Yalumba, The Menzies Cabernet Sauvignon, Coonawarra

Yalumba · South Australia › Coonawarra › Australia

Red · Cabernet Sauvignon
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91 /100
Reviews
21
professional

Vintages

No vintages

No vintage-specific entries have been added for this wine.

NV

Community Reviews

25
25
Reviews
90.7
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #8244 · Jun 17, 2020
Just too old. Cork fell apart on opening. Wet cardboard on the nose - not earthy - oxidized. One sip confirmed it is way past time. Now draining out to the Los Angeles River.
2003 vintage
Taster #4686 · Nov 24, 2017
93/100
Just love the sophisticated berries on a backdrop debonair espresso and tar. Last bottle and this is drinking great. Enjoy it now at beautiful peak though it's probably got a few more great years ahead. -2020
2003 vintage
Taster #4120 · Feb 20, 2017
92/100
Pnp, nice right out of bottle. smooth oak, long finish. Has a little more time
2003 vintage
Taster #1114 · Jul 3, 2016
Mature, ripe and a little heavy for my palate. Leafy, syrupy notes. Tannin all but resolved, acid was lacking which effected the balance and enjoyment of the wine. Nice wine, just a little heavy and flat. Looking at others notes I'm not sure this is a reflective bottle. From this experience, drink now.
2003 vintage
Taster #4686 · Apr 21, 2016
94/100
A wine that, for me, did not reveal in its youth how special it was to become. Still smells surprisingly effusive with minerals, iodine, autumn branches, and cherry syrup. And the juicy palate, while less intellectual than the bouquet, unfurls like a mushroom cloud and offers an unwavering sweet length. Delicious and wotn among eight international cabs, one from each vintage '01-'08. Best -2020
2003 vintage
Taster #4686 · Feb 5, 2016
92/100
Has really come into its own, with plenty of time to spare.
2003 vintage
Taster #0355 · Mar 8, 2014
90/100
This one actually seemed new upon opening and I bought it new from the store years ago. So it's aging well. Heavy in the oak department but not more than a slight distraction. Heavy tobacco and dark notes. Good wine.
2003 vintage
Taster #6829 · Dec 31, 2011
92/100
Fun wine, thoroughly enjoyed this one. Creme de Casis, blackberries and tobacco. Aging well.
2003 vintage
Taster #0205 · Aug 2, 2011
90/100
Not your typical Aussie. Downright austere. I do think there is enough fruit balanced with green pepper and white pepper and scorched earth to give this wine some intrigue. This would be fun to put in blind with old world and see if people could guess.
2003 vintage
Taster #8217 · Jul 4, 2011
88/100
Rather herbaceous and lean for NW wine. Will need to reexamine under better circumstances.
2003 vintage
Taster #5168 · Feb 7, 2011
91/100
Loved this as always. Nice plum (black fruits too) and mint on the nose. Although the tannins aren't as soft as I remember the last bottle being, there was sufficient fruit on the palate and a good finish. This is almost austere and probably needs some more time to unfold. But, decanted for an hour or so and loved it. Just read through some of the earlier notes and i concur with whoever mention the Bordeaux qualities of this wine.
2003 vintage
Taster #8822 · Nov 25, 2010
D: Otroligt typisk aussie-CS. Mint, svarta vinbär, ceder. Stor och flirtig doft! S: Följer doften. Frisk syra, mjuka tanniner. Ganska balanserad, alkoholen märks/stör inte. Prisvärd!
2003 vintage
Taster #1483 · Nov 2, 2010
82/100
Not quite opaque as it clears near the edges of the glass. Near black in color. Nice floral characteristics on the nose lead to a disappointing palate. Lacking fruit and a distinct smokiness take away from a smooth wine with mostly resolved tannins. Somewhat thin and short on the finish compared to previous bottles which I have loved. Maybe a bad bottle or getting over the hill. Disappointing.
2003 vintage
Taster #6764 · Nov 2, 2010
87/100
Mark Anthony Portfolio Tasting (Mini, Yaletown) : Muted nose, mineral
2003 vintage
Taster #7010 · Oct 17, 2010
93/100
Very nice and complex wine.
2003 vintage
Taster #8217 · Sep 24, 2010
89/100
Color: Very dark opaque purple, with just a bit of fading beginning at the edges. Nose: initial blast of green bell pepper and leather; floral notes of rose and violet. After 1 hour, plum and blackberry started to show, with vanilla and soy sauce as time progressed. Palate started hot, with strong vegetal notes. subsequent flavors of caramel on the mid-palate. Medium-long finish features chocolate. Seems like it could still use time in bottle
2003 vintage
Taster #6509 · Dec 2, 2009
91/100
YES. Good quality to price ratio. Looks black in the glass, an above average Oz CB with good blackberry fruits, smooth tannins and not too hot (13.5), relatively speaking. I remember drinking this back in 1999 and really liked it. Easy drinking, good without food. A "buy it, if you see it wine" rather than one you would buy to keep. But, very acceptable.
2003 vintage
Taster #6106 · Oct 17, 2009
93/100
with rosemary roasted beef. Fabulous cab. Had Mondavi Reserve cab same night and although Mondavi reserve usually is very good, it was sour and lacking in comparison
2003 vintage
Taster #4686 · May 30, 2009
90/100
Surprisingly Bordeauxlais for an Australian cab, with a shifting nose that's enticing at best and well-developed secondary nuances with a (too) acidic backbone. This isn't getting any better in the next five years and I don't know if the fruit will last long enough to carry it beyond that.
2003 vintage
Taster #4995 · Apr 18, 2009
91/100
wow! this a powerful wine. dark dark colour and a massive nose of dark fruit. the finish is a bit spicy and hot but i thik that will mellow with a bit more time.
2003 vintage
Taster #6829 · Jan 31, 2009
93/100
Despite the bad press here thus far, I found this to be outstanding. Nice fruit, blackberries, plenty of tannins, and long finish. Will benefit from more aging, and I am looking forward to the next one.
2003 vintage
Taster #8292 · Nov 25, 2008
90/100
Eucalyptus and bluberries on the nose. A bit on light side as far as body goes but decent palate of fruit, oak and nuances. ready to drink.
2003 vintage
Taster #7680 · Sep 14, 2008
This is either shut down right now or the worst $50 bottle of wine I've ever had. Spicy, woody, very vegetal aroma. Some purple fruit on the palate. Little complexity and high acidity. I'll hold off on final judgement, because this can't be right.
2003 vintage
Taster #1278 · Feb 13, 2008
93/100
Plum with a strong mid palate of dry sweet fruit and good finish
2003 vintage
Taster #5062 · Jan 17, 2008
91/100
Taken to Aussie OL in Laguna. Red fruit and bit of green/asparagus on the finish. It was off-putting to me, but some didn't like it. I thought it was drinking nicely, closer to a young Bdx than to a Cali Cab.
2003 vintage