Horsepower, Sur Echalas Vineyard Syrah, Walla Walla Valley

Horsepower · Walla Walla Valley › United States of America

Red · Syrah
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
95 /100
Reviews
20
professional

Vintages

No vintages

No vintage-specific entries have been added for this wine.

NV

Community Reviews

25
25
Reviews
95.0
Avg Score
100
Highest
Taster #8770 · Mar 27, 2026
95/100
Wow. Distinct, earthy, leathery - and everything else that's been previously said below. I can attest it's drinking amazingly well now, but my guess is that it has another decade in it. An hour of decanting is needed, but I had fun tracking it for another two hours. A gem of a wine!
2014 vintage
Taster #1334 · Jan 31, 2026
96/100
P&P; final bottle. Rich red and black fruit, tar, leather, maybe a bit of barnyard in there (at first). There is a sweetness here lurking behind the savory that makes this wine so unique and delicious...I just love it! Still lots of runway on this, but it's drinking great right now.
2014 vintage
Taster #1389 · Dec 22, 2025
94/100
The most striking wine one can imagine. Totally alien compared to the typical terrain that we are accustomed to when drinking wine. Most people dislike the first taste. Then somewhere around the 2nd to 5th they start to get curious. And by the 10th there are immersed in layers of umami and leather and funk and earth that make no sense but are totally presence inducing.
2014 vintage
Taster #3476 · Nov 4, 2025
93/100
A little too earthy for me. But does have nice fruit and smooth
2014 vintage
Taster #1389 · Aug 15, 2025
94/100
Elegant, mushroom, umami, dirt, funk, huge length, so unique. Took 3 hours to decant
2014 vintage
Taster #7326 · Jul 6, 2025
Another excellent HP wine with the typical profile. Rocks funk, savory, roasted olives, meat, licorice, herbs, salt. A good amount of black fruit, blackberries on this as well. Silky texture.
2014 vintage
Taster #6503 · Jul 4, 2025
96/100
Layers of delicious dark fruit, herbs, and earth on the nose and palate with a silky smooth texture and resolving tannins on the long finish. Drinking beautifully!
2014 vintage
Taster #1389 · Dec 13, 2024
95/100
If you were used to drinking really fruity straightforward simple red wine, the carafe house wine at a solid Italian restaurant, you may refuse to finish your glass. It is utterly sophisticated, extremely demanding, and fascinatingly layered wine. I enjoy the intellectuality of this wine more than the juice itself. I don’t think I “love” the flavor itself to be honest. 3 hour decant minimum. Nose of mushroom, green pepper, and post season rotting Apple. Opens big and funk forward …
2014 vintage
Taster #7352 · Dec 13, 2024
98/100
One of the most complex wines I’ve ever tasted. Smells pungent with essence of fresh fall fruits and vegetables. Pomegranates and the last fruit crops of summer combined with butter lettuce, spinach, and beets. A hint of cinnamon which is one of the signature scents from the red varietals of the rock region. Upon tasting, front is gradual and smooth. As the flavor grows into a subtle yet powerful finish. Fungal and funky, yet sophisticated. Flavor is complex with essence …
2014 vintage
Taster #0209 · May 25, 2024
95/100
Initial opened: Color is translucent garnet Nose is barnyard, hay, berry fruit, rocks funk but not off putting. Sweet on initial taste, constrained, silky smooth Cherry and tobacco on palette, long finish is green vegetable. Well structured, needs air. Double Decanted and left to let it get air. At 90 min open - it’s opening up. Color has deepened and is more opaque as deeper garnet Nose is fuller prominent leather, tobacco and wet stone, hatch chilli pepper On the …
2014 vintage
Taster #6848 · Mar 24, 2024
Opened 3 hours before drinking, which made a positive difference in the wine. Black raspberry, olive, blood, espresso, iodine, barnyard, and a saline finish. Unmistakeable Rocks funk. Gorgeous and generous with immaculate structure. No rush to drink these, and no problem drinking now with some air.
2014 vintage
Taster #9964 · Oct 12, 2023
100/100
Third time tasting in the past year. Tasted with 2014 Reynvaan Foothills and Stonessence, both great, but this was even better. Opened two hours before pouring, still had some the second night. Still garnet and opaque, with wonderful complex aromas of blackberries, cassis, prominent herbal notes, coffee, and a touch of the roasted meat and bacon, very much a Cote Rotie style. Flavors to match, full-bodied but very round and smooth, with soft tannins in the background. Licorice in the …
