vintage
Taster #2716
· Dec 12, 2014
89/100
had to decant for about an hour to open up and settle. Not past prime, but a bit weak once opened up. Would not rush to get again. Will not put more of this Winery in my collection.
1996 vintage
Taster #0975
· Sep 27, 2014
94/100
Very solid cork. Just into neck fill. Surpisingly little bricking and solid purple to core. Slightly sour black cherries, blue berries and hints of raspberry. I love the 5 Noble Grapes blend. Some cedar and pencil shavings with very modest sweet Oak. The tannins still had some backbone but they were pliable, smooth and long. Finish was 30 seconds. Very little sediment. A really impressive bottle that could have gone another 5+ years with ease. Extra point for its ageworthiness. …
1991 vintage
Taster #3848
· Aug 3, 2014
85/100
I bought this wine at a small liquor store that had a lot of gems, if they were cared for properly. The cork crumbled and the entire flavor profile was muted.
2000 vintage
Taster #0648
· Jun 29, 2014
91/100
worried that I waited too long but was wrong. Aged color but not yet bricking. A little barnyard on the nose. Still some tannnic structure but I think it is time to drink now to the next 2 years. Balanced red fruit flavors and integrated oak. Could use some complexity.
2001 vintage
Taster #7099
· Jun 16, 2014
better yet. still primary. sorry that it's my last bottle.
2001 vintage
Taster #3848
· May 26, 2014
84/100
I tried this wine three weeks ago and decided to go back to the hole in the wall liquor store to get the rest of the bottles that were on the shelf. There was absolutely no oak present, the wine had a brownish hue and was a bit flat. I have five other opportunities to revisit this bottling.
2000 vintage
Taster #0277
· Dec 1, 2013
94/100
Was a bit overpowering on day 1, but really opened up on day 2. It was actually quite amazing.
2001 vintage
Taster #9044
· Sep 13, 2013
91/100
I was afraid this had lost it's punch but not at all. Was delicious with a filet roast - wow - glad I saved it until now.
2001 vintage
Taster #8348
· Aug 26, 2013
90/100
Full bodied. Lush Cabernet that lacked complexity
2001 vintage
Taster #9651
· Aug 24, 2012
91/100
Still going strong, might even last another several years. Showing hints of garnet color. Otherwise typical Mt Veeder.
2000 vintage
Taster #7841
· Jun 10, 2012
92/100
Drank with a standing rib roast prepared on the grill for Mothers' Day. Really a wonderful wine. Complex and long lasting.
2001 vintage
Taster #9438
· Apr 22, 2012
90/100
Domestics 10 Years Old and Older (Pittsburgh Blue, Edina, MN) : Small pour. Nice, earthy, cassis, blackberry, young, spice, tobacco, firm tannins.
2001 vintage
Taster #3059
· Feb 28, 2012
92/100
Very nice. A little modern and Oakey but still very nice.
2001 vintage
Taster #7841
· Feb 9, 2012
93/100
Served at a fund raising dinner (6 courses and 6 wines). This was the hit of the evening.
2001 vintage
Taster #0277
· Feb 3, 2012
94/100
Drank even better than the last one. After a bit of decanting, it's just amazingly smooth. Tannins are so well integrated, you barely notice. Nose has a tons of fruit.
2001 vintage
Taster #8690
· Jan 23, 2012
94/100
drank over 3 days; just amazing 1990 napa wine; still has a lot of tannins left; after 1 hour, the initial funk went away and left with earth, leather, and mushroom; wine still taste fresh (amazing); what a wonderful experience; 3 left in the cellar
1990 vintage
Taster #7533
· Jan 9, 2012
89/100
Open 2 hours. Dark ripe fruits, a hint of cedar on the nose. Good concentration, ripe fruits, a little port like, some bitter chocolate and bitter tannin on the palate. Drank well with grilled steak, but too simple and lacking zest or excitement. A little disappointing, especially for the vintage which is supposed to be great, but maybe it gets better with some aging. Doesn't seem to have the structure though. P.S., Well, the last glass, after 4 hours, was …
2001 vintage
Taster #1958
· Jan 9, 2012
93/100
Did not have much to offer when first opened. The second night (after being on argon) it became a very pleasurable wine. The tannins are well integrated and the nose, taste and finish all represent a fine aged California cab blend. Should drink well for another 5 years with adequate decant time and airation.
1991 vintage
Taster #7099
· Jan 7, 2012
Decanted, then consumed over dinner. Garnet with looong legs. Cherry and tobacco with a hint of lead pencil in the nose. Cherry with underlying tree fruit, tobacco, spice, and barely perceptible tannins in the mouth after a moderate finish. Nicely mature and drinkable.
2001 vintage
Taster #7421
· Jan 1, 2012
92/100
This bottle surprised me, as I wasn't expecting much given the CT reviews and the poorly rated 2000 vintage from Napa. Blend of 5 grapes from a tough year in Napa. Maybe it just needed more time.
2000 vintage
Taster #8607
· Oct 3, 2011
92/100
I bought this wine in the early 90's for probably 15$; it was a 3 puffer by the Connessuer's Guide and a 90+ RP as I recall. Perhaps unwarrantedly (due to its lack of pedigree) well-cellared throughout its life here. Contrary to other CT members experience I found it remarkably youthful: med ruby w/ only the faintest beginning of bricking at the rim, clean mod effusive spicy blackberry-minty nose with same flavors held together w/ fine-grained tannins for a nice …
1991 vintage