Siduri, Pinot Noir Pisoni, Santa Lucia Highlands
Siduri · California › Santa Lucia Highlands › United States of America
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
91
/100
Reviews
75
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
9696
Reviews
90.6
Avg Score
97
Highest
Taster #8604
· Feb 15, 2023
84/100
There’s quality fruit in this wine, although maybe less ideal than what the winemaker was hoping for. But the pedigree is there. However, I just wish they didn’t have to go and try to make it better. I wish they had just let it be. Because now there’s a doctored up quality to this wine that I don’t really love. Pretty cherry and mapled fig on the nose. The palate is a bit to saccharine and synthetic for my tastes.
2006 vintage
Taster #8604
· Dec 9, 2022
82/100
Cranberry, pomegranate, cola, and earth on the nose. The palate suffers from the unintegrated acid additions. Simple caramel notes of ripe plum.
2006 vintage
Taster #7088
· Mar 13, 2022
92/100
The color is garnet red and showing signs of a mature wine. The nose is lush and seductive with notes of ripe strawberry, cola, and spice. The palate is soft and acidic with firm tannin on the finish. This is drinking really well right now. Why wait?
2006 vintage
Taster #7456
· Dec 30, 2021
88/100
Opened and poured. Wifey says good. Smokey campfire charred embers. Braised hoisin notes. Neutral-ish palate with dark red notes and bruised strawberry notes. Fairly resolved at this point, but solid. Was expecting something more spectacular for the price point and special naming.
2006 vintage
Taster #7229
· Dec 22, 2021
93/100
Youthful still, and quite substantial. 14.1ABV with oak needing a few more years to integrate & soften the fruit. Delicious, not overly complex, rich & dark black/blue fruits. Nice match with med rare duck & lamb tonite.
2006 vintage
Taster #8604
· Sep 8, 2021
85/100
Slow oxygenated for 6 hours. Notes of black cherry, cola, fig, and black tea. A little heavy handed on the palate, with a kick of heat.
2006 vintage
Taster #4347
· Nov 18, 2017
92/100
Deep, mature fruit, balance of fruit, acid, tannins. Still dark, just about right in 2017.
2006 vintage
Taster #4839
· Nov 19, 2016
92/100
Lean, refined.
2006 vintage
Taster #7229
· Apr 9, 2016
93/100
Dark, abundant black & blue fruit, just enough ripe stem, subtle acid and appropriate tannin.... fully mature, I think, with fruit gathering minor characteristics of decline. Recommend drinking within 2-4 years if well stored.
2006 vintage
Taster #2825
· Feb 28, 2016
93/100
Still delicious. Too bad it's the last bottle. Still a bit 'smokey' though.
2006 vintage
Taster #3340
· Jul 24, 2015
89/100
Nose was almost non existent and light bodied. Expected more, but I think it might have been past it's prime.
2006 vintage
Taster #2956
· Dec 9, 2014
14.1% alcohol. This has developed beautifully. It's very refined and quite elegant. Pretty red cherry color with slight bricking at the rim of the glass. Lively nose of red cherry, black cherry, funk, earthiness, and brown spice. Very lively in the mouth, with tasty, lightly tart cherry fruit, a background hint of cherry pie, good acidic backbone, and a juicy, very good finish. This has really filled out nicely. A terrific bottle. A-
2006 vintage
Taster #2825
· Aug 21, 2014
91/100
A bit 'smokey' at first then very good.
2006 vintage
Taster #5056
· Jul 7, 2014
89/100
Red cherry, cola, vanilla. Still has a bit if life. Not much change over several evenings. Short finish or it would have been 90+.
2006 vintage
Taster #6503
· Mar 16, 2014
93/100
Started out a bit awkward but smoothed out beautifully with a bit of air. Paired nicely with Thai cuisine.
2006 vintage
Taster #1510
· Nov 16, 2013
93/100
Ruby colored; slight yellowing on the rim; appears unfiltered and unfined. Abundantly complex aromas of cherry, strawberry, rose blossoms, earth, lots of herbs (sage, basil, etc). Flavors of cherry, strawberry, herbs and spice. Rich, full bodied and yet seemingly delicate. Not as big and powerful as it was 16 months ago; seems more refined. Smooth and velvety in the mouth. Excellent balance. A long and extended finish. Drinking at its apogee now.
2006 vintage
Taster #6256
· Feb 4, 2013
93/100
A fabulous wine. Decanted for about an hour but don't even think it was necessary.
