Williams Selyem, Hirsch Pinot Noir, Sonoma Valley

Williams Selyem · California › Sonoma Valley › United States of America

Red · Pinot Noir
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
90 /100
Reviews
17
professional

Vintages

No vintages

No vintage-specific entries have been added for this wine.

NV

Community Reviews

25
25
Reviews
90.4
Avg Score
95
Highest
Taster #0305 · Dec 26, 2019
While it has some interesting notes here and there, in general this wine is pretty far past the due date. Judging by the cork, I'd stored the wine well, with no seepage at all. Even so, the nose was off and a bit pruney. The color was what you'd expect with some light bricking around the edges. The palate was, for the most part, unpleasantly acidic with very little fruit to save it. I love old wine, but this one …
1999 vintage
Taster #4634 · Jul 4, 2015
89/100
Still drinking well, but fading. Suggest gettin' her done soon.
1999 vintage
Taster #1467 · Jun 12, 2014
95/100
- Brick color.
1999 vintage
Taster #8262 · Oct 1, 2013
Medium red color, nice dark cherry aroma, a bit of earthiness present, medium weight, plenty of fruit initially which seemed to fade over a couple of hours, medium length finish with fading fruit. Just past its prime we thought.
1999 vintage
Taster #0852 · Jan 4, 2013
94/100
Drinking beautifully plenty of acid and good fruit balance
1999 vintage
Taster #0492 · Nov 29, 2012
92/100
Nice. Cherry fruit. Not at all oth. Went great with roast chicken. A tad hot but no complaints.
1999 vintage
Taster #9562 · Jun 24, 2012
Served blind. Ripe fruit with notes of iron. Bright palate, lean and juicy in a very pleasant way. Guessed Burg.
1999 vintage
Taster #6141 · Jan 3, 2012
89/100
drank this with the 1998 hirsch pinot---after decanting both for 90 minutes, the 1998 was much smoother out of the box. The 1999 always had a harsh aftertaste. Drank over 2 evenings and the initial tasting note didn't change.
1999 vintage
Taster #7024 · Aug 17, 2011
disappointed by the more overt fruit/alochol...I would describe as a bit roasted but I will admit to being senitive to this character as my wife enjoyed the wine. this character scarred the experience but the wine did have pretty good balance and size.
1999 vintage
Taster #3792 · Jun 18, 2011
91/100
Initial flavors and aromas of raspberry cola and cherry. Second glass changed to a much heavier wine. Would have guessed a syrah or rhone blend. 3rd glass turned back to initial aromas and flavors. Interesting.
1999 vintage
Taster #2647 · Sep 26, 2010
Never been a big fan of the 99s, but last night this wine proved better now than when tasted several years ago. Severed along side roasted quail wrapped in bacon - a lovely cobination. No formal notes taken and, as a consequence, a rating is withheld. Nevertheless, the wine proved appealing with nice color and flavors, and reconfimrs my belief that Williams Selyems Pinot Noirs form specific vineyards can handle a decade of cellaring.
1999 vintage
Taster #8726 · Mar 24, 2010
82/100
Restaurant Week; 3/21/2010-3/27/2010 (Various) : Straight up vanillin ripe cherries that evolved to brambly crayola cherry fruit. Extracted crushed berries fruits with milo consistency and does have peppermint tea leaves too. Reminded me of an NSG but does also show most of its american roots. Not too bad, very easy to understand with not much effort needed.
1999 vintage
Taster #3792 · Nov 22, 2009
91/100
Finally starting to open up and show some promise. Deep dark purple color. Nose of cola, vanilla, bright cherry / berry. Some floral notes with dried fruits (rainins & prunes), tobacco & nuts. Bright fruit on the palate of cherry and blackberry. Its inital flavors and aromas are great, but it's a bit short in length. Intense front palate, somewhat hot., OK back palate, but the mid palate seems to be missing. Meaty, au jus, tobacco, leather. Not much fruit.
1999 vintage
Taster #6586 · Jan 8, 2009
I made a Caesar dressing, drizzled it with some homemade croutons and grilled chicken and then tossed with some romaine for a fairly healthy light dinner before we head to Big D in the morning. Showed some nice purple fruit notes under a wall of tartaric acid addition. The acid unfortunately rode rough shot over some nice fruit underneath...will time ever allow it to integrate...not so sure if 10 years hasn't allowed it already. Disappointing.
1999 vintage
Taster #1130 · Nov 11, 2008
Sharon Bowman returns to NY with an eclectic mix. : Corked. NR.
1999 vintage
Taster #6228 · Aug 21, 2008
I was drawn in by the black cherry fruit and a hint of spice. Supple and silky into the mouth it also had an alluring sappiness towards the back. Great structure with a distinct minerality and a line of acidity typical of Hirsch carries the fruit nicely. It has a bit of grip on the end that should loosen with a bit more age. This wine is just at the beginning of its window with better to come.
1999 vintage
Taster #5142 · Jul 23, 2008
91/100
reminded me of cherry brandy...
1999 vintage
Taster #3792 · Apr 20, 2008
88/100
Moderately dark red, purplish color. Still not showing much age. Perhaps a bit of slight bricking around the edges. Nose of cola, forest, cedar and bing cherry. Pallet cherry, a little spice, maybe a touch of eucalyptus? Not a big wine. More elegant in style. Still a little hot, but not bad. Becoming more integrated. Bottle age definitely helped this wine. Try again in another year. It doesn't have a ton of fruit or a huge backbone, but I'd like …
1999 vintage
Taster #3633 · Nov 26, 2007
91/100
Still a fine cali pinot. It has a faint earthyness that gives way to violet blueberry and a fresh acidity. After an hour it was fading slightly. Drink 'm if you got 'em!
1999 vintage
Taster #1698 · Oct 29, 2007
95/100
everything a pinot should be (2 diff. tastings)
1999 vintage
Taster #3046 · May 20, 2007
89/100
14.4% alcohol. i don't have too many hirsch specific wines in my cellar, and i don't have that much tasting experience with them either. i have been wanting to try this specific wine for some time, but was able to hold in the cellar until tonight. not decanted, followed in the glass now for over three hours. at age eight, i hoped it would be open for business; and, it is, but...the wine is too austere for my liking. not …
1999 vintage
Taster #7606 · Apr 15, 2007
94/100
Dinner with Evan Lobel & Friends with Lobel's Meats; 4/14/2007-4/15/2007 (The house of Jeff and Fran Kadish in Croton, New York) : Still has a dark ruby color. Wonderful nose of black cherries and minerals. An absolutely stunning Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir with delicious black cherry fruit and that ferrous minerality of the Hirsch vineyard. The wine is beautifully balanced and deeply concentrated with a soft, silky mouthfeel and excellent freshness, at least from magnum. It finishes a little tight …
1999 vintage
Taster #3792 · Apr 7, 2007
88/100
Moderately dark red, purplish color. Not really showing any signs of age. Nose of cola, forest, cedar and bing cherry. Pallet cherry, a little spice, maybe a touch of eucalyptus? Not a big wine. More elegant in style. Much better than the last bottle of this a couple of years ago, which was very hot and not well integrated. Bottle age definitely helped this wine. Try again in another year. It doesn't have a ton of fruit or a huge …
1999 vintage
Taster #3792 · May 12, 2006
87/100
Not bad, but not great. Hot. Bright red fruit. Not much else.
1999 vintage
Taster #2780 · Jan 13, 2006
91/100
Brite, touch of wood. Well integrated. Very nice.
1999 vintage