Williams Selyem, Eastside Road Neighbors Pinot Noir, Russian River Valley

Williams Selyem · California › Russian River Valley › United States of America

Red · Pinot Noir
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91 /100
Reviews
38
professional

Vintages

No vintages

No vintage-specific entries have been added for this wine.

NV

Community Reviews

46
46
Reviews
90.7
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #3116 · Aug 22, 2025
93/100
Beautiful wine, fully resolved, still shows typical SC fruit, long subtle finish. Great example of aged SC Pinot. Drank out of Magnum. Ready.
2012 vintage
Taster #1539 · Jan 19, 2025
At Boston Wine + Poker, Sudbury, Mass.: Tasted blind. This was paired with the 2012 Williams Selyem Westside Road Neighbors. This one, the Eastside, tasted more Burgundian, with spiciness, heftiness, and a lot of fruit without sweetness. Perfect for drinking now -- delicious.
2012 vintage
Taster #1184 · Jan 12, 2025
92/100
Best after 30-60 mins of air.
2012 vintage
Taster #5675 · Dec 1, 2024
92/100
Still drinking great. Cherries, raspberries, red fruits galore. Not losing any of that 12 years later. Tannins are fully sorted out.
2012 vintage
Taster #4440 · Aug 10, 2024
92/100
Selyem had an outstanding year in 2012: every Pinot Noir I tasted from that vintage was truly delightful. The Precious Mountain is now fully mature but still drinks beautifully with no signs of decline. I slightly preferred the 2012 Weir (which I rated 93), but the Precious Mountain is a strong 92.
2012 vintage
Taster #4999 · Dec 31, 2023
Nice but fading a little. Not past it but getting there
2012 vintage
Taster #9264 · Oct 6, 2023
JD Friday Wine Group - John C host (City Club FW - Wine Room) : Served blind - fairly dark in the glass, so the appearance did not look like a pinot - at least not obviously. But the nose was there, lots of sweet cherry and cola. Sweet red fruit on the palate, with more cherry cola, and the slightest hint of earth, and in a great spot. This wine was obviously a Sonoma coast pinot, but I thought …
2012 vintage
Taster #3174 · Jul 3, 2023
86/100
Over the hill
2012 vintage
Taster #8273 · Dec 26, 2022
87/100
Past peak. Red fruit and straw here but not shining. Taste is mineral and earth.
2012 vintage
Taster #9254 · Dec 17, 2022
90/100
Surprisingly young for a 10 year old, quite rich and full in a good way, but still elegant. Red berries, some spice. Good to go now.
2012 vintage
Taster #7738 · Sep 13, 2022
91/100
Drinking very well, but still has good supporting acidity. Cola and ripe red cherries and plums.
2012 vintage
Taster #7841 · Apr 11, 2022
93/100
Drink now
2012 vintage
Taster #4017 · Mar 5, 2022
90/100
Subtle, light.
2012 vintage
Taster #5207 · Feb 6, 2022
93/100
Wow. Drinking so beautifully. So much more delicate than many WS. Such a range of secondary flavors with no loss of fruit. An outa ding achievement.
2012 vintage
Taster #5662 · Jan 11, 2022
89/100
Cherry and plum fruit, with some tartness. A little cola mid palate, and just a hint of smokiness to go with the earthiness on the finish.
2012 vintage
Taster #3568 · Oct 17, 2021
90/100
Very light for California Pinot. Started the evening with this and is a better appetizer wine than a meal wine.
2012 vintage
Taster #3035 · Aug 26, 2021
90/100
PnP, but better after about 15 minutes of air. Aromas of dark red fruits and earth. Lots of dark red fruits and earth on the medium bodied palate, along with balancing acidity and touches of RRV cola and spice. A well made pinot that is showing some age, but could hold for another couple of years.
2012 vintage
Taster #3035 · Aug 10, 2021
89/100
Decanted for 45 minutes which allowed the wine to open. Light red fruits and a touch of herbs on the nose. The medium bodied palate showed a range of red fruits - some lighter, some darker - with lots of spice, some earth, a touch of herb, and juicy acidity. A "feminine" Pinot Noir from the Sonoma Coast that could hold for a few more years..
2012 vintage
Taster #3727 · Jul 10, 2021
It's a beauty
2012 vintage
Taster #7738 · Oct 26, 2020
91/100
Deep red center, red rim with signs of age. Wonderful nose of lavender, white chocolate, cherry jam, fall bonfire. Smooth and a little sweet, brandied cherries, touch of some darker fruits, good acidity, great finish of sweet cherry fruit. In an excellent place - drinking very well now but good for another 2-5 years.
2012 vintage
Taster #7738 · Sep 5, 2020
90/100
Deep red center, red rim with modest signs of age. Caramel, kirsch, blueberries, black cherries, blackberries, creamy, dusty herbs, a nice greenness. Smooth, grapes, brandied cherries, raspberries, sappy, pine needles, a little spicy, blackcurrant, some oak, good acidity still, good length, nice finish. Great Eastside, drinking okay now, but will be better in 2+ years.
2012 vintage
Taster #8018 · Sep 1, 2020
90/100
Lighter than I expected maybe aging out. Nice fruit and balance.
2012 vintage
Taster #3174 · Jun 23, 2020
91/100
Red fruits predominate. Still very fresh and inviting. Medium finish.
2012 vintage
Taster #4383 · May 10, 2020
92/100
Light herbaceous nose; light raspberry-cherry; tart with some earth; light tart-sweet finish.
2012 vintage
Taster #4383 · Apr 8, 2020
90/100
Greenish cherry; coarse with earthy fruit; sweet tannic finish; agree with wade shanley on bucher.
2012 vintage
Taster #4999 · Aug 8, 2019
