Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
94
/100
Reviews
21
professional
Vintages
1
2005
Other
93/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
2525
Reviews
92.5
Avg Score
95
Highest
Taster #6991
· Jan 10, 2026
Another corked bottle! 2 out of 6! 🫤.
2005 vintage
Taster #6991
· Dec 8, 2025
95/100
Pnp another bottle Same sandal-wood nose and aging yet still sappy delicious palate. Drinking these up as I’m not so sure of their longevity. And ..I enjoy drinking them! Ha !
2005 vintage
Taster #6991
· Oct 30, 2025
Corked Ugh 😩
2005 vintage
Taster #4285
· Oct 5, 2025
92/100
2005 Red Burgundy Retrospective - Day II (Saint Urban) : (Magnum) Reasonably complex nose. Moderate flash. Lifted and showy already. I like it. Decent palate too.
2005 vintage
Taster #5077
· Jul 3, 2025
90/100
started drnking about 2 hours after opening. Nose of leather with a bit of funk, maybe a little sulfur.
2005 vintage
Taster #0624
· Jun 26, 2025
94/100
PNP. First of a case purchased on release. Perfect cork, still pliant and stained only 1/16 of an inch. Deep red/black color. Minimal sediment. Nose shows slightly metallic, earthy cherry and menthol. Deep, lush and slightly sweet and salty cherry flavored palate that clenches up on the tongue and shows drying tannins on the mildly bitter finish. After 20 years this hasn’t budged much, Faiveley in a vintage like 05 is doubling down on tannins and extract. There’s a lot …
2005 vintage
Taster #9642
· Apr 25, 2025
PnD at a bistro in San Fran w Alena. Nice upon opening but blossomed a good hour after decanted, much more sophistication and balance. Stems at the restaurant weren't ideal but could still tell this wine was lovely. Saved half the bottle for a more legit experience. Got home and poured a splash in a proper burg glass and it really expanded. Iron steel acidity echoed with a lush stem dry leaf texture. Palette staining mid level rhubarb finish. Really …
2005 vintage
Taster #4755
· Apr 19, 2025
91/100
Consistent notes - better with air. These will age for a long time.
2005 vintage
Taster #4755
· Mar 2, 2025
91/100
From a half bottle - slowly aging. Still a ton of development to go. Hold.
2005 vintage
Taster #6991
· Feb 21, 2025
95/100
Delicious, down to my last bottle!
2005 vintage
Taster #7914
· Dec 20, 2024
93/100
PnP and followed over many hours. Bright and aromatic sois bois, raspberry, polished wood, and minerals. Big but balanced, good length, backbone and verve. Great finish.
2005 vintage
Taster #9237
· Sep 22, 2024
93/100
This is wide open, powerful, ripe and delicious. Plenty of tannins for further aging but fully ripe and integrated. Perhaps could use a bit more acidity
2005 vintage
Taster #4755
· Sep 15, 2024
91/100
Better showing than from a few years ago. More open and less harsh. Red fruit, spice, loads of structure still, good fruit/structure balance still. Hopefully these continue to open up with some age.
2005 vintage
Taster #1946
· Apr 23, 2024
93/100
This is a monster. A lot of potential, so concentrated, and tannic. Amazing complexity. Try again in 5 years ?
2005 vintage
Taster #4807
· Dec 10, 2023
92/100
from half bottle, and decanted 4 hours ahead
2005 vintage
Taster #5077
· Jun 9, 2023
92/100
started drinking 45 minutes after double-decanting. Still tannic on the palate. Nose of cassis, definitely lots of forest pine. Second pour 1½ hours after decanting and the nose was more open and fragrant, with nice woodsy notes along with leather. After two hours the nose opened up even more and got more alluring, but the palate was still relatively tight.
2005 vintage
Taster #5487
· Mar 5, 2023
Corked.
2005 vintage
Taster #5487
· Feb 10, 2023
94/100
This wine is stunning. Depth of fruit, with great notes of perfume. It will be approachable for years to come.
2005 vintage
Taster #7079
· Jan 11, 2023
95/100
Lovely red fruit, wood on the nose. Opaque crimson. Robust legs. Firm tannins melt away into dusty lusciousness after just a couple of hours. No decant, just left the bottle open. Cherry, spicy, earthy, meaty, chewy, beguiling aromatics. Corking the remaining half and looking forward to Day 2 tomorrow :) Day 2, this wine gained all the power and momentum it is known for. Happy to have 3 bottles left 🍷
2005 vintage
Taster #0870
· Jan 7, 2023
92/100
Double decant + 1 hr. Well, this to me did have the GC pedigree to it. However it was also still stuck in a formidable tannic shell which led to a sharp mismatch between a very opulent bouquet and a stern palate. This will take a long time to sort out if ever. Not sure the fruit will hold up but it is possible Score: 92. Relative to expectations: + but really, who knows?
2005 vintage
Taster #6856
· Dec 31, 2022
93/100
This needed 4 hours in the decanter to get started. Very nice balance and weight but this still needs another decade. Revisit 2030
2005 vintage
Taster #7914
· May 21, 2022
93/100
PNP out of 375 Soft red raspberry nose with hints of roses, violet and a touch of meatiness. Richness and mature palate, with smooth finish and great length. Good acidity. Guessing bottle format had to help with the maturity of this; ready to go out of a small format but probably still too young in 750s
2005 vintage
Taster #9237
· Dec 27, 2021
90/100
This has all of the power and richness of a grand cry. It ultimately doesn’t go anywhere with it — quite monolithic. Maybe too young ??
2005 vintage
Taster #9652
· Aug 6, 2021
Biennial stocktake of my cellar so racking out some OWCs and giving them a run. This needs to be held till 2025 in my view. Drinking OK and showing hints of classical elements but an über-tight core holding back surely an even finer wine. Potential 93+?+.
2005 vintage
Taster #5077
· Apr 10, 2021
91/100
served 30 minutes after decanting. Black fruits, plums, forest, leather. Tannins are still here so slightly grippy on the palate. Second pour 45 minutes after decanting was slightly better, and gradually opened up.
2005 vintage