Jacques-Frederic Mugnier Nuits-Saint-Georges 1er Cru Clos de la Maréchale

Jacques-Frederic Mugnier

Other · Pinot Noir
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92 /100
Reviews
19
professional

Vintages

1
2011 Other 92/100
Pinot Noir
NV

Community Reviews

25
25
Reviews
91.8
Avg Score
96
Highest
Taster #9055 · Mar 27, 2026
91/100
Really very nice indeed! Such a great wine maker. This is subtle, light, elegant: though the fruit is present enough to bring everything into balance. On the red fruit (to use the jargon)…. slightly developed nose, though still fresh, with just a hint of bell pepper. This is not really very green at all for a green year…. just a nice hint. Shame it’s my last bottle.
2011 vintage
Taster #1204 · Feb 1, 2026
Tasted over 2 hrs -nearly semi-translucent med red mild bricking -low-key black cherry with a hint of sweet funky sous bois wet stone -med acidity, med weight black cherry red apple peel earthy dusty med tannins leave a complexity-adding bitter residue -nice marriage of burly NSG and delicate Mugnier, quite good on its mature plateau, my guess is this bottle would do well for another 4-5 years before starting to decline
2011 vintage
Taster #3423 · Nov 26, 2025
91/100
That juicy primary primacy you get from Clos de Maréchale with the start of some herbal tertiary notes. But the palate lacks the weight to evolve much further so I would drink up.
2011 vintage
Taster #9148 · Oct 4, 2025
92/100
Starting to show tertiary, stewed fruit notes. Interestingly the tertiary notes diminished a bit with time and air, and the primary/secondary flavors strengthened. Still with nice structure and balance, and quite enjoyable. The tertiary transition has occurred in the last 2-3 years, since the last of these I opened. Drink up.
2011 vintage
Taster #3971 · Sep 15, 2025
90/100
From magnum. Slightly funky and reductive on opening. Solid showing but slightly thin.
2011 vintage
Taster #9272 · Aug 12, 2025
90/100
very nice but little more funk then i wanted--maybe it needed more than 45mins to blow off? also a little more tart on the palette than i wanted, but behind the initial funk on the nose the bouquet came thru and it was solid paired with duck a l'orange. acidity was good and definitely drinking well, structured and integrated.
2011 vintage
Taster #9206 · Mar 24, 2025
93/100
Popped and poured. After 15 minutes this comes to life. Beautiful floral nose. The wine is medium bodied, red fruited, showing earth and mineral notes, transparent and elegant. No hint of greenies. Drink at peak now.
2011 vintage
Taster #3128 · Feb 19, 2025
92/100
Old school burgundy, great freshness combined with decent fruit, especially considering the vintage and age. Ethereal style. Drinking really well right now. A food friendly wine that is not being "showy" with light bitter notes on the finish but still in balance (Half bottle at Noize)
2011 vintage
Taster #3552 · Jan 3, 2025
91/100
Nose: pepper, red fruits, rose, roast meat, sesame, smoke Notes: 13% ABV. This is a delightful wine with an excellent mix of notes. Although there appears to be a slight greenness at the end of the palate but overall this shows a very complex and sophisticated nose. The greeness is perhaps quite consistent with my last bottle of the same wine thus I believe this might have been the vintage effect of 2011. Perhaps my last bottle had a bit …
2011 vintage
Taster #0313 · Sep 24, 2024
96/100
Drinking at its peak now with many years to come. Pronounced nose intensity with notes of red fruits, cherry, strawberry, toast, spices, flora. Medium acidity and medium tannin. The wine is of outstanding quality. Especially on the nose. Finish is medium+. Should drank now to enjoy.
2011 vintage
Taster #9401 · Jul 13, 2024
91/100
Opened at Ye Shanghai in HK. Served from magnum, P&P. No extensive notes taken but really enjoyable and classically Mugnier. Red fruit, elegant, lifted, and not discernably NSG. No barnyard funk which sometimes comes through in his bottles, and performing better - despite the weaker vintage - than the 2016 I had a few weeks before. Very happy to enjoy this and thanks to R for sharing!
2011 vintage
Taster #3552 · Jun 19, 2024
92/100
Notes: 13% ABV. This is elegant and fine with a seductive nose and a clean palate. This has a beautiful strawberry aroma that exists only in top Burgundies and the wine is showing extremely well. I haven't had much of Mugnier's Marechale before and this is certainly surprising to me on a highly positive side. If tasted blind I do not believe anyone would call this to be a Nuits Saint Georges. A bit of greenness on the palate but …
