Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92
/100
Reviews
79
professional
Vintages
1
2018
Other
92/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
8686
Reviews
92.0
Avg Score
99
Highest
Taster #5860
· Feb 15, 2026
92/100
Red fruit, cherries, hint of strawberry - but not sweet. Light but fulfilling in the mouth. I last drank this 4 years ago and feel this most recent tasting found it a bit sharper and acidic in the mouth. It drank noticeably better an hour after opening. This was a last minute PnP and was drinkable on first pour. I attempted an aerator on a couple of slips but the wine suffered severely. After an hour of slowly enjoying the …
2018 vintage
Taster #7707
· Jan 17, 2026
84/100
Maybe the most disappointing WS wine we have ever had. It was cellared perfectly so there are no issues there and the wine was not corked. First hint of mediocrity was the nose or lack thereof. Color looked fine but it tasted thin, flabby and lacked any real character or complexity. Unfortunately it was the second wine of the night so we drank it behind a wonderful RRV Pinot from Eastside vineyards that was about 60% the cost of this …
2018 vintage
Taster #1403
· Dec 29, 2025
94/100
Drinking beautifully in December 2025. Still a bit of tanin holding on to string fruit that lingers in the palette. Delightfully complex. A wonderful example of the WS style.
2018 vintage
Taster #7504
· Oct 25, 2025
92/100
PnP. Nose: fresh cherry. Rose petal and potpourri. Palate: fresh cranberry, cherry, spices. Nice finish.
2018 vintage
Taster #0197
· Oct 2, 2025
88/100
Way too soon, like a decade.
2018 vintage
Taster #3368
· Jul 25, 2025
95/100
A beautiful wine. Texture complex, jumping out of the glass.
2018 vintage
Taster #2021
· Jul 11, 2025
Med ruby color. Med intensity nose of cranberry, raspberry, potpourri, cedar and forest floor. Medium + acidity, high alcohol, med tannins, med body, med + intensity flavors of raspberry, cedar and forest floor with a long lingering finish. Very good. Could probably go another 3 years.
2018 vintage
Taster #9911
· Jun 4, 2025
93/100
Ripe fruit great balance. Nice nose rich.
2018 vintage
Taster #5662
· Apr 2, 2025
90/100
Beautiful ruby color and very pleasant mouth feel. Cherry and a touch of strawberry fruit. A little vanilla toward the end. A slight but noticeable sharpness throughout. A nice Pinot, light on its feet but missing some complexity.
2018 vintage
Taster #6492
· Apr 2, 2025
92/100
For a week day wine, it was nice. Not complex, but enjoyable with shrimp scampi
2018 vintage
Taster #2353
· Apr 2, 2025
89/100
VA bomb. Tart. Hope a bottle variation. Crushed :(
2018 vintage
Taster #9413
· Feb 26, 2025
94/100
Drinking excellently right now. Full, opulent mouthfeel upon opening, rich with bacon fat. It mellows in the glass and carob, chocolate an baking spices with vanilla and cinnamon cone out.
2018 vintage
Taster #5662
· Feb 26, 2025
91/100
Ruby color and really nice mouthfeel—not too sharp, not too plush, juuuuust right. Red raspberry and cherry fruit, then some baking spice. Nicely balanced finish.
2018 vintage
Taster #5662
· Feb 21, 2025
88/100
Medium to light ruby in color. A little thin across the tongue. Plenty of sweet cherry fruit and some surprising minerality. Not much complexity but just enough oak to give it a finish instead of wondering what happened to it in your mouth. 3/11/2025 Pretty much the same experience with this bottle. I see most of the higher ratings from the community came a couple of years ago so perhaps this one is already past its prime. 6/6/2025 Apparently coming …
2018 vintage
Taster #3368
· Feb 8, 2025
90/100
Not a blockbuster but showed very well
2018 vintage
Taster #8784
· Jan 18, 2025
94/100
Light & delicious. Cherries, vanilla. Nice acidity & sweetness. Much better after an hour.
