Yarra Yering, Dry Red No 1, Victoria
Yarra Yering · Victoria › Australia
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92
/100
Reviews
33
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
4444
Reviews
92.2
Avg Score
97
Highest
Taster #4210
· Jan 23, 2026
93/100
Juicy red and black fruits with fine grained tannins. Herbaceous with cherries and plums. Fantastic wine which needs time
2019 vintage
Taster #7565
· Aug 13, 2025
Peter Bourne - Supper (Bibo Wine Bar, Darlinghurst) : Red over black fruits, slight caramel notes, herbaceous note shows mint with time, sweet spice, cedar, tiny alcohol prickle. Juicy tends to medium plus intensity acidity, red over black fruits, a little tart, alcohol warmth, lean for me, silky tannins are integrated and have a touch of rasp on the finish, quite red hued fruit dominate. Not really my bag.
2019 vintage
Taster #8644
· Mar 25, 2025
94/100
I thought this would be well past it's prime but boy was I wrong. It held its structure beautifully with silky fine tannins a medium acidity but quite a thin body without being watery in any sense. On the nose was leather, and a red and black fruit bouquet with a little green stemminess. Red and black fruits were found on the pallette too with candied raspberries blackberries and some vanilla. Honestly outstanding and surprising for its age.
1995 vintage
Taster #8644
· Nov 25, 2024
96/100
Beautiful length. Juicy fresh berries. Let breathe for about an hour and got better over time so will let the next bottle breathe for longer
2019 vintage
Taster #6505
· Jul 14, 2024
92/100
Wow!!! What some extra time in the bottle does. Ox-blood in color. Full bodied. Pak, all spice, hunts of eucalyptus, dark fruit of the nose. Perfectly balanced. Unctuous. Longish finish. Tastes likenthe nose. Thisnwine is absolutely brilliant. It's in the zone now. Drink or hold up to three years. Smash burgers on the grill for dinner
2011 vintage
Taster #7565
· Jul 2, 2024
Cellartracker in the flesh with VinTomas (Noi Restaurant, Petersham) : From half bottle. Non delineated red and black fruits, sweet spice, cedar, a little herbaceous underpin, close. Juicy, fleshy, tangy, very slightly sour red over black fruit, slightly alcohol warmth isn't too intrusive, cedar, tannins are silky, drying, frit grows with time but remains red dominant. Hmm.
2019 vintage
Taster #7565
· Mar 15, 2024
Friday at the strand (Strand Cellars, Croydon) : Sweet and ripe smelling black and red fruits, sweet oak spice, touch of raspberry compote as well is slightly fruit lozenge and there is a little fresh basil leaf. Juicy, textured grip is slightly drying, fruit as per the nose. Quite pleasant.
2020 vintage
Taster #6505
· Jan 21, 2023
90/100
***See previous notes Decided it was time to check in again. Has balanced out. Tatse profile has integrated but it still has a way to go. I want so much more out of this wine but it's still not delivering. Let's see what the next bottle brings in a couple of years. Steak and twice baked potato dinner. BRITT makes the best potatos. I cooked the steaks. All delicious.
2011 vintage
Taster #5845
· Aug 3, 2022
NobleRottersSydney - Yarra Yering (Fix, St James, Sydney) : {screwcap, 13.5%} CabS, Merlot, Malbec and PV in a 67/15/12/6 ratio. Pure cabernet nose; currants and subtle French oak. A bit raw but classy. Medium weight. Sound cabernet palate, although fairly lean and herb-like. Even palate, medium length finish. Has some potential, yes.
2019 vintage
Taster #3620
· Jun 29, 2022
Yarra Yering Tasting - 2020 vintage (At home) : 60mL tasting bottle. Dense, dark fuchsia. Gentle on the nose but with harnessed power on the palate. Deep, spicy, and dark fruited with blackcurrant, cherry, toasted spices, bay leaf. Showing some new oak influence on the palate, with a gentle floral lift on the finish. Cellar for 12-15 years. Lovely Cabernet.
