Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
93
/100
Reviews
3
professional
Vintages
1
2016
Other
93/100
Pinot Noir
NV
Community Reviews
33
Reviews
93.0
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #6720
· Sep 13, 2025
94/100
This wine shows what California’s extreme West Coast can do. Color is beginning to fade ever so slightly, and the acid normally present early on in Peay’s wines has leveled out and integrated with fruit that is still very much alive. Very well made wine
2016 vintage
Taster #9724
· Dec 31, 2023
94/100
Color and aroma are excellent, tartness comes through, complex, short finish. This wine seems to be aging well. I'm going to keep the last two and see what happens longer term. I've had some 10+ year old Scallop Shelf and that was worth the wait. In theory this should be even better over time.
2016 vintage
Taster #9724
· Apr 14, 2021
91/100
Nose better than the Scallop Shelf from this estate. Lighter style, similar to Scallop Shelf, with some extra tartness. Its solid but for the money, not a big improvement over the Scallop Shelf at close to double the cost.
2016 vintage