2006 vintage
Taster #2994
· Jan 28, 2013
90/100
Great example of 'big' new world pinot that features dark cherry almost meaty fruit, cola, vanilla and a little spice. Palate has medium + intensity fruit that is amazingly in balance given how sweet and lush it is. Decent acidity and structure. Not really complex. I'm sure this will appeal to those that like the big Cali pinot style as it has few faults and is certainly rich and delicious. However, its lack of brightness, tension, mineral and finesse pulls …
2006 vintage
Taster #7099
· Jan 20, 2013
Garnet. Leggy. Cherry and red fruit nose. Cherry, spice, and leather and a reasonable mouthfeel. No better than a year ago, but nice.
2006 vintage
Taster #2932
· Nov 10, 2012
89/100
Opened and drank over 2+ hours. Lovely fresh fruit on the nose. Started out a bit thin, a little tart, but with a good base of red fruit and cherries, then developed more complexity and structure over time. The best glass was the last.
2006 vintage
Taster #9453
· Nov 3, 2012
91/100
Decanted 2 hours. Rich nose of strawberry preserves, red fruit, and funky baking spices with a touch of vanilla. Initially smooth on the palate but gains intensity with red fruit, oak and acidity in pretty good balance. Lingering cleansing finish. This is in a better place than my last bottle 2 years ago.
2006 vintage
Taster #5733
· Nov 2, 2012
91/100
Pop and pour. Very light color, red cherry and faint strawberry on the nose. Red fruit, mild tartness; not much weight but with structure that builds mid-back palate to give this more of a finish than one expects. This is ready to drink , and I'm not sure that I'd bank on age adding to the complexity of this.
2006 vintage
Taster #7602
· Sep 28, 2012
Did not take notes, but this was really terrific. Leaner, firmer and with a darker fruit profile than I expected. Big enough to match well with a lamb T-bone steak. I will not score, but probably would have given it a 91.
2006 vintage
Taster #9134
· Sep 4, 2012
97/100
huge big nose: flowers, red fruits, semi sweet chocolate taste - big bright red flavors, colas, great integrated tannins, this stuff just fills your mouth with big fruit flavors and keeps going. even better than when we had it in 2010. you could probably hold this wine for 10+ years. so much complexity. nice long 45 second finish. bravo Adam!
2006 vintage
Taster #7099
· Aug 12, 2012
Corked. Cherry and red berry underneath, but pretty distasteful.
2006 vintage
Taster #1510
· Jul 17, 2012
94/100
A medium ruby color; appears unfiltered and unfined. Spectacular wine for me. It has highly complex aromas of cherry, strawberry, rose blossoms, earth, and lots of herbs (sage, basil, maybe a touch of anise seed). Cherry, strawberry, herbs and spice flavors. Rich and full bodied, in a pinot noir realm. Also has great balance. A long and lingering pinot noir finish. Siduri pinots sometimes have noses that can really throw you off in a blind tasting (Cargasacchi is one example). …
2006 vintage
Taster #6503
· May 31, 2012
92/100
As delicious as the last bottle, but with more wonderful earthy notes on the nose and palate.
2006 vintage
Taster #7099
· May 4, 2012
Garnet. Leggy. Cherry and red fruit nose. Cherry, spice, and leather and a satisfying mouthfeel The finish is longer, more weighty, and surprisingly sensual by comparison to my last bottle 6 months ago. This is improving, and I'm glad to have many bottles left. Something's happening here.
2006 vintage
Taster #6503
· Apr 30, 2012
92/100
Similar tasting notes to previous bottle.
2006 vintage
Taster #9562
· Mar 26, 2012
Strongly earthy on the nose and a bit on the palate. Weighty fruit but not really showing a lot of extraction. Strong blackberry and dark cherry. There is a bit of a bite on the back end that lingers over two nights but only a wee bit of heat. The earth recede on the second night but not completely leaving it to add complexity. The complexity picks up on the second night as the fruit relaxes and lets some secondary …
2006 vintage
Taster #5733
· Jan 14, 2012
90/100
Notes basically mirror those of rickspicks. Very drinkable, shows some depth through all its softness, and should last another 1-3 years.
2006 vintage
Taster #0575
· Dec 10, 2011
92/100
Very nice wine. Aromatic and dark in the glass. Strong cherry component with a hint of sweetness but has enough acid to make a dry finish. A nice lengthy finish. A really strong effort.
