Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92
/100
Reviews
22
professional
Vintages
1
2005
Other
92/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
2626
Reviews
92.2
Avg Score
95
Highest
Taster #4674
· Feb 7, 2026
like the majority of my 2005's, this is a little tough... I'm fully convinced that waiting another decade for virtually all my 2005 red burgs would be a good idea, and I'm betting these "come out to play" at some point in the future... needs more time so no rating, but it felt today like 91pts
2005 vintage
Taster #7780
· Jan 11, 2026
92/100
Nice side-by-side with the L'Enfant Jesus, this one being more classic Gevrey with darker notes, a little more tannic, not quite as pretty and expressive as the Baby. Still, quite nice. EWG 10+ years on tasting.
2005 vintage
Taster #1292
· Oct 5, 2025
91/100
2005 Faiveley Gevrey-Chambertin 1er Cru Les Cazetiers. Mid-ruby, rim variation, amber edges; red fruit, strawberry, wood, nose; mid acids; mid+ tannins; tight, tart, short red fruit finish. 16.5/91.
2005 vintage
Taster #3158
· Sep 5, 2025
94/100
Too cold initially so gave it 5 mins in Sensory glass with air. This is excellent. Linear, focused, elegant for a Gevrey. The red fruit is well present, as are the acidity and soft tannins, but there are emerging tertiary notes already. Forest floor, liquorice, muskiness. It focuses (rather than crescendos) from its red fruited beginning into a narrow and piercing beam of savouriness with absolutely imposing length on the finish. In my view this has just about entered its …
2005 vintage
Taster #3734
· Apr 23, 2025
95/100
WCC Red Burgundy Blind (Le Quai Bistrot Français, Waterford, NY) : [Double-decanted for 20 minutes at 8am.] Gorgeous red fruit nose. Complex with subtle tannins and a long, sweet finish.
2005 vintage
Taster #9635
· Apr 23, 2025
94/100
WCC Blind Burgundy tasting (Le Quai Bistrot, Waterford) : Terrific showing, my wine of the flight and wine of the night (though many others preferred the '09 Damodes in the same flight). This is drinking beautifully - a perfumed quality to the aromatics; a sappy intensity to the red fruits here; more savoury and earthy depth beneath; in that zone where the fruit's still quite fresh and youthful but there's plenty of savoury development emerging. Loved this.
2005 vintage
Taster #5599
· Feb 17, 2025
90/100
Upon opening, gorgeous bouquet of stewed strawberry, mushroom, sous bois, and umami. Palate opens up to decomposing violet, lavender, and red fruit. Earth, meatiness, and a mature oak finish this out. Drinking well, could go longer, but no need for it to.
2005 vintage
Taster #3734
· Nov 10, 2024
94/100
Two Burgs and a NY Port (Le Quai Bistrot Français, Waterford, NY) : Pop and pour. Gorgeous Gevrey right at peak. Great harmony and balance with a long complex finish. Lots of red fruit and spice. Elegant.
2005 vintage
Taster #8047
· Nov 4, 2024
Corked.
2005 vintage
Taster #6326
· Oct 28, 2024
93/100
Perhaps nearing the end of its best life, but quite nice now. Somewhat to my surprise, it didn't fade quickly but was actually better an hour after pouring.
2005 vintage
Taster #3682
· Jul 21, 2024
91/100
Dark garnet, translucent. There is a lot of extract here. Black cherry and plum, mineral, limestone note, somewhat muffled to start but the nose cleared up after about an hour. Intense palate with ripe plentiful tannins , charred wood, and acidity to balance the sweet fruit. Moderately long finish. This wine has everything it should have but little awkward at the moment. Needs more time, likely a decade or more to become exciting. I expect I would score higher in …
2005 vintage
Taster #0067
· May 26, 2024
93/100
I thought this was a very nice bottle, so maybe 20 years is just about right for the 2005 vintage.
2005 vintage
Taster #1249
· Mar 6, 2024
92/100
A very serious, old school Faiveley before the change in winemaking. Tough as nails but some great stuff under there. My only worry is if there is enough fruit to hold up to the immense tannic structure. Lay down for a while.