Solid pinot for WS...but not nearly as exciting as the 11 Bucher I had last night. Day 3: a bit of improvement some more complexity and spice. more rounded out mid pallet. Seemed to pick up some weight as well. Finish lengthened. Def more enjoyable.
2012 vintage
Taster #0840 · Jun 24, 2019
90/100
Big and rich, but also a little simple.
2012 vintage
Taster #1302 · Jun 22, 2019
91/100
Mature, integrated and delicate with nice balance of red fruit and earthiness. Heavy on the wood and smoke flavors for a wine with such finesse. Maybe waited too long to drink? Paired well with smoked pork roast.
2012 vintage
Taster #3440 · May 12, 2019
93/100
PnP at a restaurant. initially a bit unbalanced with sour and tart notes coming thru. 30 minutes later things had started to smooth out and gained some weight on the palate. fantastic wine
2012 vintage
Taster #5473 · Mar 25, 2019
90/100
Ripe with minus acid and plus oak. round but somehow the mid-palate is hollow and the wine does not have the oomph.
2012 vintage
Taster #3633 · Mar 16, 2019
94/100
Uncorked and aired for 30 minutes classic W-S with deep blueberry aroma and flavor without being cloying. Very hard not to absolutely love this
2012 vintage
Taster #0840 · Dec 5, 2018
No doubt a very good pinot. Yet, first night it seemed a little plain and lacked the range of character I expect from top wines. However, on the second night this wine blossomed quite nicely and began to show its stuff. It maintained bright, fresh fruit throughout, and also gave up some nice spice and finish.
2012 vintage
Taster #0883 · Nov 9, 2018
92/100
Very pleasant and delicate wine. Did not pack the punch of other 2012 WS appellation or single vineyard pinots but did have a near elegant (explaining the 91 point rating) balance of tea, very faint orange peal, intermittent pops of faint cherry and acid finish that made it an enjoyable, slow drinking bottle. If your looking for big California in your face Pinot this is not the wine, especially at this price point. An enjoyable bottle but seems like one …
2012 vintage
Taster #3239 · Sep 27, 2018
93/100
Fantastic. Delicious, medium bodied, wonderful fruit, great acidity. Overall just tasty, great wine.
2012 vintage
Taster #7015 · Sep 22, 2018
92/100
Consumed over two hours complimenting pan seared sockeye sockeye salmon. Right at its peak. Quite a lovely mouth full of juice. Big perfumed bouquet, with lots of cherries. It morphs into a long complex finish of prunes and figs.
2012 vintage
Taster #1184 · Aug 29, 2018
93/100
Ready to drink - perfect with salmon steak and salad - smooth bing cherry with a slight fruit tart to finish it off.
2012 vintage
Taster #4839 · Aug 26, 2018
90/100
Not much ooomph.
2012 vintage
Taster #5104 · Aug 10, 2018
92/100
As good as CA pinot gets. Ripe berries. Hint of vanilla. A long finish of herbs and cinnamon. tannins and acid have mellowed over time. Drinking great now as an aged CA wine, but feels like one can do this for a few more years too.
2012 vintage
Taster #7621 · Apr 18, 2018
92/100
notes of light cherry, a hint of floral. A lighter pinot. Very nice the first night, a touch aged the second, a hint of long in the tooth the third, but still very drinkable. Suggest not letting this wine age more than another year or two.
2012 vintage
Taster #7081 · Dec 28, 2017
90/100
While it lacked the "etherial-ness" of other bottles I have enjoyed from WS and this particular vineyard, it was still a very nice high(er) toned example of a C-noir with notes of roses, raspberries, and plum. Supporting the fruit were spice and earthy nuances. The acids seemed to have moderated based on earlier reviewers comments but were still very evident.
2012 vintage
Taster #3653 · Jul 20, 2017
1st day: Needed to aerate an hour; tannic (88). 2nd day: Flavors have evolved (90/91). 3rd day: Really smooth, aromatics are gone (90 pts overall).
2012 vintage
Taster #3575 · Jul 4, 2017
90/100
Popped and poured before dinner. Cherry notes on the nose. Tart red fruit on the palate along with some secondary notes. Enjoyed over two hours.
2012 vintage
Taster #3998 · Dec 3, 2016
89/100
I liked it, but didn't love it nearly as much as my wife did. The 89 is the middle ground from her 90 and my 88. I found the wine beautiful to look at with a translucent ruby hue in the decanter. The nose was floral and on the lighter side with more berry than cherry/plum. Flavors were a tart strawberry/raspberry mix that did not pair with the pork roast as I expected. It was ok with the spaghetti squash. …
2012 vintage
Taster #3407 · Feb 16, 2016
88/100
Agree with previous reviewer about the sweet tarts. Good but not memorable.
2012 vintage
Taster #0333 · Mar 3, 2015
86/100
Pop and pour. Uncomplicated red fruit nose. Strawberries and barely ripe cherries, along with a good bit of acidity. A bit like a mouthful of red Sweet-Tarts. Meh.
2012 vintage
Taster #2291 · Nov 15, 2014
Winemaker notes Bright berry and cherry notes with elements of underbrush are highlighted in this elegant Pinot Noir. The finish is long with a gravelly, mineral-like texture giving this wine a true Sonoma Coast profile. The Vineyard Precious Mountain located in the Sonoma Coast appellation, sits atop the second mountain ridge in from the Pacific Coast, near Fort Ross. This is a very small vineyard planted on steep slopes at an altitude of 1,750 feet. At this altitude coastal breezes, …
2012 vintage