Arnaldo Caprai, Montefalco Sagrantino, 25 Anni
Arnaldo Caprai · Umbria › Montefalco Sagrantino › Italy
Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
92
/100
Reviews
39
professional
Vintages
No vintages
NV
Community Reviews
4242
Reviews
92.2
Avg Score
96
Highest
Taster #5085
· Dec 25, 2025
94/100
Fabulous with lasagna and lamb for Christmas lunch
2007 vintage
Taster #4310
· Dec 12, 2024
90/100
5 liter bottle.
2001 vintage
Taster #7742
· Oct 31, 2024
93/100
Barolo night at Oso : Was a bit modern and polished initially. But settled down after 2 hours really well. High toned roses and tar on the nose and plenty of fruit and structure on the palate. Big scaled wine but never overpowering. Enjoyed this a lot.
2001 vintage
Taster #6680
· Oct 31, 2024
91/100
Same bottle as Dibbs. Dark garnet, dark fruit, some used oak, still a fair bit of tannin. mid 2000s. 2006?
2001 vintage
Taster #1839
· Apr 21, 2024
92/100
A fine wine, still fresh and showing the characteristics of age.
2001 vintage
Taster #8960
· Apr 13, 2024
93/100
Even better than last bottle as the tannins are more fully integrated presenting a balanced finish. This big wine is drinking very well.
2009 vintage
Taster #8606
· Jan 6, 2024
Has gone bad.
2001 vintage
Taster #0245
· Jul 30, 2023
94/100
Still in good condition. No decant. Dark color, some brownish edges. Fruity nose. Full bodied wine. Intense bouquet of very ripe dark fruits, blackberries, plum, dark cherries, chocolate, mocca. Thick, viscid texture. Long, silky and intense finish.
2001 vintage
Taster #3864
· Feb 4, 2023
89/100
Funky nose but good in the palate. Needed to breathe for a while. Is this past prime?
2001 vintage
Taster #0836
· Nov 12, 2022
93/100
[Balla Italian Soul Birthday Dinner 11/12/22] Decanted for 30 min. Grippy red fruit, sour red cherry, strawberry, red currant. Tannins are fairly resolved but still quite tight and youthful. Very good wine.
2001 vintage
Taster #9884
· Jul 4, 2022
93/100
50+5+13+17+8=93
2001 vintage
Taster #2268
· May 1, 2022
94/100
Stored at optimal conditions since release. Perfect fill and cork not soaked, but difficult to remove even with Thedurand. Garnet with orange hue in thin layers. By pouring I got an intense note of blueberries first, than plums, lovage, umami, dark chocolate. All without a decant. On the palate medicinal notes, plums, black berries, lovage, leather, tobacci and spices. Still with some drying tannins, but all in all well integrated. The part I decant, was a bit onedimensional with less …
2001 vintage
Taster #0475
· Apr 24, 2022
95/100
My first 25 Anni. Decanted for a couple of hours, w/ lots of sediment. 100% Sagrantino. Deep dark brown w/ thick, glass-staining legs. Developed, w/ pronounced ripe black fruit, black plums, dried red flowers, leather, earth, dark chocolate and well integrated baking spices from 2 yrs in French barriques. Dry, but w/ ample fruit left, med (+) acidity, med (+), chalky tannins and high alcohol (14.5%). Even at 21 years, it is a full-bodied, intensely flavored, tannic beast, w/ a …
2001 vintage
Taster #2455
· Dec 5, 2021
95/100
Rating is after an 8-10 hour decant. Very tight upon opening. Once the tannins and alcohol die down, lovely fruit and earthy notes. Great with stronger flavors like cheese or lamb.
2007 vintage
Taster #7142
· Feb 24, 2021
94/100
Showing the magic of Sagrantino. Beautiful wine with many years to go.
2001 vintage
Taster #0071
· Feb 16, 2021
90/100
Very rich, strong blackberry/ licorice on nose. Great but holding second bottle for another year
2009 vintage
Taster #0747
· Dec 29, 2020
92/100
Smooth and velvety, hints of plum and hazelnuts. Wonderful food wine.
2001 vintage
Taster #8960
· Jun 15, 2019
91/100
A big, bold, very delicious wine. Medium to dark ruby color. Light floral and fruit fragrance, earthy palette and medium finish. The tannins are still rather sharp when first opened but smoothed out nicely after 1 hour decant. Another year or two in the cellar will help.
2009 vintage
Taster #9582
· Oct 23, 2018
93/100
Powerful, tannic. Decanted for 8 hours.
2007 vintage
Taster #8018
· Sep 16, 2018
95/100
This is one fine wine. POP. Very unusual Sagrantino. Warm and smooth. Sweet fruit but not dessert. This is a pair with almost anything wine.
2001 vintage
Taster #1436
· Aug 17, 2018
93/100
Velvety wine smooth tannins plenty of sweet cherries
2001 vintage
Taster #1492
· Dec 25, 2017
95/100
Loved it - great place. With Xmas dinner. No notes.
2007 vintage
Taster #6902
· Oct 8, 2017
92/100
Tannine Monster
2007 vintage
Taster #3628
· Mar 28, 2015
90/100
Deep purple color with a bouquet and flavor of plums and sea salt. Good balance, moderate depth, and a moderate finish. Very pleasant.
