Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91
/100
Reviews
57
professional
Vintages
1
2009
Other
90/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
4343
Reviews
90.2
Avg Score
99
Highest
Taster #8811
· Aug 20, 2025
96/100
Quick 30 minute decant. Aromas of strawberry, maraschino cherry, mushroom, earth and rhubarb. Flavors of cherry, strawberry, cranberry, earth and rhubarb. Ends with a 35-40 second finish with cherry and red berry notes. Does not taste like 16 year old wine. Don’t even see any bricking. This is fantastic.
2009 vintage
Taster #5418
· Jul 20, 2024
91/100
Very nice red fruit flavors, good acidity, not showing 15 years of age. Drink up - very good!
2009 vintage
Taster #6008
· Feb 12, 2024
94/100
AW94. Beautiful violet nose on pnp - good length, some slight variation in bottle having sourced from different collections, but excellent overall. This was a fantastic vintage, more impressive than 2010 and still time left to enjoy many more in this wonderful drinking window.
2009 vintage
Taster #3916
· Mar 19, 2022
91/100
Still drinking well. Amazing for this 13yo RRV Pinot. Fruit, acid, and tannins are seamlessly integrated. Medium body. Short to medium finish. Will buy again.
2009 vintage
Taster #3916
· Jan 1, 2022
90/100
Drank for New Years. PnP. Incorrect stemware. Still drinking well.
2009 vintage
Taster #4192
· Jul 23, 2021
90/100
Still in good shape but no point in waiting. Cola and dark red fruit, but a bit astringent and out of balance. Probably would have been better with an hour or two decant beforehand. Still enjoyable but not a star.
2009 vintage
Taster #4749
· Feb 18, 2021
93/100
Beautiful fruit and balance. Impressive
2009 vintage
Taster #3093
· Jan 4, 2021
99/100
This bottle was amazing. Perfect blend of fruit, acid, tannin. Complex that kept us talk about it for hours after the bottle was empty. Best wine I had in 2020.
2009 vintage
Taster #8381
· May 2, 2020
Amazing even after sitting this long!
2009 vintage
Taster #7403
· Mar 21, 2020
93/100
Fruit is still singing , awesome pinot
2009 vintage
Taster #0740
· Feb 27, 2020
95/100
Absolutely brilliant. One of our favorites from the WS lineup.
2009 vintage
Taster #6958
· Jan 30, 2020
Didn�t have this in CT but found it in the cellar and thought I better pop it immediately. No worries though. This is perfectly sound still. Great cork. Good color. Black fruits, cola, forest floor. Drinking well but this is now for near term consumption.
2009 vintage
Taster #7597
· Jan 12, 2020
90/100
After dinner drink. Very good wine, good color, fruit, body and length. Still going strong.
2009 vintage
Taster #4325
· Jan 6, 2019
94/100
Holidays 2018 (Dogwood Grove) : This seemed special – a lifted nose of strawberry with pleasant accents of cedar and coconut and a satisfying modern palate of berry medley, strawberry preserves, vanilla. It was long and delicious. Provided an interesting contrast with the Burgundy – less earthy and long, but more delicious and vibrant. In a great drinking window, and might have several good years to come. Although I think the Burg can go even longer.
2009 vintage
Taster #3174
· Nov 22, 2018
93/100
Deep crimson. Plums, roses, currants and tarragon nose. This is in a good place. Balanced and complex, elegant and powerful.
2009 vintage
Taster #6257
· Mar 29, 2018
92/100
Just a beautiful wine. This is delicious. It has delicious fruit, great stricture and a nice finish. My husband found more leather on the back end than wanted but I disagree. This has aged wonderfully. I think this wine has peaked. But it will stay here for a few years. It�s delicious.
2009 vintage
Taster #3510
· Dec 30, 2017
95/100
Perfect balance & weight and cherry taste profile - really good PN
2009 vintage
Taster #6214
· Aug 22, 2017
92/100
See previous note. Even more flesh than last time. It is in the perfect stride at the current moment.
2009 vintage
Taster #7776
· Aug 6, 2017
94/100
Love to be in the room when Galloni (90 and meh) and Josh Reynolds discuss wine. I think Reynolds, at 93+, nailed this one. We popped and poured at Avenue B, and it just sung. Plenty of WS trademark cherries, but a ton of backbone to go with it. Darker than I expected, bright, complex nose of cherries and spice. Complex and full bodied on the palate. Long finish. Others have called this Burgundian. I think maybe a little, but …
2009 vintage
Taster #0740
· Jun 18, 2017
91/100
Much better than the last bottle.
2009 vintage
Taster #7606
· May 28, 2017
93/100
A great showing for this wine tonight. Deeply rich and concentrated with fabulous ripe cherry fruit tinged with smoky minerals. Really crisp and fresh with a fine mineral crunch on the finish. The perfect combination of rich California fruit with a Burgundian style texture.
2009 vintage
Taster #7597
· May 28, 2017
90/100
Good wine drank over 2 nights. Good color and nose and palate indeed have cola flavors. This is good though, great fruit, body and finish. Yummy!this will go with number of menus. It can stand up, won't get better so drink up.