2006 vintage
Taster #4956
· Oct 19, 2011
90/100
Tasted alongside other 2006 Pisoni vineyard wines. Not as well structured as the Pisoni Estate Pinot of the same year, or even Lucia for that matter. This vintage didn't wow me as well as other vintages of Siduri Pisoni that we've had. Some dark berry fruit, pomegranate, a little earth at the finish. If this were $20 cheaper, I'd have been delighted. But . . .
2006 vintage
Taster #7602
· Oct 11, 2011
Didn't take notes, but this was a typical Siduri pinot - fruit forward & plush. Lots of cherry and strawberry with soft edges. Goes down very easily and overall is very enjoyable. Will not score as I don't recall enough details.
2006 vintage
Taster #5533
· Oct 8, 2011
93/100
HERBAL NOSE WITH CHERRIES AND SPICE AND A FLAVOR TO MATCH. LONG FINISH.
2001 vintage
Taster #7099
· Sep 25, 2011
Popped and poured. Brownish garnet and translucent. Red cherry and juniper nose. Red cherry, strawberry, and juniper with a moderate, remarkably light (nearly airy) finish. Enough acidity to serve well as a complement to dinner, but ultimately simple. At this price, pinot can be better.
2006 vintage
Taster #4976
· Jul 14, 2011
93/100
My type of Pinot. Lots of dark fruit and spice notes on the nose. The palete has med to big black fruit with herbs and earth tones, and some oak. Nice balance between the acidity and texture.
2006 vintage
Taster #3496
· Jul 13, 2011
88/100
Pinot night at Wave 2700 Very easy to drink. Picked up some forest floor and mushrooms. Flat finish.
2006 vintage
Taster #1510
· Jul 3, 2011
90/100
Similar to my notes of 5-8-11 and 12-10-10. As the wine warmed and settled down, aromas of cherry, strawberry, spice. Decent fruit in the mouth. Paired well with a grilled kabob containing organic chicken, at a friend's house. Rating 90-91.
2006 vintage
Taster #1510
· May 8, 2011
91/100
Much the same as my notes of 2/10/10. Cherry, strawberry, spice on the nose. Average finish; a little heat on the back palate. The mid-palate is better with food, thus the 91 rating instead of 90.
2006 vintage
Taster #5391
· May 3, 2011
91/100
Consistent with previous notes. Very nice.
2006 vintage
Taster #2994
· May 3, 2011
90/100
PnP. Garnet with violet and slight browning. Forward nose of cherries, strawberry, spice (lots), caramel, earth. Palate has medium body with simple, but flavorful, fruit, little complexity or finesse, spice pops through and some earth on the finish. Soft, but texture ill defined. Decent acidity. Enjoyable; especially the nose.
2006 vintage
Taster #0171
· Mar 31, 2011
90/100
Not decanted.
2006 vintage
Taster #6503
· Feb 3, 2011
93/100
Red cherry and raspberry aromas and flavors with silky texture and hints of earthy notes on the tasty finish. Classic Siduri!
2006 vintage
Taster #1510
· Dec 10, 2010
91/100
Consumed a short time ago. Nice pinot nose. Cherry, spice and some strawberry. drinking nice now and should get better.
2006 vintage
Taster #0171
· Nov 25, 2010
91/100
Not decanted.
2006 vintage
Taster #1875
· Nov 16, 2010
92/100
Big, full bodied pinot but balanced and not cloying. Long finish. Needs maybe another year for full potential.
2006 vintage
Taster #2261
· Sep 19, 2010
91/100
I like this and while its in a good drining window i (as well as others at dinner) found it to be over-oaked--and that oaky "sweetness" detracted from the vived red fruit on the palate. Certain things iliked about it but i prefer a bit more up-front fruit in my "new-world" pinots.......well-made but not in the same class as a williams-selyem for the same approximate $$$$
2006 vintage
Taster #9453
· Aug 14, 2010
90/100
Decanted 2 hours. Cherry/strawberry with funk, oak and a touch of vanilla on the nose. Mouth coating palate with fruit, acidity and oak - nothing really out of balance. Slightly tart, mature stem, oak finish.
2006 vintage
Taster #6463
· Aug 1, 2010
92/100
Birthday Wines (Kruger's D*ck) : Wow, after digging up some old Bordeaux, what a palate shock to get some new world PN. Had in the past and thought it was delicious. A little full bodied PN than I enjoy, however can't take away the fact that it is delicious. Lots of black cherry and berries, spicy midpalate, and soft finish. As rich as a PN this is, shows an elegance that all PN should have.
2006 vintage