2001 vintage
Taster #9358
· Feb 8, 2015
83/100
Oaky oaky oaky. Vanilla and buttery black fruit marred by oak tannins. Could be from anywhere. Boring. Bleh.
2001 vintage
Taster #1892
· Dec 29, 2014
94/100
Totally tannic and unapologetic.
2007 vintage
Taster #4663
· Nov 30, 2014
On my 51 birthday
2007 vintage
Taster #1393
· Nov 16, 2014
88/100
Dark purple, big, tannic monster, and to me over oaked. If I had to guess I would have thought it was a good but modern style Super Tuscan. Jammy plum fruit but mouth drying tannin cuts the finish a bit short. Not sure where this wine will go but I'd rather hold this wine for at least 5 more years than drink it now. Scoring wine as it as opposed to its potential.
2007 vintage
Taster #5402
· Jun 15, 2014
94/100
100% Sagrantino with yields less than one kilo per vine. Aged for an average of 25 months in French oak barriques with an additional 6 months in bottle before release. Deep, inky ruby with brick rim. Complex nose, delightfully layered offering violet scents upfront with plum and cassis followed by medlar, iodine, blood and leather. Deep and firm yet not assertive with velvety tannins an elegant backbone lifted by peppery spice and refreshing acidity.
2001 vintage
Taster #7934
· Feb 15, 2014
90/100
Very big wine, concentrated and smooth, definately Sagrantino. Tasted at Tre Bicchieri. Almost too much wine to ever be really good with food. Need to wait for a few years and see it again.
2009 vintage
Taster #3127
· Jan 18, 2014
91/100
Madonna di Campilio Ski Trip; 1/17/2014-1/19/2014 (Madonna di Campilio) : Still in the young category and requires decanting to develop. A very well made wine of quality and purity. Big and powerful wine, big tannin at this stage and at times showed sharp edges especially on the finish where it had some unbalanced acidity. Judging by the 1996 we had a couple of months ago this wine needs quIte a bit of ageing to develop and this 2001 maybe needs …
2001 vintage
Taster #1901
· Sep 20, 2013
93/100
Dark, with vanilla notes. Big wine, powerful, bold, yet smooth. Youthful, but more approachable than the 2008.
2009 vintage
Taster #7568
· Apr 13, 2013
90/100
OMG or should I rather say OMFG! If you ever thought that a young Chateau Latour is not your thing because it is too feminine and lacks a proper tannic corset, here is your wine! Having attended Bordeaux Primeur tastings for many years and therefore developed a high tolerance for young tannins I cannot believe how outer worldly tannic this wine is. And this despite I knew that Sagrantino is one of the most tannic of all grapes. Honestly, I …
2007 vintage
Taster #4671
· Jan 21, 2013
94/100
A powerful wine. Decanted two hours and more, it showed complex flavors of dark berry fruits, strong minerals and hints of anise. Very full on the palate with good length and some clamping down of tannins in the long finish. Not sure this will improve or just hold, but an excellent wine that went especially good with steak and stood up to an also powerful 1986 Chateau Talbot, which showed magnificently.
2001 vintage
Taster #0402
· May 17, 2012
92/100
bold, well balanced.
2007 vintage
Taster #3143
· Apr 28, 2011
89/100
Full-bodied but not heavy--no noticeable heat. Starts with plum and a little blackcurrant, then the fruit reddens with air. Very soft but throws up a wall of tannin after a while. Smoky and rich. Still primary.
2001 vintage
Taster #7221
· Feb 18, 2011
96/100
Gambero Rosso (Metropolitan Pavilion) : On the nose, this wine was a monster with raspberry, holiday spices and dark forest notes. It verged on sweet but something animal about this Sagrantino, pulled it back to reality. On the palate, a massive wave of concentration was turned fresh by vibrant acidity as blackberry jam, pomegranate, cinnamon and herbs wash across the tongue like silk. The finish showed this wines intimidating structure as velvety tannin coated the mouth. The Arnaldo Caprai 25 …
2007 vintage
Taster #2546
· Feb 16, 2011
90/100
2011 Gambero Rosso Tre Bicchieri Tasting; 2/15/2011-2/16/2011 (Beltramo's in Menlo Park, California, and Fort Mason, San Francisco, California) : Very dark purple red violet color; nice berry, ripe plum nose; tasty, tart berry, tart plum palate; medium-plus finish 90+ points
2007 vintage
Taster #9034
· Feb 11, 2011
94/100
excellent dark fresh fruit, still young with years to go...cherry, berries, pencil, tobacco herbs...high amount of alcohol but still elegant, gentle and subtle...very powerfull...it therefore needs some food...
2001 vintage
Taster #6493
· Jan 6, 2011
Young, opaque and impenetrable. Gorgeous licorice, herbs, dark fruit, raspberry-chocolate before the wall of tannins close in. Unique and promising.
2001 vintage
Taster #2827
· Dec 11, 2010
92/100
Perfect with a pasta dish. Great rustic italian wine. Decanted for a few hours before we drank, but it seemed pretty accessible as I tasted it throughout the two hours.
2001 vintage
Taster #1957
· Sep 26, 2010
93/100
Tannins beginning to mellow. This was fantastic with pasta. Wish I had more
2001 vintage