2018 vintage
Taster #3830
· Jan 16, 2025
92/100
Immediately open with a cola-heavy red fruit nose. Pleasant acidity. Only a touch of tannin left - and I’d drink up. As the wine sits the aromas of hazelnuts and a bit of mint emerge. Excellent showing for an entry-level WS Pinot.
2018 vintage
Taster #1078
· Dec 29, 2024
90/100
Aromas of dark cherry and floral; flavors of dark cherry, minerals (earthiness) and pomegranate. The light rose color confused me as did the faster than usual legs for a pinot. The finish was longer than I was expecting. My conclusion was an adequate wine, but there are better ones at this price point. NOTE: please be aware that Williams Selyem has recently been sold and transferred to new owners.
2018 vintage
Taster #8109
· Dec 19, 2024
92/100
Williams Selyem Dinner (Jardin Du Jade, G/F, Sun Hung Kai Centre, Wan Chai, Hong Kong) : More opaque than its Foss Vineyard sister. we drank alongside but same semi-transparent purple-tinged ruby colour. Nose is quite closed...cloves. Palate is quite sharp, red cherry. Still young. Tighter than its sister but smooths out a lot with time in the glass. Elegant. Really well-made in a restrained style. Grew to 92 after initially coming from behind. Too young for me but I could …
2018 vintage
Taster #4059
· Nov 15, 2024
93/100
Opens with cherries and raspberries, transitioning to notes of light mushrooms and forest floor with some oak influence. On the lighter and more elegant side of pinot. Nice balance between sweetness on the open and acidity on the finish. 13.6% ABV. This is still fairly primary, and can probably go for at least 5-10 more years, and perhaps further develop those secondary notes.
2018 vintage
Taster #7597
· Nov 10, 2024
90/100
w nice fish dish, halibut with potatoes (stew like). yummy meal. good combo. this needs to be drunk. solid wine. good fruit and body.
2018 vintage
Taster #7528
· Aug 11, 2024
91/100
Wine Rating Methodology 96-100: One of the most enjoyable wines I have ever tasted. I would not hesitate to open this wine for any Master of Wine. 91-95: Extremely enjoyable wine that I would drink and buy again. Fantastic to open up for those who appreciate wine. 85-90: Decent to good wine. Weekday bottle you don’t feel guilty about not finishing. Below 85: would not drink or buy again. ***Price of wine vs. enjoyment (value) is taken into consideration
2018 vintage
Taster #6492
· Jul 31, 2024
96/100
What a great wine! Smooth fruit forward and beautiful mouthfeel.
2018 vintage
Taster #9092
· Jul 22, 2024
93/100
Tasts very similar to 2017: spicy, soft, juicy, long finish. Crowd pleaser
2018 vintage
Taster #8575
· Jun 8, 2024
93/100
Perfectly delightful.
2018 vintage
Taster #4929
· May 26, 2024
92/100
Mix of sour and dark cherries.
2018 vintage
Taster #6983
· Feb 24, 2024
94/100
Lovely brambly mossy damp forest nose. Chiseled, lighter body with great balance and pleasing acidity, super soft and light tannins. Raspberry jam on the palate.
2018 vintage
Taster #9293
· Feb 14, 2024
95/100
think the people on this site are a bit hard on grading. Opened and had with lamb and it was magnificent. Still looked like it was brand new.
2018 vintage
Taster #0975
· Jan 15, 2024
93/100
Red fruit and pure elegance. A real treat.
2018 vintage
Taster #6492
· Jan 7, 2024
92/100
Lovely med bodied pinot. Great with pizza!!
2018 vintage
Taster #8114
· Dec 24, 2023
92/100
Light in color, nose rich with red fruit and clove. Medium body, well integrated tannins - medium finish - very pretty
2018 vintage
Taster #1142
· Nov 5, 2023
87/100
Drink now!
2018 vintage
Taster #8069
· Nov 4, 2023
92/100
Drinking beautifully right now, medium-bodied @14.1%, but still light on its feet. Lots of life ahead but singing on a fall evening.