2011 vintage
Taster #6278 · Jan 1, 2024
94/100
Took to Pastis miami Late dinner with BB A big elegant wine No formal tasting notes but the wine showed beautifully with no decanting Much improved from my previous bottle in a great spot now.
2011 vintage
Taster #5403 · Dec 28, 2023
92/100
Overtly floral and ripe notes of strawberry and cherries. Opens up on the palate after an hour. This is lovely stuff and improved in the glass. Paired ever so nicely with Otto white truffle linguine.
2011 vintage
Taster #8690 · Nov 19, 2023
A very lovely wine by an iconic producer. First bottle ever of any Mugnier and first also for this climat for me. Ordered this from the list of a restaurant, and this was supposedly slow ox’d for 30 to 40 mins without a decant. It was actually ready to go. One noticeable thing is that the fruit fades very fast in the glass if there’s 1/3 of a pour remaining, so in order to keep the fruit aromas, the wine …
2011 vintage
Taster #5187 · Aug 17, 2023
Quick notes while drinking with a friend. Opened and let slow ox for an hour. The color had some nice bricking. On the nose, dried red fruit, pomegranate, floral, baking spice, and mushrooms. No greenness of the 2011 vintage detected. Palate: spice, med acidity, med tannins, and well balanced. Drinking beautifully right now. Corked this in 55degree F cooler and came back to it 4 hours later after going to dinner, and it went dead. It became thin and lean. …
2011 vintage
Taster #1674 · Jul 7, 2023
93/100
This was drinking very well. Gamey nose and dark red fruit and dark orange notes. I would have liked a bit more finesse but a lovely red burg in its midlife.
2011 vintage
Taster #5915 · Jul 1, 2023
92/100
Here are my basic notes since I wasn't really focusing on the wine much. Earthy and mushroomy when first opened. Not much fruit. After an hour or so the fruit started to appear and helped the wine come together. This is drinking pretty well right now. Typical Burgundy, paired really well with a filet topped with foie gras and red wine demi.
2011 vintage
Taster #6171 · Jun 2, 2023
Amazing and kicking right now but with lots of structure too. Lots of spice and character. Youthful.
2011 vintage
Taster #7971 · Mar 21, 2023
91/100
The wine was earthy with a hint of farmyard on the nose. On the palate - beautiful fruit balanced with great acidity. Delicious! Doesn’t have the complexity of Grand Cru but in such a great spot now I will happily drink this every day.
2011 vintage
Taster #9318 · Jan 22, 2023
Clos de la Marechale Vertical (Decatur, GA) : A nose not too far from the 2004, some herbal green notes, meaty beef broth character, iron, still some juicy fruit; grippy and powerful on the palate, still better than the '04 & '07, young and may improve still; interesting.
2011 vintage
Taster #0763 · Jan 21, 2023
93/100
Pnp. Probably near the peak now and can be enjoyed over the next couple of years.
2011 vintage
Taster #7972 · Jan 9, 2023
90/100
The one with Frederic Mugnier (Les Amis) : Mugnier dinner at Les Amis with Frederic Mugnier Bouquet opened with cola cherry, raspberries, violets, some earth and a very light touch of dried red fruit. Slightly restrained showing some rusticity and a touch of greenness from what felt like stems. Palate showing glimpses of richness with good balance but I thought it lacked a bit of that complexity today and felt a bit "watery and airy". Alone it lacked a bit …
2011 vintage
Taster #0637 · Oct 8, 2022
Pop and pour. About 2 years since my last btl. Wow, stunning now.. Cola, soft nuits earth and game, dried raspberry and wild strawberry, perfume for days. On the palate: fantastic acidity, a touch thin, but somehow simultaneous denser on the finish, which shows loads of spice, strawberry.
2011 vintage
Taster #9401 · Sep 15, 2022
91/100
Opened at the Landmark Mandarin in HK. P&P and enjoyed over several hours. No extensive notes taken, but quite structured and took a bit of time to properly express itself. Mugnier elegance but not at the same level as his Chambolles. Decent drinking window, just let it breathe a little bit. Good mix of red and darker fruit. I look forward to tasting later vintages in a few years as the old influences of Faiveley's management is slowly phased out, …
2011 vintage