2020 vintage
Taster #6708
· Jun 21, 2022
Highly perfumed and beautifully balanced. Notes of mint, tobacco, cassis and violets. It is silky of texture, with latent power. It has terrfic presence but is light on its feet and the extremely long finish is carried by perfectly ripe tannins.
2019 vintage
Taster #6147
· May 8, 2022
95/100
The wine looks purple colored. The legs are medium. There is no sediment in the bottle. It smells like violet and raspberry. The body is medium/full. The wine has silky texture. The wine finishes long. The wine has medium acidity.
2020 vintage
Taster #7565
· Nov 28, 2021
Real Review - Top Wineries of Australia (Campbell's store, Circular Quay West, The Rocks, Sydney) : Red over blackcurrant, mint, sweet spice from polished oak, a little red berry and plum. Juicy, fleshy, grippy drying, slightly coarse tannins close down the palate a bit, flavours persist beneath this long. Hmm.
2019 vintage
Taster #3385
· Aug 26, 2021
Day 1, popped and poured: Alluring bouquet of blackcurrants, violets and baking spices. Medium-bodied and with a distinct line of acidity woven in, lively blackcurrant fruit with some smoked meats, polished ribbons of medium-bodied persistent tannins that are ninja-like - sometimes they are in the background, sometimes they creep up on you with a crescendo increase in intensity. Good length. Really wonderful and promising. Pretty approachable at the moment as well.
2019 vintage
Taster #1137
· Jun 24, 2021
95/100
Clear WOTN in Yarra 2019 Virtual Tasting. Structured. Very youthful. Mixed berries but trending darker = a little dry herbs and meats secondary. Medium bodied and firm pronounced tannins. Had that alluring powerful but yet elegant quality. Clearly built to last. (Score is somewhat prospective of course)
2019 vintage
Taster #3448
· Apr 1, 2021
92/100
Mornington & Yarra Valley Trip Jan 2018; 3/31/2021-4/2/2021 : dark plum, black menthe. Beaut stem balance. Very good. actually like this
2011 vintage
Taster #2712
· Mar 2, 2021
97/100
will keep this short as i have written about this wine several times. its just unreal and again last night yet another stunning bottle. In all honesty i thought it was 1 point behind other bottles with just a tad of development and a poofteenth less richness just off the pace but it is pure penny pinching and semantics and only a tosspot like me would be able to see the difference. it was the earlier bottling with the blank …
1985 vintage
Taster #6505
· Dec 8, 2020
89/100
Should have read previous notes. Decanted a couple of hours. ugh. Deep, rich, dark burgundy, full bodied wine Pencil lead, some dark stewed fruit, garden vines Somewhat abrasive. Medium finish. Tastes like the nose. Metallic notes. Cigar box. Reminds me of Palmer BDX. A decent wine but not my style. High QPR (-1pt)
2011 vintage
Taster #7523
· Nov 23, 2020
89/100
Bought at the winery 01/2019...poped and poured Loved the nose, a mix between mature Bordeaux and that typical eucalyptus Aussie touch Palate was not as exciting with not enough fruit and structure to compensate the overwhelming green pepper aromas Overall still a well made pleasant wine (especially considering the vintage) but wouldn't buy again at such expensive price Agree with previous reviews, do not decant
2011 vintage
Taster #2712
· Sep 28, 2020
97/100
well all i can say is yet another simply stunning, rich, decadent, juicy, full bodied, luscious dark berried mouthful of divine Cabernet wine from master Bailey Carrodus. As i have written before Bailey told me this would be immortal and at 35 years and a quick impromptu opening from a bottle sitting base neck or VHS , this was stunning and years to go. it got better and better, fatter and richer with more air. Problem is that is so …
1985 vintage
Taster #0144
· Jul 17, 2020
96/100
Grapenomad's tasting note is pretty much spot on. 2011 was a terrible year for the Yarra, but the team at YY have made a simply outstanding wine. Great structure, well integrated cabernet and good red fruits. I personally would also suggest popping and pouring - don't decant this one lest you get more cabernet coming through.
