Critics Average score from professional wine critics and publications.
94
/100
Reviews
9
professional
Vintages
1
2023
Other
94/100
Chardonnay
NV
Community Reviews
1212
Reviews
94.2
Avg Score
97
Highest
Taster #7771
· Sep 6, 2025
93/100
One hour slow ox. Intense light golden color. Lemon and lime rind, Asian pear, and subtle hazelnut. Very smooth, dry, oily palate, with fine, silty acidity. Take my rating with a grain of salt. This had little aeration and my wife (who doesn’t enjoy any white wines) was negatively influencing me. Drank this with owner/winemaker Laura Jones. Terry Richardson and his lovely wife Diane drove us to this Sonoma meet up. Very fun afternoon.
2023 vintage
Taster #0395
· Aug 29, 2025
30 min decant and consumed alongside the other two 2023 Sphaerics releases. This was the brighest of the bunch. White florals, pear, gunpowder, petrol. Some charred wood and burnt sugar aromas as it warms. Pear, citrus and wet stones on the palate.
2023 vintage
Taster #5374
· Jul 29, 2025
96/100
Good friend Agelvis used this one as a 'kickoff' white for our wine group last night.....and mostly to quell Heather's lust for whites! Splash double decant given to this one then enjoyed by everyone (but mostly Heather) til gone! I had previously only had the Overline Chard from this maker and quite enjoyed it. This one is easily on par with that, but yet also a bit different at the same time. Light yellow (pale) in the glass. Nose of …
2023 vintage
Taster #7771
· Jul 28, 2025
94/100
Splash double decant. Pale golden straw color. Lemony vanilla cream, rice cake (the unsweet puffed rice), quince, white pear, and subtle macadamia. Dry, creamy palate, with fine acidity. Mark1NPT felt like the palate had lots of citrus and vanilla. I really enjoyed this, but I think I like the lower cost overline a bit better. I’m visiting them next month.
2023 vintage
Taster #8868
· Jun 15, 2025
Temporary Living and not the best drinking; 1/30/2025-6/15/2025 : Nice but needs more time
2023 vintage
Taster #3727
· Apr 26, 2025
94/100
Rich ripe and round but still maintains nice balance.
2023 vintage
Taster #6134
· Apr 12, 2025
94/100
2023 Sphaerics Lineup (Napa, California) : There is a lovely rounded quality to the tones of Meyer lemons, peaches, nectarines, vanilla beans, some warm dough, poached pears, yellow flowers, and cinnamon spice notes. There is excellent depth that is really attractive and balanced while showing off some poise and stature to the notes. The Medium/full bodied feel has a wider quality whilst showing off the depth and rounded qualities of the nose along with tart, medium+ acidity that shows off …
2023 vintage
Taster #0079
· Apr 6, 2025
86/100
Pale color. Aromatically simple with some melon and floral lift. The palate is hollow without any concentration or longevity, followed by a charry and oaky bitterness from the wood. The finish comes across boozy and high in abv. I was hoping for more at this price.
2023 vintage
Taster #7638
· Mar 9, 2025
97/100
From the pickup party/reception at Brian and Laura’s. I’m going to give this note relatively short shrift, having just written a longer one on Overline and expecting to do so on If and Only If. Like it’s label mates, there’s a defined style here, the richness and creaminessI love about California but with solid frame and lightness of touch on abv and oak giving a really clean and focused feeling. Still with tropical fruit notes, but more citric here balancing …
2023 vintage
Taster #0013
· Dec 26, 2024
Tank Sample. This showed the best of the 3 tank samples. I did all 3 tank samples blind, I called each correctly. The "If and Only If" is more complex but, to me, a Chard that will need 10 years, this wine was in great harmony for a barrel sample. A touch leaner, more my style, with apple, pear, lemon, and a bit more mineral than the others. At the price point, this wine is nuts and a wine that …
2023 vintage
Taster #4566
· Dec 22, 2024
97/100
While the “if and only if” is busy in beast training mode for the 2028 Summer Olympics in L.A., the “on days and nights” is bouncing around and scouting Juilliard and Groundlings, hoping Will Ferrell is going to stumble into some trendy comedy club and discover it laying out its best improv gig. The “on days and nights” is engaging and expressive for such an infant, with a fun-meets-stylish amalgamation of purity, suave balance, “I want some more of that …
2023 vintage
Taster #0842
· Dec 21, 2024
97/100
Tank sample tasted with owners Laura and Brian. Like Overline this drank best when allowed a few hours air. The nose jumps out of the glass here with an eruption of flinty minerals and stone fruit. Mouth coating creaminess that retains freshness with lemon, mineral and slight reduction carrying from front to finish. Ripe stone fruit, crème brûlée, pineapple upside down cake and subtle oak add complexity and length. This drinks more like a ripe burgundy than California. It will …
2023 vintage