Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
90
/100
Reviews
8
professional
Vintages
1
1978
Other
90/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
1212
Reviews
90.4
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #2876
· May 23, 2023
92/100
Very dark fruit, mushrooms, forest floor and some nutmeg came out over time. Youthful, creamy almost glossy palate. Great balance. Nice surprise
1978 vintage
Taster #0424
· Aug 18, 2019
Clear edge leading to brick into a ruby core. Dried cranberry, earthy/mushroom, iron and floral elements on the nose. Fully integrated and totally alive on the palate. The iron element lingers on the back end. Good amount of fruit here too. I don’t have a tone of experience with old burgundy, but this was a lovely wine. It’s probably good for another 5+ years but it’s totally great right now.
1978 vintage
Taster #6737
· Nov 24, 2016
91/100
Tasted blind: Very deep color with only slight clear rim; deep spicey yet reticent nose, dark rich fruit; deep and brooding with solid structure; quite good and only getting better as it takes on air. Might seem crazy to some but this will probably be spectacular in 20 year's time. My recent experience with a bottle of their '53 Vosne Romanee Clos des Reas would indicate 25 more years would better suit it.
1978 vintage
Taster #3122
· Apr 30, 2015
87/100
not that good, a bit singular.
1978 vintage
Taster #8370
· Jan 8, 2014
funky on the nose. Shrill on the palate. Not a good wine. Fill looked excellent. I'd have to agree with Meadow's note for this particular bottle.
1978 vintage
Taster #4443
· Sep 20, 2010
89/100
Burgundy vs. Piedmont: 1971, 1978, 1985 (Boka - Chicago IL) : Served blind. Sweet fruit, sweet baking spice. Nice balance, fun flavors, but not particularly elegant.
1978 vintage
Taster #1704
· Jun 30, 2010
90/100
Powerful, masculine, firm structure.
1978 vintage
Taster #5854
· Dec 16, 2009
Vosne Romanee Holiday Dinner (Charlie Trotter's, Chicago IL) : Dark red berries on the nose with powerful spice, and subtle minerality. Masculine, fruit forward palate with a lot of grip on the finish. Very well structured. Sweet baking spice all throughout. The most youthful of the 3 or so I've had of these over the past year.
1978 vintage
Taster #4443
· Dec 16, 2009
88/100
Great Vosne Dinner with Friends (Charlie Trotter's - Chicago IL) : Ripe fruit from beginning to end. Sweet fruit and lots of fun baking spice. Good structure providing backbone, this wine is more fun and enjoyable than either exciting or interesting.
1978 vintage
Taster #2693
· Apr 11, 2009
Dark but amber in color. All secondary flavors at this stage - sous bois, soft spices, and muted red cherry flavors. Soft palate, without characteristic Richebourg power but more subtle in style. Well resolved and ready. Very enjoyable.
1978 vintage
Taster #2659
· May 12, 2008
94/100
The Sorting Table / Glunz Grand Wine Tasting (Webster's Wine Bar - Chicago, IL) : Tasted at the Sorting Table / Glunz event @ Webster's Wine Bar. Gorgeously aged garnet/brown color. The nose is still very lively. Some nice spice with earth and mulled red berries. Palate is elegant and supple. Very nice finish. Excellent balance and acidity. Still some life in this bottle after nearly thirty years. Depth and complexity are stunning with secondary aromas of leather and charred …
1978 vintage
Taster #8238
· May 12, 2008
92/100
A lot of bottle variation based on the 3 tasted. The best one was absolutly delicious. Ripe nose with hint of chocolate, earthy notes, red berries and prunes. Still very good structure, med body with red fruits still very much alive with earthy notes. Very good length with soft tannins.
1978 vintage