Chateau Faizeau, Selection Vieilles Vignes, Montagne-Saint-Emilion
Chateau Faizeau · Bordeaux › Montagne-Saint-Emilion › France
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
89
/100
Reviews
34
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
3838
Reviews
89.2
Avg Score
96
Highest
Taster #8889
· Mar 22, 2025
89/100
Nydelig st Emilio’s. spist til biff
2015 vintage
Taster #8047
· Jul 25, 2023
89/100
A 'Lost Cellar' wine found deep in a corner of my cellar this wine opened in good shape with a still deep colour and a mature nose of dark plums, blackberry and dark raspberries with touches of charcoal and liquorice. The palate is nicely rounded and while the finish is a little attenuated it remains a very pleasant bottle of Merlot.
1998 vintage
Taster #2513
· Apr 2, 2021
94/100
Deep dark ruby, dense. Sweet berries, plums, fruitcake, chocolate. Soft and silky up front, notable acidity and fine tannins on the finish. Black, red and blue berries, plums, sweet cherry, chocolate, lightly earthy, hints of tar spice, smooth and beautifully balanced. Delicious drinking, definitely ready now.
1998 vintage
Taster #0810
· Jan 11, 2020
92/100
Incredible bouquet. Gorgeous garnet color. Nice legs. A smooth, smoky, chocolatey flavor, with nice tannins and aftertaste. Really good.
2015 vintage
Taster #0384
· May 18, 2019
92/100
Decanted a few hours. Ripe and round with a great finish. Good concentration and structure. Plumby with dark chocolate and gooseberry notes. Drink 2020-2030.
2015 vintage
Taster #9015
· May 21, 2018
89/100
Made from 100% old vine Merlot, the wine is soft, silky, ripe and sweet, with accents of licorice, dark chocolate, licorice and a kiss of oak in the finish.
2015 vintage
Taster #8318
· Mar 8, 2018
92/100
Very consistent, a very, very good wine, rich yet refined. Similar tasting notes to my prior, just all a notch up, I gave it more time to unfold and breathe. Solid juice.
2004 vintage
Taster #1154
· Feb 11, 2018
90/100
Kraftig, lukket, trenger 5-10 års lagring
2015 vintage
Taster #8318
· Jan 15, 2018
92/100
Not sure where the green notes came from on other reviews, nor anything chemical. This hit very nice. Dark fruit, plum and blackberry maybe, leather, good texture. Can feel the meaty thing more by an iron-kinda-mouth-feel from a rare steak if you will. More a nuance than a flavor. Softened tannins, and very light to be honest. Didn't match the weight of the flavor profile, interesting. I liked it, and it really hit home. Had this bottle for years in …
2004 vintage
Taster #0767
· Aug 25, 2016
90/100
Improved since 2013. a very nice St Emillion but not exceptional, good structure, still nice tannins and Very nice nose - Cassis licorice blueberry. A little bit smokey? What will this do in 6 months?
1998 vintage
Taster #9961
· Jul 12, 2016
90/100
Chunky on opening. Still holding together. Nice Merlot dominating the palate.
1998 vintage
Taster #9015
· Apr 29, 2016
88/100
Using 100% old vine Merlot, the wine is fresh, spicy, forward and offers a mineral, spicy, oak, thyme and plum finish.
2015 vintage
Taster #9961
· Jun 15, 2015
96/100
Great out of the bottle improving only marginally with air. Some complexity. Very chalky on the palate. Medium palate. Enjoyable. Faded the second night. Drink now.
1998 vintage
Taster #0950
· Jun 4, 2015
Dead wine.
1998 vintage
Taster #2914
· Apr 2, 2015
84/100
Thin and fading wait too long
1998 vintage
Taster #0784
· Jan 20, 2015
86/100
Green nose, with some damp forest aromas and secondary hints of leather and hidden fruit that turned oaky and meaty as the wine opened. Some brick red on the edges of deep reddish-purple in the glass. Medium-thin mouthfeel with moderate mouth-drying tannins. Short finish with an unpleasant chemical aftertaste.
2004 vintage
Taster #9961
· Oct 27, 2014
89/100
Interesting. More complexity than last tasted but fruit starting to fade even though length still good. Still delicious for the price
1998 vintage
Taster #0950
· Jan 8, 2014
90/100
Last bottle and the best of them all by a good margin. Purplish maroon color didn't give away the age. And a good solid core of fruit (which other bottles lacked to this degree) held up throughout the two hours it took us to consume this. The finish only barely started to crack toward the very end. Love that the back label advises to "drink within five years".
1998 vintage
Taster #6678
· Dec 25, 2013
88/100
decanted for about 2 hours before drinking over christmas dinner with prime rib. nose was a touch green, almost piney. On the palate the wine was nice, dark fruit, with a nice finish. Wish I had more.
