Carmenet Cabernet Franc Moon Mountain Vineyard

Carmenet

Other · Cabernet Sauvignon
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91 /100
Reviews
24
professional

Vintages

1
1999 Other 91/100
Cabernet Franc, Cabernet Sauvignon
NV

Community Reviews

24
24
Reviews
91.2
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #7238 · Sep 1, 2025
90/100
Opened as part of a large tasting. PnP. Very aromatic with black fruit, earth, leather, cassis, and an herbal note. A beautifully mature with that still has plenty of fruit. Black fruit, cassis, earth, slight herbal. Medium body, well balanced with good acidity. Smooth , silky tannins in the finish.
1999 vintage
Taster #7238 · Sep 4, 2023
90/100
A beautifully mature cabernet. PnP. Slightly shy aroma with black fruit, herbal, earth, leather, cassis flavors. Still has plenty of fruit and not drying out. black fruit, cassis, earth, slight herbal. Medium body, well balanced with good acidity. Smooth , silky tannins in the finish.
1999 vintage
Taster #7238 · Feb 20, 2023
90/100
Another beautifully mature cabernet. PnP. Didn't need a decant. Starts with black fruit, herbal, earth, leather, cassis flavors. Still has plenty of fruit and not drying out. black fruit, cassis, earth, slight herbal. Medium body, not jammy. well balanced with good acidity. Smooth , silky tannins in the finish.
1999 vintage
Taster #4777 · Sep 6, 2016
88/100
Nice and enjoyable, though pretty simple cab.
1999 vintage
Taster #2404 · Sep 5, 2013
90/100
Solid if unexciting Cali Cab, with chocolate, coffee and blackberry on the nose, but not great depth of palate or finish. It had probably aged past its prime. Still, a nice accompaniment to sauteed chicken with port sauce and figs.
1999 vintage
Taster #3637 · Mar 8, 2013
90/100
Dark purple core with minimal color variation. The nose is expressive with an expansive leafiness, black fruits, and a component of earth. The palate is ripe but not jammy, nor big. The fruit is sweet and soft, well balanced by an acid lift that keeps the fruit from cloying. The mouthfeel is smooth and lithe but has power like a tensed muscle. The moderately lengthy finish is earthy and a little woody, with a nice snap of tannin. Good wine, …
1999 vintage
Taster #0630 · Mar 19, 2012
91/100
Purple red color. Very expressive nose with cassis, blackberry, violets and quality wood spice. A very silky palate follows through with rich cassis, black olives, dark chocolate and a lingering spicy and flowery perfume on the back-end. Lovely wine for the price and is in its prime drinking window. The wine was even more expressive the second day.
1999 vintage
Taster #3243 · Oct 14, 2011
90/100
The wine looks Garnet colored. The legs are Medium. The wine looks Garnet colored. The legs are Medium. It smells like and Fig. It tastes like and Forest floor. The body is Full. The wine is textured Smooth. The wine finishes Long.
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Jun 12, 2011
92/100
An excellent Cab, nice nose, great color, smooth well balanced tannins. Just sorry I am running out, this is drinking well but really isn't showing that it is near its end
1999 vintage
Taster #3236 · Jan 22, 2011
88/100
This didn't meet my expectations from the previous CT notes.
1999 vintage
Taster #6597 · Jan 21, 2011
93/100
Had this about a year ago. It was holding on with great fruit after a decant. Suspect it just past it's prime and glad I drank it. Kept the bottle from a great vintage.
1999 vintage
Taster #3860 · Nov 12, 2010
91/100
great balance between fruit and tannins. Last bottle. Too bad.
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Nov 6, 2010
94/100
A very good Cab, Big, smooth tannins, great structure and balance, wonderful mouth feel, great nose, color and finish. Sorry I am running out. It is really ready now!!
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Aug 1, 2010
92/100
Still drinking very well!! A wonderful Cab, Full, Big, Rich and soft. My only regret is my 2 case inventory is getting low.
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Jun 20, 2010
93/100
This ris a very nice wine, especially if you let it open up for a couple of hours!!!! Great Structure, nice balance wonderful mouth feel and strong finish. Let it breath!!! I ran it through an areator and it still got much better after a couple of hours in a decante r.
1999 vintage
Taster #8777 · May 25, 2010
92/100
Popped and poured. Lovely lovely. Tannins very well integrated, chocolatey is mostly what I recall. Exactly what I was hoping.
1999 vintage
Taster #3104 · Jan 3, 2010
90/100
Very smooth. Drinking nicely now.
1999 vintage
Taster #1900 · Dec 15, 2009
90/100
nicely aged mellow cab. Good fruit, woood smoke, and chocolate.
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Dec 12, 2009
94/100
Fantastic wine!! Great nose as soon as you open it, well balanced very solid tannins but very nice fruit. Wonderful feel on the palate, strong finish. This was better than the 97 vintage again, glad I have 9 bottles left. The will hold up for a while yet.
1999 vintage
Taster #1002 · Sep 7, 2009
91/100
good wine
1999 vintage
Taster #4402 · Apr 6, 2009
92/100
Stil quite good. Lots of bouquet & tastes.
1999 vintage
Taster #1002 · Oct 8, 2008
92/100
strong tannins, good flavor
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · Jul 8, 2008
93/100
Very nice cab, great color, big fruit, smooth and velvety on the palate. Tannins settled in after decanting and it drank better than the 97, surprise.
1999 vintage
Taster #2369 · May 16, 2008
92/100
Very nice nose, great color, classic Cab, very good balance, smooth tannins, didn't need to open up much, it is drinking nicely right now.
1999 vintage