2018 vintage
Taster #6840
· Oct 9, 2023
99/100
Eh
2018 vintage
Taster #6118
· Sep 13, 2023
89/100
A little tart initially but became a little softer as the evening progress. Just OK.
2018 vintage
Taster #6710
· Sep 10, 2023
90/100
On the lighter side, nice fruit but not much depth for my personal pallet. Paired with grilled lamb chops and went well. I prefer something a bit more full bodied but we enjoyed it.
2018 vintage
Taster #6492
· Jul 22, 2023
94/100
Strawberries and cherries; soft, elegant and understated. Slightly acidic, so wait 2 - 3 years for the next bottle
2018 vintage
Taster #5549
· Jul 13, 2023
90/100
Very well made and drinking nicely. Nothing especially memorable in my mind. Solid effort, which we received as a gift. Probably would not put my own money into it, given other options.
2018 vintage
Taster #5187
· Jun 28, 2023
Shared by friends. Strawberry, earth, floral, cinnamon, and a hint of vanilla bean. A little bit of noticeable heat, med body, med acidity, long spicy finish.
2018 vintage
Taster #9413
· Jun 11, 2023
93/100
Perfectly balanced with raspberries and red cherries up front and long finish with minerality. Drink now!
2018 vintage
Taster #4510
· May 19, 2023
93/100
Trenger litt tid for å åpne seg skikkelig, men for en deilig pinot! Lilla farge. Duft av søte bringebær, tre, nyper. Sødmefull, saftig, fresch pinot, flott struktur, fin syre, sitter rimelig lenge, bra konsentrasjon, relativt moden nå, kan nok fint ligge noen år til, men er veldig bra nå. Liker dette godt og kom seg veldig ut over kvelden.
2018 vintage
Taster #7352
· May 3, 2023
91/100
Light red in color. Almost translucent. 13.9% ABV. Sourced from Calegari, Foss, Terra de Promissio, Drake Estate and Williams Selyem Estate Vineyards. Pretty nose of red fruits, cola and flowers. Light to medium body with ample acidity. Fresh, crisp and vibrant. Cherry, cranberry, iron and minerals on the palate. Tremendous length on the finish. Light and delicate Pinot Noir that could not be more delicious. Drink this while you wait a little longer on the single vineyard designates. Best over …
2018 vintage
Taster #1179
· Mar 25, 2023
95/100
Can taste the minerality, which doesn’t seems normal for a California Pinot. Not too much acid, which really keeps the finish very smooth.
2018 vintage
Taster #2612
· Mar 16, 2023
91/100
Typical WS Pinot…plush and flavorful, with a little elegance
2018 vintage
Taster #4498
· Mar 10, 2023
90/100
This was great and was enjoyed with some friends while playing cards. Great dark fruit and silky tannins. No complaints - good value.
2018 vintage
Taster #0194
· Feb 5, 2023
Opened 1 hour prior, brought to restaurant. Black tea notes with subdued red fruits with some forest floor. Fruit seems lacking. Drank ok but not up to previous vintages.
2018 vintage
Taster #2612
· Dec 27, 2022
94/100
Same as last bottle…epic
2018 vintage
Taster #2612
· Dec 3, 2022
94/100
Plush and flavorful…another winner from WS
2018 vintage
Taster #5821
· Nov 30, 2022
This wine is terrific and became a good lesson in consuming well made Pinot Noir. Do not be afraid to open a bottle early! This started out as classic Sonoma Coast pinot, well balanced acid and dark bright fruit nesting underneath. Drinking well, especially with dinner. An hour and a half later the fruit erupted and now it’s so wonderful from start to finish with the fruit prominent in all aspects. Always open early, espeif the wine is on the …
2018 vintage
Taster #9413
· Nov 25, 2022
92/100
Lovely, delicate balanced wine with raspberries, red fruit and spices such as vanilla
2018 vintage