2011 vintage
Taster #4629
· Jul 4, 2020
91/100
Many say that this the 2011 is not an outstanding vintage, but this to me is the benchmark of Australian Bordeaux blends. I believe that they shine best when vintages are cooler. But maybe that's just me. This was popped and poured, no decanting. Deep garnet in the glass. Complex nose showing aromas of blackcurrant, cranberry, pencil lead, cocoa and a bit of fresh tobacco. Smooth sailing on the palate with tannins still going strong, but ripe and an acid …
2011 vintage
Taster #0157
· Jun 6, 2020
94/100
In a lovely spot. Dark fruits, but swirls of truffle, cigar box and forest floor. Lovely length. Textbook Yarra BB.
2011 vintage
Taster #2712
· Apr 28, 2020
97/100
I remember talking to Dr Bailey Carrodus a year or so before he died about this wine. basically he told me it will be immortal. I think he is right on the money. here it is at 35 years of age and it still hasn't got anywhere near its peak. i still have several bottles an inch into the neck, must have used ripper quality corks, every time i open it i am blown away at the rich dense purple …
1985 vintage
Taster #3123
· Nov 24, 2019
93/100
Cool, calm and collected, this is a true cab; pebbery with a cool aristocratic fruit, immense balance and still that wee bit of ausssie-charm, that one must not forget. Still young and fruitful, but the drinking window has opened. #Lyst
2011 vintage
Taster #5026
· Jul 2, 2019
Return to Aus; 6/23/2019-7/5/2019 (Adelaide, South Australia wine regions, Tassie, Yarra, etc.) : There's definitely a theme of vegetal for all of the wines from this era of the winery with this wine maker. Here it's capsicum (green pepper) and secondary flavors and again a real dearth of the fruit. Not quite as compelling for me.
2011 vintage
Taster #4118
· Mar 30, 2019
89/100
Praelum - AUSSIE (Praelum Wine Bistro) : Nose dominated by elderflowers, grass and fern, and has a savoury palate. Some red fruits on finish
2011 vintage
Taster #5274
· Mar 2, 2019
88/100
Screwcap Pencil lead and oak nose Smooth texture, savoury olive and sage more than fruit. Refreshingly youthful (due to screwcap?), but question if it will ever develop complexity Not an outstanding vintage
2011 vintage
Taster #4197
· Feb 5, 2019
dark burgundy, medium clarity, ruby hue Nose: cassis, plum, tobacco, spice, chocolate, cola, eucalyptus, stem, oak Pal: cassis, plum, tobacco, spice, chocolate, herbs, pine, stem, minerals, cola, oak Feel: medium, full, round Finish: medium T8
2011 vintage
Taster #8047
· Nov 8, 2018
90/100
The 2011 YY No1 has a deep dark crimson colour and a nose of cassis, dark plums, eucalyptus and blackberry leaf. The palate is smooth and full with a touch of eucalyptus that detracts from the classic Cabernet fruit which is somewhat subdued. The finish is quite fine with the overall impact that of a well structured wine but somewhat atypical for this wine.
2011 vintage
Taster #4118
· Oct 21, 2018
90/100
Straits Wines - Wine Fiesta 2018; 10/20/2018-10/21/2018 (The Clifford Pier, Fullerton Bay Hotel) : intense and tannic, with blackberry, pepper, paprika, and earth
2011 vintage
Taster #2693
· Apr 7, 2018
89/100
This had more classic tobacco and dark fruit, albeit with a warmth that doesn't come across as quite Bordeaux or California. Some bloody, iodine elements with time, and it does flatten out a bit from an initially well balanced, mature profile. A solid wine, but time to drink up.
