Caldwell Chardonnay Society of Smugglers

Caldwell

Other · Chardonnay
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
89 /100
Reviews
5
professional

Vintages

1
2017 Other 89/100
Chardonnay
NV

Community Reviews

5
5
Reviews
89.4
Avg Score
92
Highest
Taster #2038 · Jul 8, 2022
91/100
Right between the last two notes
2017 vintage
Taster #2806 · Jul 21, 2020
88/100
Explosive oak on the nose with burnt cream, butter, citrus, and high acidity. Not my preferred style.
2017 vintage
Taster #2038 · Apr 7, 2020
92/100
Classic Chardonnay on day 1 but really blossomed after 2 days in the fridge. Fruit notes opened. Long finish. I guess I need to leave them be for a few more years
2017 vintage
Taster #6363 · Oct 12, 2019
90/100
Color: pale lemon Nose:melon, citrus, fresh air Taste: citrus, crisp apple and pear with a hint of petrol This is a clean crisp Chardonnay devoid of toasted oak (yay!) full mouthfeel with a bit of glycerine and tangy lingering finish. Complexity increases a bit with time. Very enjoyable.
2017 vintage
Taster #1636 · May 18, 2019
86/100
Not bad but disappointing. Terrible QPR much like their cab from recent member shipment. Fraudulent being charged $65 for this.
2017 vintage