2009 vintage
Taster #6214
· Feb 2, 2017
91/100
Stewed cherry, cola, crushed rock and white spice. A medium-long finish and welcomed layers. I love the flavor and nuance combination. Drink now - 2020.
2009 vintage
Taster #2904
· Jan 19, 2017
88/100
One of the best WS I have tasted in a while. While it is not all Burgundian, it has restraint and balance and a touch of lingering crispness on the finish. No WS RRV (or hot style) cherry cough syrup on this wine.
2009 vintage
Taster #3239
· Jan 6, 2017
85/100
This was my fault for not drinking earlier. Still a nice wine, but past its prime. Notes of cherry, but more dark and less fresh. Drink if you have it.
2009 vintage
Taster #1302
· Dec 23, 2016
93/100
Bright, fresh, sweet cherry flavors with hints of dried herbs. Silky texture, smooth finish.
2009 vintage
Taster #2956
· Dec 20, 2016
14.1% alcohol. Drinking very well right now. Red-black cherry color. Fragrant nose of black cherry, baking spice, rich earth, and minerals. In the mouth, fairly plush but also precise, with black cherry, baking spice, and earth notes expanding on the palate. A bright brush of acidity and a moderate finish. Very nice. Has the bones to last another 3-5 years for sure, but it's in an excellent spot right now. A-
2009 vintage
Taster #5481
· Oct 27, 2016
90/100
Drank over two nights and held up well. A bit on the downside of its life cycle but still very nice drinking.
2009 vintage
Taster #3239
· Oct 24, 2016
89/100
Time to drink up. A little past its prime, but still lovely fruits, medium bodied. Nice cherry notes.
2009 vintage
Taster #7015
· Sep 22, 2016
75/100
Have to agree with some of the other posts here. Might have waited too long at the fair on this one. It's good, but not at all what a $50 bottle of wine should be. Actually has next to no complexity to go along with a decent amount of fruit. Tasted blindfold, I would guess $15 max for the bottle price. This is the single most disappointing Williams Selyem I've ever tasted and I've been on their mailing list for …
2009 vintage
Taster #0740
· Aug 14, 2016
89/100
Disappointing. Not sure if its past its prime or it ever was that great to begin with. The '08s RRVs were much stronger and held up very well with time and air. This was acidic and a bit sour from the get go. Day 2, this still had a lot of 'pop' to it. Felt stronger. 89/90
2009 vintage
Taster #2904
· Jul 29, 2016
70/100
A very simple wine perhaps pasts its prime. Drink up or better yet use it to make a nice sauce. These wine apparently have no longevity. Purchased upon release and held in a cold cellar. Yuck.
2009 vintage
Taster #0492
· Mar 18, 2016
90/100
Nose is horse stable, cedar, orange zest and cherry. The downside is the lack of Pinot Noir characteristics on nose The upside is the delicious "tamed" red fruits mid-profile and a wine that finishes with distinctive smokiness atop crisp sour cherry. Delicious.
2009 vintage
Taster #3037
· Jan 6, 2016
88/100
Past its prime. Needed an hour; ok thereafter.
2009 vintage
Taster #2825
· Oct 11, 2015
93/100
Deeply fruited, elegantly focused, with spice and earth, all nicely balanced.
2009 vintage
Taster #5353
· Sep 28, 2015
87/100
Meh. Drink soon. Starting to pull apart.
2009 vintage
Taster #9421
· Aug 21, 2015
86/100
Pop n poured and followed over 2 hours. Served @ a wedding Aromas were a bit muted as compared with the Sonoma county. Even the corked Sonoma Coast had more aromatics. The wine seemed a bit disjointed and clumsy on the attack and finished with some heat. Perhaps it would have been better the next day.
2009 vintage
Taster #9476
· Jan 9, 2015
84/100
Turd. Prunes, dank, not good. Had to break out the wasabi to filter the dankness. Otherwise, it was wine. 2 out of 10 Ws's miss the mark. The rest are thumbs up. Next
2009 vintage
Taster #6692
· Apr 1, 2014
93/100
deep nose of earth and berry; sappy mixed wild berry and spice with plenty of depth/earth; the oak is integrating nicely; long finish with spice and a bit of pepper; more intense than most WS that i have tasted but very balanced; a bit too big for the chicken and veggies at this point, but has great upside over time.
2009 vintage
Taster #2037
· Apr 28, 2013
84/100
Smell: medicinal. Taste: extreme fruit. not much elegance/complexity.
2009 vintage
Taster #1426
· Dec 23, 2012
90/100
Popped and poured; nice wine but not outstanding. Medium red; nose of red fruits and brown sugar; on the palate nice acid balance and good intensity. May develop more complexity over time and is a bit tight today.
2009 vintage
Taster #7017
· Sep 27, 2012
92/100
Pop and pour and followed over three hours. Delicious wine. Floral nose with some brown spices mixed in. The initial impression is somewhat candied (strawberry licorice) but there is bight and verve from the tartness to keep it all in check. Levels of complexity, showing some mushrooms, earth (forest floor as they say), along with the fresh, sweet berries.
2009 vintage
Taster #4999
· Jul 8, 2012
93/100
explosion of fruit. floral flavors. nice tannin not too over powering. This will only get better with age...only wish I had more
2009 vintage