1995 vintage
Taster #1078
· Apr 7, 2018
90/100
Salil does Chicago 4; 4/6/2018-4/7/2018 (Chicago, IL) : This was more impressive to me early on in the evening, and it seemed to taper off towards the end of the night. This is clearly cabernet, but the notes of mint and eucalyptus definitely don't point to it being Bordeaux. Good black fruit on the nose and palate, but the palate seems to taper off a little early on, leaving a little more acid and tannin than there need to be. …
1995 vintage
Taster #9546
· Jul 22, 2017
91/100
Decided to check in on this after a Yarra Yering '15 vintage tasting earlier in the week. This is subtle. Showing some slight development but still primary with Cabernet dominant, followed by the Malbec. In a good place. Very nice but not groundbreaking at this point.
2011 vintage
Taster #4588
· Apr 5, 2017
89/100
Outside the truly outstanding chateaus the stereotypical Bordeaux blend, for me, is an awkward mix that over a few decades has been eclipsed by modern winemakers in the US and in Aus (all in my opinion of course - and to each, there own). So whilst I can appreciate others might want to try their hand at this, it does nothing for me. An Aussie Bordeaux blend is perhaps cerberally interesting, but it seems like a step backward rather than …
2011 vintage
Taster #7138
· Sep 11, 2011
90/100
Excellent taste.
1995 vintage
Taster #1565
· Jun 10, 2009
92/100
Yarra Yering Dry Red No. 1 - The Complete Vertical 1975 to 2006 (The Ledbury, London) : Stalky, peppery, some farmyard pong, grippy tannins, but very fresh and complex, quite enticing. [Apparently the 1985 was recalled by the winery as being sub-standard]
1985 vintage
Taster #1565
· Jun 10, 2009
93/100
Yarra Yering Dry Red No. 1 - The Complete Vertical 1975 to 2006 (The Ledbury, London) : Pepper and nettley fruit, quite bordeaux in style with a bit of cedar, high acid, but loads of fruit - a real beauty. This was from a magnum and so there was plenty more over dinner, where it had got smoother, more vanillin
1995 vintage
Taster #6372
· Jun 10, 2009
92/100
Yarra Yering Vertical- a nose of coffee and peppers. in the mouth some old cherry and bell pepper. medium weight wine with that 70's Yarra acidity. this wine held up well through the evening
1979 vintage
Taster #1565
· Jun 10, 2009
92/100
Yarra Yering Dry Red No. 1 - The Complete Vertical 1975 to 2006 (The Ledbury, London) : Herby nose, moccha, a green streak, light bodied, floaty. We had the remnants at the end of the evening, and it had got more elegant, a beautiful old lady
1979 vintage
Taster #5274
· Feb 14, 2009
91/100
Starting to brown around rim. Berries and cedar on nose, still showing Bordeaux notes, lovely firm tannins
1995 vintage
Taster #4534
· Sep 7, 2006
93/100
Dark ruby red color, again with a bit of bricking, but not much noticeable aging since the last bottle. Nose of mixed spice, maybe a cinnamon sort of thing, black cherry/berry. Tannin still present, but in a good, structured way. Palate matches the nose, with a black cherry jam, herb, tobacco, and mineral components. I am still astonished that this wine is this good - I've got three more left - will drink one a year or so and track …
1995 vintage
Taster #4534
· Aug 30, 2005
94/100
Good golly. I pulled this for no good reason to be a ringer in a '95 Bordeaux tasting. One of the wonderful things about this program is that, as I searched for wines by vintage I noticed that this was also a '95 and decided to pull it, along with a Pichon Baron. Other wines in attendance included La Mission, Lynch Bages, Calon Segur, Beycheville, Leoville Barton, and a Chateau Montelena ringer. So with 6 bords, a great CA wine …
1995 vintage
Taster #5845
· Mar 11, 2001
Auswine offline (Darlinghurst, Sydney) : No ullage. Incredible deep deep red colour with no hint of lightening. Magnificent nose dominated by secondary aromas – cedar, tobacco, and a patina of polished leather over aged blackcurrant fruit. Rich and spicy, a full palate free of holes, powerful and yet subtle, with a long finish. Absolutely delicious, a magnificent wine from an ignored vintage. Wow!
1985 vintage