2014 vintage
Taster #1334 · May 11, 2023
95/100
Decanted for an hour in the Recanter, then back into the bottle for service. Massive wine, very complex and savory with an underlying sweet fruit component. Really nice and a pleasure to drink. Was even better on day 2, so maybe a longer decant if you pop one soon. Drink now with air - 2034+.
2014 vintage
Taster #9259 · Apr 24, 2023
Decanted this twine more than 24 hours before serving. This was better than some of the other Horsepower Syrahs I've opened. It has a lot of the Cayuse funk but didn't have any of the other off-putting flavors. I am sure this will appeal to those seeking this style. It's not my cup of tea so I am probably not a great review resource.
2014 vintage
Taster #7161 · Nov 18, 2022
88/100
A touch stinky on the nose (which is a good thing). Dark and dense, a bit spicy on the finish. Unique flavor on the palate unlike anything from France or even California. Not my style.
2014 vintage
Taster #9964 · Nov 4, 2022
96/100
To our taste fully mature. Garnet, slightly translucent. Powerful complex nose typical of Cayuse but less pronounced than some of their other syrahs. On the palate very rich, lots of fruit, but very smooth and well-balanced; nice long aftertaste. This should easily last another few years but no real need to age it further. Ric
2014 vintage
Taster #9964 · Sep 29, 2022
96/100
First of this vintage we've tried. To our taste fully mature. Garnet, slightly translucent. Powerful complex nose typical of Cayuse but less pronounced than some of their other syrahs. On the palate very rich, lots of fruit, but very smooth and well-balanced; nice long aftertaste. This should easily last another few years but no real need to age it further. Ric
2014 vintage
Taster #3005 · May 14, 2022
94/100
Method: blind; Grassl 1855 Look: medium garnet with very light bricking Nose: pepperoncini; fennel seed; paprika, sausage, tea leaf, celery salt, fresh dill; great complexity Palate: paprika, dried cherry, black tea, violet, dill, minerality; [forgot to note finish]; dry; medium- body; low tannin; medium acidity Overall thoughts: Super complex, elegant, and balanced. It's a bit light, but still flavorful. I never guess Syrah when I drink Horsepower and always guess the wine is 10+ years older than it really is, …
2014 vintage
Taster #8080 · Jan 21, 2022
95/100
I confess to being puzzled by the dichotomous comments regarding this wine; many find it a huge, dense behemoth while others note how smooth and bright and energetic it is . . . . Followed over the course of 4 hours, the wine changed very little other than a slight attenuation in bouquet. Color/App: translucent light/medium ruby core -> diffuse, light ruby rim. Savoury bouquet of olive tapenade, mix of black and red fruits, roasted meat and a bit of …
2014 vintage
Taster #6047 · Jan 19, 2022
96/100
This wine is phenomenal. Mushroom, wood and somewhere between black and red fruit on the nose. This all follows to the palate with a bit more earth and spice. Long finish. Very Cayuse-esque but still it’s own thing.
2014 vintage
Taster #5630 · Dec 3, 2021
94/100
Rich, delicious, intense blackberry fruit with meaty flavors, excellent structure, long finish
2014 vintage
Taster #7249 · Oct 19, 2021
95/100
You have to give this lots aeration time….6+ hours minimum
2014 vintage
Taster #6521 · Jul 4, 2021
95/100
The nose is absolutely insane and it melds with a medium bodied, rich palate and a concentrated finish. Smoke, blackberry, oil, black licorice, a bit of leather, a hint of menthol and dark chocolate. This is not a wine for wimps.
2014 vintage
Taster #5317 · Jun 12, 2021
ESTG pandemic breaker : This was a tough gearshift from the starters for me. Very, very Cayuse on the nose, very animal Syrah in that reductive way. The palate is dark, intense, smoky, but actually surprisingly light and energetic.
2014 vintage
Taster #0634 · May 15, 2021
Oh baby this stuff is electric. Elegance and power wrapped up in one gorgeous package. Super bright cranberry and strawberries. Slightly wild but done damn perfectly. Love this. Tannin is soft but supple and the acid is alive. No idea how this wili age but who cares when it's drinking so stunningly right now. Two thumbs way up!
2014 vintage