2004 vintage
Taster #2887
· Aug 10, 2013
87/100
Sent of mint, spice. A bit of tannin left, not much. Over all very good with my pepper, chipotle brisket.
2004 vintage
Taster #0767
· May 19, 2013
89/100
Drank last night. Decanted for about 45 minutes. Very nice mellow, classic right bank merlot. Light subdued tannins, nice mellow hints of berry and good color. My guess is this wine will be fine for 3 to 5 more years.
1998 vintage
Taster #0950
· Jan 30, 2013
88/100
Excellent bottle that held up perfectly over two hours of drinking; and it showed better than some more exalted right bank 98's have recently.
1998 vintage
Taster #3136
· Nov 24, 2012
88/100
Surprised to find this wine still very much alive. Fruit is nearly gone but structure is still there. Not very complex, but well balanced.
1998 vintage
Taster #3246
· May 21, 2012
86/100
Unfortunately this bottle wasn't showing as well as the one last year. I'm a bit concerned that it might be heading a bit downhill. Never really gave much on the nose and the finish was particularly bitter. I'm not all that sensitive to TCA so I suppose it's possible that this was just a touch affected, though the telltale signs of cardboard and wet basement weren't present.
1998 vintage
Taster #8314
· Sep 6, 2011
Très beau vin, un fruit encore très présent et une bouche soyeuse. Tout est là...un vin à point. presque Wow
1998 vintage
Taster #8314
· Sep 5, 2011
91/100
Très beau vin, un fruit encore très présent et une bouche soyeuse. Tout est là...un vin à point. presque Wow
1998 vintage
Taster #7320
· Apr 28, 2011
last one! Still not drinking any better than I recall from initial tasting. Great nose, nice first taste, but very thin, lacking in body. Pleasant enough but not noteworthy
2004 vintage
Taster #3246
· Apr 6, 2011
89/100
Consumed last night at a local italian fine dining establishment. 100% Merlot, pruney with light tobacco and graphite notes. Opened a little with time. Tannins are fairly mature and somewhat subdued with a fine grained texture. Overall, not complex or all that concentrated, but just nicely aged right bank Bordeaux. I'll drink my last two bottles over the next few years.
1998 vintage
Taster #7320
· Feb 9, 2011
could have purchased a california cab for $5.00 less and enjoyed it more
2004 vintage
Taster #9961
· Jan 30, 2010
87/100
Big tannins, but fruit was either missing or restained/'sleeping'. Gained some complexity over time but not great.
1998 vintage
Taster #5391
· Jul 26, 2009
85/100
I think I i will give this another six month's to a year and try again. I popped the cork and took a small sample - a little closed. I decanted for about an hour and had a glass. It was quite tannic with muted fruit. I thought I could see potential though. I vacuum sealed it and left the remainder for the next day. I thought there was a little improvement but not enough. At this point I couldn't …
2004 vintage
Taster #9873
· Mar 1, 2009
89/100
Popped and decanted. Nose (major)- strong red currant, cedar, clove, smoky black cherry. Nose (hints)- cassis, smoke, black cherry. Palate- medium bodied, nice thick spicy cedar tannins from oak, long black cherry finish, great length, hint of currants, woody finish. Criticisms- Acid + fruit on midpalate could be bolder but otherwise very good. Might improve with more time in bottle. Wine Style / Quality Rating: B+. The best I have tasted from Montagne-St. Emilion. Value Rating: A-. Great value for …
2004 vintage
Taster #6322
· Feb 28, 2009
90/100
Purchased on release for $18. Popped and poured at Kiki's Bistro. This was a wonderful little surprise. A nice mature Merlot-based claret that has attractive small-berry fruit and fine-grained tannins. Well-balanced. Assertive enough to to stand up to a smoky cassoulet and steak au poivre, but delicate enough to make you linger over each sip. Makes me want to seek out some more lesser-known Right Bankers from '98.
1998 vintage
Taster #5824
· Aug 9, 2008
93/100
Great nose; Excellent palatte; Good build, depth; Strong; Tannic
2004 vintage
Taster #8657
· May 20, 2007
85/100
Classic bordeaux flavours of leather and currant, great value wine - a step up from your every day bottles, wish I had bougth more.
1998 vintage
Taster #2971
· Nov 19, 2005
88/100
Didn't have time to decant, and that was a mistake. Started out failry lightweight, but gained weight with time. A shorter finish than I'd hoped for, but a reasonable though unexciting wine overall (B+).
1998 vintage
Taster #6198
· Aug 22, 2002
85/100
not as good as a St. Emilion - a little weaker (this is a satellite wine)
1998 vintage
Taster #2159
· Jul 2, 2001
92/100
Opaque mulberry with purple rim. Intense nose of currants, oak, cedar, blackberries and plum. Full-bodied with massive, mouth-puckering tannins. Plummy and jammy mid-palate, long tannic finish. This is an outstanding wine, especially for the price. It has the "stuffing" to age very well.
1998 vintage