2005 vintage
Taster #7780
· Nov 8, 2023
91/100
Earthy but somewhat subtle aromas, woods, pine, wild berries; silky smooth mouthfeel with resolving tannins and nice medium lift in the end; in good shape but I think this wine was never a blockbuster. 91+ At Petit Trois w/Stf, with trout amandine and the big mec.
2005 vintage
Taster #6991
· May 21, 2022
94/100
Drank the second bottle and wow what a difference! Double decanted for ~4 hours. Dark red color, pure and we’ll balanced. I wish I had another bottle ! Drinking very well now with a good long decant, has years to go still.
2005 vintage
Taster #8736
· Apr 26, 2022
90/100
Great nose, definitely showing terroir. On the palate it feels austere however. The grip is angular and the fruit feels unripe. Surprising for the vintage. I think the tannins will polish with some additional time but not sure if the fruit will linger. Only time will tell.
2005 vintage
Taster #2644
· Apr 26, 2022
94/100
Last night's dinner with my wine group included the 2005 Faiveley Gevrey-Chambertin Les Cazetiers. It was opened, but not decanted for an hour before pouring. Elegant with a long finish, notes of orange peel, and red cherry, A beautiful nose. Enjoyed by everyone. WS's review mentioned smoke-laced fruit, which none of us picked up.
2005 vintage
Taster #6991
· Apr 13, 2022
88/100
May have been an improperly stored bottle? The wine was attenuated and had a dry brief finish. Oddly enough it had a wonderful burg nose but the fruit was gone and it tasted over the hill! I have another bottle ( unfortunately it’s from the same source ) so I’ll give it a try too.
2005 vintage
Taster #0067
· Apr 1, 2022
91/100
Popped'n poured - first of six bottles. I thought this still rather tight and in need of more time, although promising.
2005 vintage
Taster #4807
· Aug 18, 2021
95/100
[from half bottle]
2005 vintage
Taster #8047
· May 6, 2020
93/100
Opened and left standing for 4 hours before pouring this remains a typically firm yet expressive 2005. In the glass it revealed a deep cherry red colour and a nose of dark cherry, redcurrants, strawberry and rose with some touches of truffle and forest floor. The palate was medium weight with lovely fruit richness and poise that led into a fine tannin finish with good persistence. There was a lovely touch of rose and strawberry that lifted the palate and …
2005 vintage
Taster #6388
· Feb 19, 2020
dark ruby. slightly sweaty, medium fruit with earthy and orange peel fruitcake. I remember (without the benefit of notes) that this was lighter tasting and more high toned about 5-6 years ago, but now seems more settled and savory. Although this is a good bottle of Burgundy, I just don't think these Faiveley's are worth the money, and in my opinion, trade off their Grand Cru reputation. I have yet to be impressed by this producer. The fruit doesn't seem …
2005 vintage
Taster #8047
· Jan 20, 2020
93/100
A Lost Cellar Wine and a delicious surprise this 2005 Faiveley was initially quite closed and obdurate yet with time it revealed a deep cherry red colour and a nose of dark cherry, redcurrant, strawberry and rose with some touches of truffle and forest floor. The palate was medium weight with lovely fruit richness and poise that led into a fine tannin finish with good persistence. This is a lovely 1er Cru that reflects both the quality of the year …
2005 vintage
Taster #6653
· Dec 28, 2019
91/100
dark fruit and forest on the nose, delicate tannins that indicate that it would keep for at 10 years more. Dark fruit and cedar. lovely balance between fruit and tannins.
2005 vintage
Taster #7780
· Nov 29, 2019
90/100
Dark, somewhat austere, dried out leather, dark fruit, dusty earth; this was hard on the palate, rustic ample tannins, lacked elegance but good with skirt steak at the Audrey at the Hammer. Decent, but disappointing fo this level.
2005 vintage
Taster #7495
· Jan 27, 2008
Austere, acidic, no.
2005 vintage