Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92
/100
Reviews
12
professional
Vintages
1
1994
Other
92/100
Merlot
NV
Community Reviews
1313
Reviews
92.0
Avg Score
94
Highest
Taster #8053
· Mar 29, 2026
92/100
Cherry nose. Peak.
1994 vintage
Taster #2453
· Sep 17, 2025
92/100
Still very much alive. Enioyed by the bottle at Compagnie Flatiron in NYC. Aged Napa just hits different. This has a shocking amount of acidity to it, given the age. Also, beautiful color! No VA at all, just did a splash decant for sediment, but PnP would be totally fine with about five minutes of air before pouring. I still get nice fruit, with dried blueberry, dark cherry, alongside dried herbs, but also some cedar and forest floor with mushroom. …
1994 vintage
Taster #0332
· Jun 15, 2017
92/100
Nose of black cherry, plum, saddle leather, and hint of briar, same on the palate, medium/big body, delicious tasting, some qualities of old Pomerol, mouth filling fruit, elegant tasting, easy to sip and enjoy, slightly past its prime but my $30 buy years ago makes me wish for more, 1994 was truly a great Napa Vintage, and a lovely, flavorful, long finish.
1994 vintage
Taster #2546
· Feb 21, 2014
92/100
From magnum - bricking medium dark red violet color; mature, redolent, tobacco, dried mushroom nose; tasty, mature, tobacco, dried mushroom, tart currant palate; medium-plus finish (98% Merlot, 1% Cabernet Franc, 1% Cabernet Sauvignon; 13.6% alcohol; 17 months in 70% ne French oak)
1994 vintage
Taster #1112
· Feb 21, 2014
all horse saddle, old leather on nose but absolutely crazy good on palate, incredibly smooth,velvet-like tannins with a perfectly matching acidity, more earth than fruit overall
1994 vintage
Taster #3399
· Nov 20, 2013
90/100
Drank at Duckhorn dinner. Decent, but did not really seem to hold up that well. Quite light and not much fruit left on it. Nice perfumie nose. Really light. Hints of cherry flavor. Nothing that really wow'd me though.
1994 vintage
Taster #4290
· Nov 18, 2013
93/100
Drank from a 6L bottle. Very tasty and still very much alive. Great nose, loaded with dark fruits, cherry, plush and juicy on the palate - almost like canned fruits syrup. Very soft and smooth. Balance is there. Elegant. Just a great Merlot with nice age on it. This has held up wonderfully.
1994 vintage
Taster #2187
· May 23, 2011
91/100
Garnet, fades at edges to slightly brick color. Nose of black fruit, blackberry and eucalyptus. With moderate alcohol and medium + acidity this wine has aged well. Tannins are fine & well integrated. Palate is complex with a slight vegetal note. This is at peak now but shows no signs of fading- will hold 3-5 years more.
1994 vintage
Taster #8391
· May 22, 2011
92/100
Nice color! Rich, dark garnet with slight bricking at edges. Nose quite reticent at first, but as wine warmed from cellar temperature, the nose opened up nicely to reveal blackberry, cedar, eucalyptus and a little citrus. On the palate, excellent fruit, dusty tannins and lots of acid - which make for a long, tasty finish. The wine is certainly NOT over the hill, and has possibly another 5 years of life left in it.
1994 vintage
Taster #2309
· May 14, 2010
93/100
Didn't seem to have as much left as previous bottle, but still holding up really well. Great complexity, with fruit, vegetable, and floral notes.
1994 vintage
Taster #2309
· Nov 8, 2009
94/100
Held up beautifully. Had that lavendar, rose petal, flavor that I like in Merlot.
1994 vintage
Taster #8791
· Jan 29, 2007
90/100
Had it last night, thought it might be to late to still enjoy this bottle. Was surprised, smooth with not to much spice, thick dark color, and pretty tasty.
1994 vintage
Taster #6965
· Feb 13, 2005
93/100
Reminds me why the Howell Mtn is one of my favorite merlots. Great spice, long finish, still holding up great.
1994 vintage