Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91
/100
Reviews
18
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
2424
Reviews
90.5
Avg Score
93
Highest
Taster #4047
· Dec 21, 2025
oxidized
2007 vintage
Taster #6750
· Oct 21, 2021
Too far evolved with the faded fruit giving way to a lot of wood.
2007 vintage
Taster #1143
· Dec 23, 2020
93/100
Delicious. Decanted 5 hours. Worth the price.
2007 vintage
Taster #5968
· Aug 16, 2019
93/100
Drank 1st bottle in Aug’19 with Matthew and Alan. Funky, mushroomy, earthy nose. Little oxidized note but still fairly fresh. Brighter than a Barolo, which makes it more approachable. Structure is just starting to soften. Vibrant dark color but no browning yet. Beautiful dark fruit with slightly herbaceous note on the palate. Hint of acidity that transitioned into a beautiful supple finish with drippy tannin that’s just starting soften. Super classic super Tuscan. Will drink beautifully for the next 5-8 …
2008 vintage
Taster #6647
· May 19, 2019
91/100
Last bottle, and the good components of previous bottles are still there. The lack of finesse is not noticed when paired with a deer roast at the in-laws
2007 vintage
Taster #3714
· Jan 15, 2019
88/100
Bien, pas des plus complexe mais encore un beau fruit et une belle acidité, pas long mais pas méchant
2007 vintage
Taster #6647
· Jan 3, 2019
90/100
Black fruit, power, sweet touch, friendly, full, round and generous, but lacks some finesse and seems therefore somewhat heavy and boorish
2007 vintage
Taster #6647
· Dec 29, 2018
Oxidation
2007 vintage
Taster #6750
· Dec 28, 2018
89/100
lesser showing than last time, lacking some balance with a too important bitter component.
2007 vintage
Taster #6566
· Dec 28, 2018
Good value. Still good red fruit, and nice acidity. A little hot on the finish.
2007 vintage
Taster #6647
· Jan 2, 2018
91/100
See my previous note of March 2017 - consistent showing
2007 vintage
Taster #6680
· Sep 19, 2017
90/100
Emirates lounge. First time having a Caiarossa, understand same Dutch ownership of this Tuscan estate as Chateau Giscours and Du Tertre. After the 2000 Lagune and despite the 08 vintage being a cool vintage in Tuscany, this comes across as a big wine. Dominated more by ripe dark fruit from the Syrah, Cabernet Franc and Alicante grapes than Can Sauv or Merlot. Plenty of herbs and spices so there is some typicity and it's a well made wine but am …
2008 vintage
Taster #9013
· Sep 16, 2017
91/100
Competent Supertuscan, which has genuine verve and territorial identity. There is, of course, a fleshy nose of ripe damsons, graphite, cedar, sweet tobacco, black pepper, some cherry confiture. On the palate, it's in a very good place now: rich, almost decadent, hedonistic, pulpy. There's plenty of rich damson, a touch fruitcake, cooked red fruit, all framed in a bittersweetness that I often associate with Tuscany. Definitely a herbaceous trace. Some minerality on the finish. Plenty happening here - this isn't …
2008 vintage
Taster #1593
· Jul 29, 2017
88/100
Full bodied. Dark fruit notes but not a superb wine. Not on my list of future purchases.
2008 vintage
Taster #6750
· Apr 6, 2017
91/100
The nose shows red fruits, elegant, fresh, toasted, stewed fruits. In the mouth we find a very prominent acidity remineding me of Sangiovese, the sweet touch gives a lovely interaction with the acidity, tense wine (was served blindly)
2007 vintage
Taster #8779
· Apr 2, 2017
93/100
Great complex super Tuscan blend that is big and bold with an oaky flavor.
2007 vintage
Taster #6647
· Mar 26, 2017
91/100
Complex structure, red fruits, acidity, sweet touch but nicely countered by the acidity, a bit lactic. Still very much alive with nice tension in the wine.
2007 vintage
Taster #9339
· Oct 4, 2015
92/100
Nez concentré et expressif sur la mure et le bleuet, la vanille, et les herbes Fruit croquant en bouche, tanins encore bien présent, finale longue, fruitée et légèrement tanique Délicieux malgré son jeune age
2007 vintage
Taster #3825
· Mar 7, 2015
18mo oak - 25% new. N- spice, tobacco, meat, floral, cherry, strawberry, oak. P - high tan, ripe, oak, spice, herby, plum, cherry.
2007 vintage
Taster #5202
· Jan 24, 2015
86/100
Red fruit, cedar, tobacco, vanilla. Tanins are a little unbalanced. B
2008 vintage
Taster #9573
· Oct 21, 2013
91/100
Retailer tasting : Friendly and earthy bouquet. On the palate juicy fruits, some earthy impressions, beautiful acidity and a great length. Really beautiful wine, early maturity now and a future of 3+ years.
2007 vintage
Taster #8492
· Sep 27, 2012
91/100
Académie des Cinquante Bordeaux visit; 9/26/2012-9/29/2012 : Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc (30%), Merlot, Petit Verdot, Syrah, Mourvedre and Grenache. Biodynamic. Ripe fruit, velvety, hint of tar, excellent balance, quite modern, young but drinking very well.
2007 vintage
Taster #2546
· Feb 4, 2012
90/100
2012 - 8th Annual The Golden Glass: Slow Food Wine & Food Tasting Event (Herbst Pavillion, Fort Mason, San Francisco, California) : Medium dark red violet color; ripe plum cassis, oak nose; ripe plum, cassis, oak palate; needs 2 years; medium-plus finish (blend of Sangiovese, Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, Merlot, Petit Verdot, Syrah, Mourvedre and Grenache)
2007 vintage
Taster #2618
· Jun 3, 2011
With 2007 final blend is done after all 8 varietes finish barrel aging. Excellent silky texture, a beautiful, fine fabric of red fruit. Memorable wine. Grand tasting recent vintages at Divino Tuscany
2007 vintage